The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 5: Once Upon a Time in Iraq

The story of how the US and its allies overthrew a despotic regime and made things much worse succeeded brilliantly by focusing on moving personal stories

Like all the best documentaries, Once Upon a Time in Iraq is just some people telling a story. Here they are dramatically lit, often no more than faces emerging from the darkness: the civilians, journalists and soldiers who had no option but to experience the war in Iraq first-hand. It was happening in front of them, to them. It’s the viewpoint that perspective – a slippery notion – too easily avoids.

At first we are not even certain who these people are, but that doesn’t make their stories any less powerful. Across five shattering instalments, Once Upon a Time in Iraq gradually reveals their former identities, peeling back layers: translators trying to survive; journalists trying to bear witness; soldiers who came to bestow freedom. There are no politicians offering global justifications or hindsight-tinged regrets here; participation is limited to folks with front-row seats. When the politicians do appear it’s in the comprehensive archive footage of the period, speaking the language of victory and freedom. None of what they have to say has aged well.

Once Upon a Time in Iraq is, in short, the story of America and its allies overthrowing a despotic regime and then setting about making things much, much worse, causing untold suffering in the process and destabilising an entire region for decades afterwards. Most of the participants show obvious signs of the toll taken. “I didn’t do good with the reintegration,” says Lt Col Nate Sassaman, a soldier the journalist Dexter Filkins called “the most impressive officer I met in Iraq”. For some, recounting the past means reliving it – one marine takes a big swig of tequila from the bottle before he starts.

The heart of the story comes from the Iraqis, some of whom were still kids when the invasion began; others were mothers whose children were killed or injured. At the start, Waleed Nesyif, who quickly establishes himself as a plain-speaking, chain-smoking star, watches footage of himself as an 18-year-old translator working for western journalists way back in 2003. “Am I wrong, or did I sound like Borat?” he says. Long before the end, his disillusionment is complete.

Prior to the war many Iraqis like Nesyif yearned for freedom, but within weeks of the invasion they were reduced to asking for, as he put it, “dignity, electricity and some semblance of security”. None of those was forthcoming; some still aren’t. Even during filming the electricity fails mid-interview. In the chaos that followed the invasion, insurgency took root. In the face of insurgency, the cruelty of the occupying forces intensified.

Although the documentary throws up larger questions – was all the suffering the result of a war that was misconceived, poorly planned and spectacularly badly executed, or is all war like that? – director James Bluemel wisely focuses on personal stories. As Nesyif remarked when the series aired last summer: “The human face of this documentary is its greatest achievement.”

The whole thing is still available to stream, but a word of warning: Once Upon a Time in Iraq is the polar opposite of binge viewing. Its humanity doesn’t make it any less harrowing – you will need time to decompress between episodes. A lot of what makes it so difficult to watch is the presumption that you already know the story – as bad as you thought it was, it was worse than you dared imagine.

Contributor

Tim Dowling

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020: 50-1
Michaela Coel’s smart, subversive and taboo-breaking drama gave us absolutely unbeatable television – plus more of the year’s best

18, Dec, 2020 @8:09 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 7: The Last Dance
This Michael Jordan-produced docuseries about basketball has been one of the most addictive – and revealing – viewing experiences of the year

Ammar Kalia

14, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 3: Small Axe
Steve McQueen’s five-film anthology based on real people and events celebrates Britain’s Caribbean history, enriches our national story and is a television landmark

Steve Rose

18, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 2: I Hate Suzie
Billie Piper was on searing form as a B-list celeb whose life is unravelling in this unflinchingly honest portrait of womanhood

Hannah Jane Parkinson

21, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 10: Ghosts
Written by the Horrible Histories crew, this must-see supernatural comedy bears their stamp of absurdity – and is full of feelgood spirit

Stuart Jeffries

09, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 9: The Queen’s Gambit
Anya Taylor-Joy was brilliant as a fiercely determined woman battling sexism and personal demons on her way to the top of the chess world in the 60s

Rebecca Nicholson

10, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 8: This Country
The trials and tribulations of Kerry and Kurtan in a small Cotswold village will have you crying with laughter one moment and stunned with grief the next

Lucy Mangan

11, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best TV shows of 2020, No 1: I May Destroy You
Michaela Coel’s convention-defying drama was a singular fusion of hilarity and tragedy and that withheld easy answers

Yomi Adegoke

22, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
2020 vision: how Covid news topped the TV ratings
Virus briefings trounced celeb contests and one man’s tale of a family trip to Durham was the most gripping of all

Mark Lawson

23, Dec, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Normal People's Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal: 'It's been a wild few months for us'
The stars of the BBC’s hit Sally Rooney adaptation on their quarantine viewing, and how their lives have changed since playing Marianne and Connell

Interview by Stuart Heritage

25, Dec, 2020 @11:00 AM