Upright review – Tim Minchin's road-trip series is clever, scenic and addictively good

With a light touch and electric performances, the series marries melancholy with comedy to deliver an odd-couple narrative that goes beyond the norm

Positioning a piano outside its natural environment has a way of making the instrument visually arresting. If in doubt, consult the famous beach scene in the director Jane Campion’s 1993 masterpiece The Piano, with Holly Hunter tapping away as waves roll into the shore and night turns to day.

Consult, also, Foxtel’s addictively good eight-part series Upright, an on-the-road dramedy revolving around a musician’s journey from Sydney to Perth, to return home to his dying mother. Created by Chris Taylor (of The Chaser) and directed by Matthew Saville (whose recent work includes TV productions Friday on My Mind and Seven Types of Ambiguity), the show spans many outback locations, from a good old bikie-infested pub to a beautiful pink salt lake which, one character speculates, must surely be coloured by “flamingo shit”.

But there’s a physical centre that anchors the narrative, no matter where it leads: an old piano loaded on to a trailer. This instrument is being transported by the aforementioned musician, Lucky, who is played by Tim Minchin – also one of the writers on this show (the others are Taylor, Leon Ford and Kate Mulvany), as well as a producer on the show.

In Upright, Minchin’s eyes seem naturally ringed by stress and worriment rather than the kohl that his on-stage persona prefers. The musician, comedian, actor, writer, Matilda the Musical creator – etcetera etcetera – keeps the scarecrow hair, of course, and amps up the slightly wastoid demeanor, conveying the countenance of a flaky sort of fellow who had a beer for breakfast and might write a song about it in the afternoon.

Milly Alcock as Meg in Upright
As Meg, Milly Alcock delivers ‘an almost electrical energy’. Photograph: Matt Nettheim/Sky Atlantic

Upright is a two-hander shared between Lucky and a young teenage companion, Meg (Milly Alcock), who come together quite literally – meeting after colliding in a car accident early in the first episode. While Lucky is a little adrift from reality, a little distant, Meg is high-wired and in your face, pouncing on every moment: a potty-mouthed rebel with a big attitude and a take-no-guff personality.

En route to the hospital, Meg tells Lucky she doesn’t believe in coincidences: the old “everything happens for a reason” chestnut. He rebukes her with a more jaded and world-weary perspective: that in fact “nothing happens for a reason, or everything happens for no reason”, thank you very much.

This scene, which playfully discusses fate and probability, is a melancholic riff on ideas expressed in one of Minchin’s comedy songs, the faux-romantic If I Didn’t Have You. In it he explains to his wife that “if it wasn’t for you, darling you, I really think that I would probably have somebody else.”

It is a clever introductory segment, establishing an odd-couple chemistry that goes beyond introvert versus extrovert, or old versus young, suggesting two people coming at things from fundamentally different perspectives. Without labouring the point, we are informed that Upright is a story about large and small journeys – ie Lucky’s big trip back home (an easy metaphor for the “road of life”), plus smaller and more expeditious missions en route.

The road story format allows the screenwriters to move briskly from one (mis)adventure to the next, sometimes with a funny line or brief absurdity to counter potential heavy-handedness. Episodes tend to begin with either an allusion to Lucky’s family predicaments or a flashback detailing something about them.

It becomes gradually clear what his mother means when she says, in a phone message played back on several occasions, that he should come home because “everybody makes mistakes”.

Minchin’s performance combines stoner-like man-child and emotionally stunted adult with a splash of shaggy panache all his own, evolving his character from sad-sack weirdo to a reasonably complex person. Alcock is excellent as the other half of the odd couple: with a head-turning, hair-trigger performance that delivers the show an almost electrical energy. The talented cinematographer Katie Milwright (who recntly shot Gurrumul, Celeste and a couple of episodes of Tidelands) conjures a slick but weathered look: a bit sticky, a bit hot, a bit dusty, sans the cliche hot-and-humid Australian aesthetic.

Still from Upright
The pair move from one (mis)adventure to the next. Photograph: Matt Nettheim

The surrogate father/surrogate daughter element between the two leads evolves so organically you barely notice it happening. Matthew Saville has lightness of touch – he is a very humane kind of director with an obvious interest in exploring how decent but flawed people behave in emotionally demanding situations. The most powerful example is his terrific 2007 feature film Noise, though there are traces of it throughout his oeuvre – from Please Like Me to the feature film A Month of Sundays.

Musical elements are present throughout Upright but downplayed. Saville and his writers appear to be reluctant to divert the series into full toe-tapping party mode, as if doing so might constitute too much of a Tim Minchin-ism. When the star plays the piano, it resonates.

But the piano is not just an instrument: it’s sort of a character, sort of a visual motif, and certainly a centre of gravity around which the drama and comedy orbits.

• Upright airs in the UK on Sky Atlantic, and streams on NOW TV. In Australia, it airs on Fox Showcase and streams on Foxtel


Luke Buckmaster

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Upright season two review – Tim Minchin dramedy has already jumped the shark
Minchin and Milly Alcock are perfectly fine, but don’t share the playfully brittle chemistry that made their original union pop and crackle

Luke Buckmaster

14, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Upright review – Tim Minchin's pitch-perfect Aussie odyssey
The comic and his teen co-star Milly Alcock shine in a remarkably charming and moving yarn about transporting a piano 4,000 miles across the Outback

Lucy Mangan

12, Dec, 2019 @11:10 PM

Article image
Tim Minchin lands new TV series Upright: 'The show I've been waiting for'
The Foxtel-Sky UK production will follow two misfits and a cherished piano on a road trip across Australia

Steph Harmon

23, Jul, 2018 @12:46 AM

Article image
Tim Minchin on Upright and getting serious about acting: 'I’ve got a lot to overcome’
Back in Australia after two professional heartbreaks, the comedian discusses his new show, the knife edge between comedy and drama – and why he wants a ‘Hanksian’ career

Steph Harmon

26, Nov, 2019 @8:21 PM

Article image
From Upright to Get Krack!n: the eight most memorable moments in Australian TV in 2019
Plus Deborah Mailman takes Total Control, Frayed shows a different side to 1980s Newcastle, and 60 Minutes outdoes itself on hyperbole

Steve Dow, Nathan Dunne, Steph Harmon, Gabriel Wilder, Clarissa Sebag-Montefiore, Stephanie Convery, Luke Buckmaster

28, Dec, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Squinters review – Tim Minchin and Jacki Weaver take the low road in glib commuter comedy
ABC TV delivers a healthy dose of laughs alongside frivolous word salads in this patchy and meandering gabfest

Luke Buckmaster

07, Feb, 2018 @3:35 AM

Article image
Tim Minchin's homecoming show: 'I will make you cry'
Australia’s funniest national treasure utterly unafraid to take the piss out of everyone

Clarissa Sebag-Montefiore

20, Mar, 2018 @3:00 AM

Article image
Helpmann awards: Tim Minchin's Matilda the Musical scoops record 13 prizes
Eight young actors who played the title role share one of musical’s four acting awards, while Minchin wins best original score

Melissa Davey

26, Jul, 2016 @2:28 AM

Article image
Last King of the Cross review – true crime series too polished for its own good
Based on John Ibrahim’s memoir and starring Tim Roth as a crime boss, this drama about Sydney’s ‘mecca of sin’ is full of forgettable machismo

Luke Buckmaster

15, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Crash Landing On You: parachute into this addictively romantic South Korean soap opera
A freak tornado, a paragliding misadventure, and a love that crosses the divide between North and South – and that’s just for starters

Jo Walker

11, May, 2020 @4:18 AM