The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 5: Squid Game

Hwang Dong-hyuk’s South Korean satire chimed with a massive global audience facing calamitous times

In 2009, Squid Game’s creator Hwang Dong-hyuk got himself deep into debt. When both he and his mother found paid employment impossible to come by, he had to turn to loans to survive. Hwang’s homeland is a desperate society, divided between those working themselves to death and those who, having been made redundant, are trapped in debt. But, in channelling the experience of downtrodden South Koreans into one of the finest TV shows of 2021, he made something whose appeal transcended national boundaries.

We saw 456 debt-riddled contestants selected by a shadowy corporation to volunteer for a real-life gameshow in which the winner goes home with 4.6bn won (£28m) if they survive a series of brutal games, while the losers go home in body bags. In the first episode, contestants could only move when the face of a sinister mechanised doll is turned away from them. Those caught out were mown down with machine-gun fire. As corpses littered the floor and the living congratulated themselves on surviving, this was a drama that encouraged us to follow the logic of capitalism to its extreme by treating everything, including fellow humans, as commodities, as means to ends.

In a world where most of us teeter on the edge of the pit of debt, or are lying in it, Squid Game asked how ruthless we would be given the chance to get out. Would you be a social Darwinist winner, or one of 455 other corpses whose organs are harvested for sale on the black market? Would you, in extremis, resemble the relatable and compassionate loser dad – player 456, Seong Gi-hun – or self-serving venal gangster player 101, Jang Deok-su?

But its appeal also lay in something less high-minded. One reason Squid Game overtook Bridgerton to become Netflix’s most-watched series is that it was edge-of-the-seat drama in which we hardly knew who would be terminated in the next game. That ability to create tension, whereby apparently anything could happen and no character is beyond the bullet, takes storytelling skill rarely seen on TV today. One of the pleasures for me, certainly, was how I was wrong-footed several times when I was sure one character would survive but was killed off. Just as well I didn’t bet on the outcome: like Gi-hun when he gets fleeced at the bookies, I’d be a terrible gambler.

Squid Game wasn’t the first show to put a bunch of people together and have them kill each other to survive for others’ entertainment. But before making Squid Game, Hwang studied fight-to-the-death precursors such as early 00s Japanese film Battle Royale and 2007 TV anime Gyakkyō Burai Kaiji: Ultimate Survivor – then upped the voyeuristic ante to make his version even more grippingly sadistic. When, halfway through the series, a bunch of masked VIPs (most of them, significantly, westerners) pitch up, they bet on who will live and die. They used people as footstools and feasted on banquets behind glass screens that offered fine views of the carnage below.

For me one of Squid Game’s curiosities was that the drama did not play out, as say Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games did, as a TV show (there is no oleaginous Stanley Tucci interviewing survivors about their love lives before they battle to the death). But that’s to miss the point of Squid Game: it was not a critique of media rapaciousness, but of a society gone wrong. Perhaps Hwang, who is now making series two, didn’t want to bite the Netflix hand that fed him.

There have been complaints that the subtitles didn’t give us the full sense of what is being said in Korean. Or that the westerners’ accents were dreadful, and yes some, like basketball star LeBron James, found the ending unsatisfying. Otherwise, though, Hwang delivered what he planned.

“The show is motivated by a simple idea,” he told me. “We are fighting for our lives in very unequal circumstances. During the pandemic, the poorer countries can’t get their people vaccinated, so they are contracting viruses on the streets and even dying. It’s not profound.” But it is, Mr Hwang. Squid Game was an allegory of the world in 2021.


• This article was amended on 20 December 2021. An earlier version misidentified the “self-serving venal gangster player” in Squid Game as player 067, Kang Sae-byeok. The intended reference was to player 101, Jang Deok-su.

Contributor

Stuart Jeffries

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Squid Game’s creator: ‘I’m not that rich. It’s not like Netflix paid me a bonus’
The smash hit survival drama has earned Netflix £650m. But the stress of making it cost Hwang Dong-hyuk six teeth – and he hasn’t been paid any extra. He reveals the family disaster that inspired his hyper-violent capitalism satire

Stuart Jeffries

26, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021
The great telly countdown hits the top spot with a furiously joyful, gut-wrenching five-part drama that was funny and full of life

22, Dec, 2021 @6:03 AM

Article image
Squid Game owes its popularity to anxieties of modern life
It’s the first South Korean drama to top the US Netflix charts and its core message is ‘can I ever repay this debt?’

Zoe Williams

09, Oct, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 2: The White Lotus
An immaculate social satire featuring scabrous character studies, a murder-mystery and a shocking revenge scene

Lucy Mangan

21, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Hellbound: the South Korean death-fest that wipes the floor with Squid Game
The terrifying Netflix show also deals in violent ends – with demonic smackdowns by CGI brutes – but it’s so much more than Squid Game. This is truly exceptional drama that will be spoken about for decades

Stuart Heritage

25, Nov, 2021 @12:25 PM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 9: Starstruck
Rose Matafeo plays troublemaker Jessie in a moreish comedy series that brings joy, heartbreak and meet-cutes with a movie star

Hannah J Davies

10, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 4: Succession
The show’s dark third series gave us what might be its greatest ever run of episodes – and someone to root for at long last

Stuart Heritage

17, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
You’ve seen the gory Squid Game TV show? Now buy the tracksuit…
The hit South Korean Netflix show, likely to become the most-watched TV series ever, is setting trends around the globe

Edward Helmore

10, Oct, 2021 @6:45 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 7: Time
Jimmy McGovern’s prison drama seemed dauntingly bleak but in the end offered glimmers of hope … and some sublime acting by Sean Bean and Stephen Graham

Phil Harrison

14, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2021, No 6: Feel Good
Series two of the exquisite comedy tackled trauma, PTSD and gender identity and still managed to make you feel warm inside

Chitra Ramaswamy

15, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM