Amazing Stories review – Spielberg anthology is full of heart

Apple has rebooted the director’s hit 80s sci-fi show. It might not be on trend, but it has optimism and nostalgia at its core

Do you remember the first iteration of Steven Spielberg’s Amazing Stories in the mid-80s? An anthology series back in the days when we just called it “TV”. Some episodes were better than others, but they were all solid, satisfying, fully braced tales that left you with a deep sense of contentment. Restorative to the spirit in both form and content – tales of derring-do, noble sacrifice and uppances come abounded – they left you ready for your tea, bed and to face another day of leg warmers, neon eyeshadow and Thatcherism.

I am delighted to report that the new incarnation, brought to you by young upstart Apple TV+, has – going by the one episode that the streaming service has released for review – deviated from this flawless formula not a jot. The first tale is an Outlander-esque time-travelling love story that’s as compact and well made as you could hope. Sam (Dylan O’Brien, who also stars in MTV’s series Teen Wolf, in case you want to experience your own little time vortex) is a lad about town currently helping his more responsible, settled brother Jake in his house restoration business. As they work on their latest wreck, a fierce storm known as a derecho hits and Sam is transported back to the house’s earliest days. There he meets and falls in love with Evelyn (Victoria Pedretti), the impoverished daughter of the family who built and live in the house, and who is about to be forced into a loveless marriage to save the family fortunes. From there, things unfold pretty much as you might expect.

Victoria Pedretti in Amazing Stories, Season 1 , “The Cellar”, on Apple TV+.
Loveless marriage … Victoria Pedretti in Amazing Stories. Photograph: Apple TV+

In its native US, the show has received much criticism for its lack of flair, innovation and complexity of character. Which seems to me to misunderstand the nature of the beast and the audience at which it’s aimed, which is surely not world-weary adult or even young adult viewers, but – just like the original – children. At teatime, ideally, if teatimes are still a thing. To them, basement portals, the bemusement of people landing in the wrong era, beloveds parted across the decades and all the hoary rest of it will be as fresh and exhilarating as it was the first time you came across it, in a Bunty comic strip, or classic time-slip children’s novel (Marianne Dreams? Charlotte Sometimes? Tom’s Midnight Garden?), or one of the Back to the Futures. What’s more, it’s full of iPhones or devoid of feminist liberation depending on the direction of travel. And if you can let yourself watch as a child again, the hour can become charming once more, even for those old enough to remember when the future Marty was going back to (“It’s your kids, Mary!”) was still to come.

It’s an unfashionable approach, of course, and maybe it does sit a little oddly with Apple’s image and positioning as a new and thrusting arrival on the streaming scene. But you don’t recruit Spielberg if you aren’t looking for a product with heart – one that has optimism instead of cynicism at its core, that seeks to entertain rather than emptily impress or dazzle. It may be a measure of Apple TV+’s confidence in itself that it is prepared to look at a property and say: “You know what? If it ain’t broke, let’s not try to fix it.” And Spielberg’s never broken.


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Visible: Out on Television review – a fabulous history of small-screen gayness
With jaw-dropping old clips and starry talking heads from Ellen to Oprah, this series shows how far LGBTQ representation has come – and the power TV has to make change

Rebecca Nicholson

14, Feb, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Physical review – Rose Byrne’s fitness guru fails to get the pulse racing
It’s all pain, no gain as a hippy housewife turns to VHS-era aerobics in this Spandex-clad dramedy from Apple TV+

Lucy Mangan

18, Jun, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Trying review – infertility proves fertile ground for laughs
Rafe Spall and Esther Smith are brilliant as the couple considering adoption – and rising above the absurdities of their painful plight

Lucy Mangan

01, May, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Acapulco review – Apple’s Spanglish comedy is a feelgood fiesta
Picking up the cheerful TV baton from Ted Lasso, this bilingual series offers a wholesome holiday to a candy-coloured 80s Mexico filled with possibility and soapy drama

Rebecca Nicholson

08, Oct, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Stillwater review – panda pleasures, with a side order of mindfulness
Apple TV+ has hit the jackpot with a new children’s animation that delivers wholesome morals via dreamy visuals

Ellen E Jones

04, Dec, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
The Mosquito Coast review – Apple’s thriller remake is a disappointing journey
A visually impressive yet narratively underwhelming new take on Paul Theroux’s novel, starring his nephew Justin, isn’t worth the effort

Radheyan Simonpillai

29, Apr, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Ted Lasso review – Apple's soccer sitcom plays an unfunny old game
Jason Sudeikis is the American coach of a British football team in a middling fish-out-of-water comedy that never finds its footing

Benjamin Lee

13, Aug, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Boys State review – amazing study of teenagers running for pretend office
The gloves and training wheels come off as a group of smart, poignantly naive and utterly insufferable Texas boys get together to simulate government

Peter Bradshaw

03, Aug, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Invasion review – no stranger danger in Apple’s anaemic alien takeover
Meteor showers, mass nosebleeds, missing people … this small-screen tale of extra-terrestrials coming to Earth could be thrilling – if only something would actually happen

Lucy Mangan

22, Oct, 2021 @1:30 PM

Article image
The Innocents review – confessions of a teenage shapeshifter
This po-faced fantasy eight-parter about teens in love – More Twilight than Let the Right One In – wallows in yearning but goes nowhere

Jack Seale

25, Aug, 2018 @5:30 AM