Louis Theroux: Surviving America’s Most Hated Family review – a deeply uncomfortable watch

This follow-up film about the supremely intolerant Westboro Baptist church finds plenty to be outraged by, but it also veers into exploitation

Just as you did with his previous visits, you need to brace yourself before watching Louis Theroux’s return to Topeka, Kansas to see how the Westboro Baptist church – the folk who picket US soldiers’ funerals with placards reading “God Hates Fags” in protest at their country’s tolerance of homosexuality – are getting on. Surviving America’s Most Hated Family (BBC Two) was his exploration of whether things have changed since founder Fred Phelps (known as Gramps to the rest of the church, largely made up of those with his own fervid blood running through their veins) died five years ago.

The short answer is – no, not enough to make a meaningful difference. Not enough to lift them out of the category of hate-group. Not enough to stop you wanting to weep at the contortions of logic and perversions of thought that can be followed in the name of God. The worlds of pain inflicted by this – on others, usually – still open up behind their words almost every time a member speaks. For instance, a new family – the Jacks – has joined forces with the Phelpses, and one of the father’s four children explains that they left their mother behind four years ago when he was 13. He doesn’t really miss her because, “She claims she loves me but by the standard of God she hates me. Because she doesn’t tell me the truth – that if I don’t obey God, I’m gonna go to hell.” His favourite placard is “God still hates fags”.

The preaching in their chapel does seem to have softened since Gramps departed and was replaced by a council of elders. You wonder if this is as much a product of their inability to match the potency of his oratory – and footage of him from Theroux’s previous visits in 2007 and 2011 reminds us how uniquely horribly gifted he was – than a desire to dilute its toxicity. The family still picket as strenuously as ever, and seem to feed off the outrage of passers-by. On the other hand, Theroux hears a persistent rumour that Gramps died excommunicated after shouting “You’re good people” at the gay rights charity HQ across the street. Did dementia strip him down to a better man at the core? Was it a moment of simple madness that meant nothing? Or was it, of course, demonic possession? It seems clear, however, that something has shaken members. Is the gentler preaching a sign that cracks in the certainties upon which Gramps’s church was built are starting to appear? No one is willing to admit the event even happened.

Theroux stood his ground to an admirable degree with the noxious family – and with Steve, a documentary-maker who, unlike Theroux, was so impressed with what he found at the church when he came to film it a few years ago that he joined up. What has always marked the Westboro Baptists out is the aggression with which they approach everything, the instant access to fury they all have and the readiness to beat down anyone, especially those who press points in the way Theroux does, with verbal violence. Steve shares this ability in full. This is a family of bullies, blood-related or not.

Less admirable is Theroux’s treatment of Megan, daughter of Shirley (one of the most committed and unforgiving members of that committed and unforgiving group) and granddaughter of Fred. She escaped the church a few years ago after finding a community of people on Twitter who gave her the confidence to question her lifetime of indoctrination, and has built a life without contact with her outraged family since. He reduces her to tears – as he must surely have known he would – with the news that two of her siblings recently became engaged. This will make it that much harder for them to follow her example and, in all likelihood, means that she will never see them properly again. We see the chasm of grief opening deeper and deeper in her in real time. It is profoundly uncomfortable to watch and, for me, errs firmly on the side of exploitation – which is not, generally, Theroux’s stock-in-trade.

The testimony of more than one new member that it was Theroux’s earlier documentaries that drew them to the church also raises questions about the ethics of giving publicity to Westboro. They are hateful, repellent, appalling in every conceivable way, and they cause a misery that far outweighs their number. But still, that number is small, and its impact, in the grand scheme of things, remains so too. It’s hard to imagine the attention paid to their extremist tactics didn’t encourage them and increase the church’s influence. God help us.

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Louis Theroux: Dark States – Heroin Town review: bleak as hell
The documentary-maker is back with a tale of America’s worst ever drug epidemic and its forgotten victims. Plus: it’s party time in John Singleton’s new LA drama Snowfall

Sam Wollaston

08, Oct, 2017 @9:55 PM

Article image
Louis Theroux: Drinking to Oblivion review – you’ll worry about your alcohol consumption
The docu-king is back in Britain with a brilliant, brutal look at addiction. Plus: the genius of Yehudi Menuhin, the 20th century’s greatest violinist

Sam Wollaston

25, Apr, 2016 @6:20 AM

Article image
Louis Theroux: Selling Sex review – employment, empowerment or exploitation?
With the sex economy booming, Theroux sensitively shadowed three women at its coalface – from a hard-up student to a woman married for 44 years

Lucy Mangan

12, Jan, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Louis Theroux: Life on the Edge review – 25 years of oddball odysseys
This new four-part series sees the documentary maker revisit the highlights of his long and varied career, from cornering hucksters to run-ins with neo-Nazis

Lucy Mangan

06, Sep, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
TV tonight: Joe Exotic gets the full Louis Theroux treatment
A year after Tiger King, the documentarian charts the rise and fall of the animal keeper. Plus: Wellington Paranormal. Here’s what to watch this evening

Ammar Kalia, Ellen E Jones, Hannah J Davies, Jack Seale and Paul Howlett

05, Apr, 2021 @5:20 AM

Article image
Louis Theroux: Savile review – from awkward to seriously uncomfortable … and extraordinary
Theroux sets out to explain how he, and everyone else, failed to uncover Savile’s rape and child abuse in a brave, bold and honest film

Sam Wollaston

02, Oct, 2016 @9:15 PM

Article image
Louis Theroux – The City Addicted to Crystal Meth | Grizzly Bear Face-Off: Austin Stevens' Adventures | Engineering Britain's Superweapons | Girls Aloud: Out of Control | TV Review

For Louis Theroux, life is just one big awkward moment. And thank goodness for that, says Sam Wollaston

Sam Wollaston

09, Aug, 2009 @11:05 PM

Article image
Ryanair: Britain's Most Hated Airline? review – tales of horror and stinginess
By removing practically everything bar the seats and the pilots, company founder Michael O’Leary changed budget air travel for ever, as this scathing exposé shows

Lucy Mangan

07, Feb, 2019 @10:00 PM

Article image
Thunderbirds Are Go and Louis Theroux: Transgender Kids - TV review
As a young boy I loved the Tracy brothers and this update is pretty FAB too

Stuart Jeffries

06, Apr, 2015 @6:00 AM

Article image
Louis Theroux: 'I worried I might be mansplaining motherhood'
As he tackles one of his most harrowing subjects yet, the documentary-maker talks about parenting, psychosis – and his secret beard

Gwilym Mumford

08, May, 2019 @2:59 PM