Starstruck review – Rose Matafeo’s millennial fairytale

Co-written by the standup and Alice Snedden, this series about a struggling twentysomething who has a one-night stand with a film star is both improbable and rather enjoyable

BBC Three’s new comedy Starstruck is another bauble to add to the small, but precious and increasing hoard of productions effortlessly infused with the particular sensibility that comes with being led by women. You don’t notice how much the rest of your cultural input is informed by the male perspective – it’s been so common, so unchallenged until ridiculously recent times– until something different comes along.

Written by the award-winning comedian Rose Matafeo (who also stars) and the comedy performer and writer Alice Snedden, and directed by Karen Maine (also award-winning), Starstruck is the six-episode tale of twentysomething Jessie (Matafeo). She lives, millennially, in east London – one flatmate, a ninth of a suburban terrace house rented between them, two dead-end jobs and a variously enjoyable series of one-night stands at the weekends. One of them turns out to be with a film star, Tom (Nikesh Patel). At first, she is gobsmacked to discover his real identity and then, as you would be, hysterical. “It’s not going to happen again,” she says to her flatmate Kate (Emma Sidi). “But he can’t take it back!”

Once you are over this slightly improbable premise and a slightly flat first episode while everybody finds their rhythm in this fairytale-inflected Hackney romcom, there is a lot to enjoy.

There’s Matafeo’s performance for starters. Her timing is as immaculate as you would expect from an experienced standup, and her various foot-in-mouth moments arise from a convincingly galumphing, garrulous nature instead of the grating dizziness-in-proximity-to-a-man that we usually get from the genre. Kate is more easily stirred (“Oh, my God,” she cries, when Tom turns up at their flat one afternoon in the second episode, “You’re going to the OSCARS!”) but even she is more one of life’s natural flappers (“Where’s the tea? Will he want whisky? Ice-cream! WHAT’S THE VIBE?”) than traditional Ditsy Sidekick. It’s very pleasing.

Patel pulls off his difficult role – a genuinely charming, sane, un-selfcentred film star – with aplomb. His chemistry with Matafeo and the consistently above-average, if never quite sparkling, script makes even the post-coital banter and flirtatious, conversational scenes work. Such scenes can be the downfall of the highwire romcom acts.

Their meet-cute is in the men’s loo of a nightclub, into which Jessie has nipped to avoid the queue at the ladies’. Tom emerges from a cubicle as she is washing her hands. She points out that men have the great good fortune to be able to wee standing up, so what was he doing in there? “Treated myself to a sit-down one,” he says. “You would pee in a gift horse’s mouth?” she replies, more in sorrow than in anger. This pair are made for each other, despite the fact that she is different enough from the expected film star companion for the paparazzi waiting outside his flat after their second night together to assume that Jessie is the cleaner. “Ultimately uncalled for,” she murmurs later.

Still, there are plenty of highways and byways to be explored and obstacles, including a misidentified pair of knickers and a recent ex-girlfriend, to be navigated before they earn – I hope, for not all episodes were made available for viewing – the right to live happily ever after together in more than a ninth of a house.

And there’s Minnie Driver, albeit not in the first episode. But do stay until at least her turn as Tom’s adamantine agent, Kath. Part Bebe Glazer from Frasier, part Driver’s own role as John Cleese’s sociopathic daughter Lorraine Finster in Will & Grace (and do seek that out, too, while you still have time on your hands before full lockdown lifts), her main job, as she sees it is, to keep Tom thin (“If you think of eating bread, call me”) and turn his desire away from indie credibility and towards commercial success. (“Look at this script! You’re an unlucky-in-love optometrist – who falls in love with a blind girl! Rachel McAdams is already attached!”) If there’s a happier sight than an actor getting to play an agent, I don’t know what it is.

So, even if you smile rather than laugh your way through Starstruck’s first episode, do give it at least another 22 minutes of your time thereafter. You might end up quite struck by it yourself.

Starstruck is available on BBC Three now and will air on Mondays at 10.45pm on BBC One from 26 April

  • This article was amended on 25 April 2021. A previous version described the series as Anglo-Australian; Rose Matafeo is in fact from New Zealand


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Starstruck review – a lovely, warm, witty return for Rose Matafeo’s big-hearted romcom
Sweet, occasionally swoon-worthy and magical when binge-watched: this comedy’s second series two sees Jessie and Tom pick up exactly where they left off

Rebecca Nicholson

07, Feb, 2022 @10:20 PM

Article image
Starstruck star Rose Matafeo: ‘Success freaks me out! It’s a gut-punch’
The creator of the hit BBC romcom talks about having less than a day to enjoy its triumph – and how extreme nerd-dom got her through 2021

Stuart Heritage

24, Dec, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
TV tonight: the Starstruck lovers’ worlds collide at a glitzy bash
More obstacles for Tom and Jessie when his brother turns up less than sober. Plus, a look at the thought processes of two of the world’s worst dictators. Here’s what to watch tonight

Hollie Richardson, Phil Harrison, Jack Seale, Henry Wong and Simon Wardell

21, Feb, 2022 @6:20 AM

Article image
Schmigadoon! review – a one-note musical … and even that falls too flat
It has a stellar cast including Keegan-Michael Key, Cecily Strong, Kristin Chenoweth and Alan Cumming. But sadly, Apple TV+’s Brigadoon parody is lacking in every other way

Lucy Mangan

16, Jul, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Meet the Richardsons review – sofa, so good for this comedy couple
Jon Richardson and Lucy Beaumont’s domestic mockumentary returns for a second series, with fewer meta jokes but just as much fun

Rebecca Nicholson

08, Apr, 2021 @9:40 PM

Article image
Atypical season four review – warm autism comedy comes of age
Netflix’s sitcom about an autistic teenager’s road to independence reaches its final season, dealing with big themes in a way that is sweet but not saccharine

Rebecca Nicholson

09, Jul, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Bloods review – patchy paramedic comedy unlikely to split your sides
Comics Samson Kayo and Jane Horrocks bring just enough charm to elevate this ambulance-based sitcom from perilously laugh-free to worth 22 minutes of your time

Lucy Mangan

05, May, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Q Force review – Netflix’s gay spy caper is disastrously dated
A glut of queer culture cliches, outdated references to Ally McBeal and Brokeback Mountain and – crucially – an absence of laughs, make for a stereotypical stinker of an animation

Rebecca Nicholson

02, Sep, 2021 @2:29 PM

Article image
Ladhood series two review – Liam Williams muddles through masculinity
The comic’s painfully funny, semi-autobiographial sitcom returns for a second series, balancing crass banter with intelligent insights into emotional inadequacy

Jack Seale

15, Aug, 2021 @7:30 AM

Article image
Dad Stop Embarrassing Me! review – Jamie Foxx’s first flop?
This lazy Netflix comedy about a cringe-inducing parent who’s not very cringe-inducing at all is a rare misstep for the entertainment polymath

Ellen E Jones

14, Apr, 2021 @12:00 PM