Labour’s Jon Ashworth has pulled out of the final pre-election episode of BBC Question Time, after the programme was criticised for featuring an all-male panel.

The shadow health secretary said he had “no idea” it was an all-male line-up when he agreed take part in the programme, so has agreed to step aside in favour of the Oxford East Labour candidate Anneliese Dodds.

The BBC made clear it never intends to have an all-male line-ups on its five-person panels but instead relies on political parties to put forward female politicians. Ashworth was a last-minute replacement for the shadow cabinet member Laura Pidcock, who had pulled out for personal reasons.

Here is a look at tomorrow’s panel for our show in Hull. Joining Fiona we have @JamesCleverly, @JonAshworth, @IBlackfordSNP, @EdwardJDavey and @TiceRichard #bbcqt

— BBC Question Time (@bbcquestiontime) December 4, 2019

Harriet Harman, the longest continuously serving female MP, complained: “Oh for goodness sake! Why does BBC think men have all the answers!!! I thought we sorted this in the last century!”

The BBC said it was unhappy with the situation: “You’re right – all-male panels are not the ideal in 2019. The (female) Labour politician we announced yesterday had to pull out for personal reasons. We’re pleased to say Anneliese Dodds has now agreed to appear, and we’re grateful to her for stepping in at short notice.”

Question Time panels usually have at least one political pundit or public figure appearing alongside four politicians, making it easier to ensure at the very least a bare minimum of female representation on the panel. But with just days until the general election, the BBC had decided to offer slots to five major political parties and – after Pidcock withdrew – all the parties had nominated a male politician to take part in the programme.

Instead, Dodds will be joined by the Conservatives’ James Cleverly, the Liberal Democrats’ Ed Davey, the SNP’s Ian Blackford, and Brexit party candidate Richard Tice.

Men-only Question Time panels are very rare and the BBC has made a concerted drive in recent years to increase the number of women appearing on its news and current affairs programme, with many programmes hitting the target of 50:50 representation following a staff-led effort to convince producers to push for equal on-air gender representation.

It is the latest example of the BBC’s editorial decisions coming under substantial scrutiny during this general election, prompting the director of news, Fran Unsworth, to write a defence of the corporation’s impartiality for the Guardian.

She said that given the scale of the BBC’s output, some human mistakes are inevitable, adding: “Conspiracy theories are much in vogue these days. But we are a large organisation that employs thousands of independently minded journalists. Our editors employ their judgments on their own programmes for their own audiences. These aren’t the ideal conditions for a conspiracy.”


Jim Waterson Media editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Emily Maitlis and Nick Robinson audition in Question Time pilots
Kirsty Wark and Samira Ahmed also tried out as hosts during secret show with panel of MPs

Dan Sabbagh

08, Oct, 2018 @9:03 AM

Article image
David Dimbleby to step down as chair of BBC's Question Time
Presenter, who has hosted the show for 25 years, says he plans to return to reporting

Jim Waterson Media editor

17, Jun, 2018 @9:00 PM

Article image
Culture secretary urges BBC to appoint female Question Time host
Matt Hancock backs calls for a woman to replace David Dimbleby on politics show

Mark Sweney

21, Jun, 2018 @12:12 PM

Article image
Top Gear returns Chris Evans to his mid-90s glory days
BBC bosses hope presenter can replicate the days when millions tuned into his Radio 1 breakfast show and watched his Channel 4 hit TFI Friday

John Plunkett

19, Jun, 2015 @5:05 PM

Article image
Jeremy Clarkson brushes off BBC decision to pull Top Gear
Presenters tweets appear to brush off suspension of motoring show over allegations that he punched a producer

Matthew Weaver

11, Mar, 2015 @10:17 AM

Article image
Barry Norman: 'His enthusiasm and love for film always shone through' | Peter Bradshaw
The face of the BBC’s Film programme for almost three decades was an accessible, unpretentious surveyor of cinema

Peter Bradshaw

01, Jul, 2017 @11:53 AM

Article image
Channel 4's Ukip film attracts complaints before it even airs
Docudrama Ukip: the First 100 Days, which depicts race riots as the party’s policies hit home, attracts complaints of political bias

Kevin Rawlinson

16, Feb, 2015 @2:55 PM

Article image
Thinking outside the box: the sad demise of radical TV
Gone are the days when public intellectuals would riff on Marx while exposing a hint of calf on telly. But were these all-white mansplaining marathons ever as progressive as they made out?

Stuart Jeffries

04, May, 2018 @10:19 AM

Article image
Autism in film: X+Y is audacious – but is it cliched or the real deal?
In X+Y, a gifted young man prepares for a mathematics contest. Does it, and films like it, misrepresent or empower those who are on the autistic spectrum?

Leslie Felperin

12, Mar, 2015 @3:15 PM

Article image
Question Time: BBC has 'great opportunity' to appoint female host
Programme should be presented by a woman for first time, say MPs and journalists

Jim Waterson Media editor

18, Jun, 2018 @6:41 PM