The Politician review – Ryan Murphy's student politics show is a born winner

Murphy’s dazzling Netflix series plays gloriously with the inauthenticity that has become standard in the corridors of power

When the history of our times comes to be written, possibly with burned stick on dried rat skins, the opening message of Ryan Murphy’s new Netflix series The Politician will demand a page of the annals to itself.

“The Politician,” it says, “is a comedy about moxie, ambition and getting what you want at all costs. But for those who struggle with their mental health, some elements may be disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.”

It will have to be explained to the citizens of the New Times that the people of the Before Times lived in such an enfeebled state that they could not be sure whether this was tongue-in-cheek commentary or a legitimate warning – an act of love by a creator who had proved his warmth and insight by banging out hit after hit on cultural touchstones of his time, including The People v OJ Simpson and The Assassination of Gianni Versace.

In the event, it was both – and the perfect introduction to the tale of moneyed teenager Payton Hobart (played by Tony award-winning Ben Platt), who has dreamed since he was seven of becoming president. At his interview for Harvard, the dean notes that it has become an increasingly popular goal now “the air of impossibility has been removed”.

Hobart has done nothing since then that is not in pursuit of his ambition, building on the innate advantage of his rags (born the unwanted child of a cocktail waitress) to riches (adopted by Gwyneth Paltrow’s matriarch of a fabulously wealthy family) story. He has studied the greats, from Ronald Reagan (“the first television president”) onwards, amassed all the extracurricular points he can, read nothing but political power players’ biographies and is now running for student president.

Platt, with Gwyneth Paltrow.
Platt, with Gwyneth Paltrow in The Politician. Photograph: Netflix

It’s another dazzling Murphy triumph. It has his trademark hurricane of a narrative that sweeps you up and deposits you breathless and agape somewhere else entirely an hour later. He has garnered a set of blistering performances from his actors. The laurels should go to Platt, whose Hobart has layers of sincerity and insincerity he riffles effortlessly through in every scene. But he is surrounded by almost equal brilliance, whether from neophytes like Julia Schlaepfer (channelling young Hillary and Barbara Bush as Hobart’s girlfriend and adviser Alice), Lucy Boynton as the power behind his opponent’s throne (adding a frankly frightening dash of Ivanka to her portrayal) or veterans like Jessica Lange and, still to come, Bette Midler. Lange is on ravishingly monstrous form as the grandmother of Infinity Jackson, a student with leukaemia whom Hobart is determined to recruit as his running mate to get the sympathy vote he lacks.

The Politician is infused with Murphy’s genius for illuminating the macro through the micro. Nothing is quite what it seems, and in the teenagers’ pathologically self-conscious lives we see the world and the politics we have created. We watch as personalities and attitudes are constructed, torn down, flung up again, filtered, adjusted, lit, shadowed, complicated and simplified as needful. The medium is the message, the message is the medium. True distinctions collapse, and meaningless ones are demarcated. When Hobart cries, his tears are as real as they are fake and we can’t even tell if he knows which are which, or if he cares. Are those who affect affectlessness more or less terrifying than those who are really as shallow as they seem. How did we get here? And how do we leave?

This is Murphy’s first product for Netflix since he signed a five-year contract for an estimated $300m (£241m). They have their money’s worth already. Nobody does it better.


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Living With Yourself review – are two Paul Rudds better than one?
Rudd is doubly charming in this cloning comedy-drama on Netflix, which riffs on identity, self-sabotage and the lives we wish we were leading

Lucy Mangan

18, Oct, 2019 @5:01 AM

Article image
Lunatics review – thankfully no blackface, but still painfully unfunny
Chris Lilley’s latest comedy lacks the offensiveness of his past work. But a sigh of relief is still some distance from laughter

Lucy Mangan

19, Apr, 2019 @11:01 AM

Article image
BoJack Horseman review – what will we do without him?
From alcoholism to miscarriage, Netflix’s hit animation has tackled the toughest of subjects with a side of animal magic. As it ends, it remains both wise and poignant

Stuart Jeffries

31, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Good Place season 3 review – a fiendishly smart sitcom salvation
Ted Danson leads the gang into an unwitting experiment as the wonderfully elaborate show keeps up its staggering gag count

Lucy Mangan

28, Sep, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Sex Education season two review – fast, funny and still not for the faint-hearted
The teenagers’ sexual escapades continue apace, bringing constant laughs in this rare, magnificent comedy that is good for both the heart and the soul

Lucy Mangan

17, Jan, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
Is The Politician the most annoying TV show of 2019?
Ryan Murphy’s first show in his $300m Netflix deal is overstuffed with irritating excess from a grating Ben Platt performance to a wildly lurching tone

Stuart Heritage

30, Sep, 2019 @1:57 PM

Article image
The Innocents review – confessions of a teenage shapeshifter
This po-faced fantasy eight-parter about teens in love – More Twilight than Let the Right One In – wallows in yearning but goes nowhere

Jack Seale

25, Aug, 2018 @5:30 AM

Article image
The Rain review – Netflix brings post-apocalyptic thrills to Denmark
This tale of environmental disaster is about more than survival – it questions the very nature of humanity

Sam Wollaston

04, May, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Mindhunter season two review – still TV's classiest guilty pleasure
The psychopath killer thriller’s FBI maverick sleuth is more authentic than ever as he investigates the Atlanta child murders and the ‘BTK strangler’

Jack Seale

16, Aug, 2019 @1:17 PM

Article image
The OA season two review – the psychic octopus is the final straw
Brit Marling’s mystery serial has a cult following who pore over each supernatural dance routine and bizarre plot point. But in truth, this is just an unending stream of WTF? bunkum

Jack Seale

22, Mar, 2019 @6:30 AM