'Prince Andrew can't slink away from this now' – the TV triumph of Virginia Giuffre

Calm, thorough and deeply plausible, Virginia Giuffre’s BBC interview was everything Prince Andrew’s wasn’t – and it made the severity of the accusations against him look undeniable

Prince Andrew’s Newsnight interview quickly became more about him than the subject. Through no fault of Emily Maitlis’, Prince Andrew outed himself as such a lunk-headed idiot that the serious allegations against him retreated a little.

When you think of that interview, you immediately think of Andrew’s volley of jaw-dropping explanations. His inability to sweat. His photographic memory of Woking Pizza Express. His tendency to be “too honourable”. You were watching a man who spent his life being held accountable for nothing attempt to skirt an important issue with the power of his bovine privilege alone, and failing hard. The interview became less about his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein and more about watching a man drive his own life off a cliff.

And while the interview certainly had impact – it isn’t every day someone does so badly at Newsnight their mum fires them from their own family – it did mean the focus shifted away from the women at the centre of the allegations. Last night’s Panorama was a much-needed corrective.

There was nothing flashy about The Prince and the Epstein Scandal. There were no stand-out lines, and no memes will come of it, but Virginia Giuffre managed to be everything Prince Andrew wasn’t. She was thorough where Andrew was evasive. She was determined where Andrew panicked. She sat with the weight of her accusations where Andrew ignored them. Her proximity to Epstein left her with nothing. Andrew’s left him with everything to lose. More than anything, Giuffre looked like a person; a real, flesh and blood person who had spent at least some of her life dealing with the consequences of something. She was Andrew’s opposite in every way.

This was a much more muted hour of television than Newsnight. Newsnight let Prince Andrew tie his own shoelaces together and watched him fall, but this is what made sure he’ll never get up again. Facts and inconsistencies were fastidiously laid out one after the other. Different voices – victims, lawyers, former heads of royal protection – were piled up until the severity of the accusations against Andrew became undeniable. This isn’t something he can slink away from any more. This isn’t going to go anywhere.

Smartly, Panorama also used Andrew’s interview in key moments, just to highlight its utter stupidity. The emotional climax of the episode came at the halfway point. Giuffre described what it was like to be abused by a member of the royal family – where it happened, how long it lasted, what it felt like, her subsequent feelings of powerless and shame – before breaking down when she attempted to understand it. “I couldn’t comprehend how the highest levels of the government and powerful people were allowing this to happen,” she wept. “Not only allowing it to happen but participating in it.” Her anguish was perfectly evident. Cut to Andrew on Newsnight, eyes darting around beneath his sheen of privilege, telling Maitlis that “I can absolutely, categorically tell you it never happened.”

Although it aired afterwards, Giuffre was interviewed for Panorama before Prince Andrew’s Newsnight episode was recorded. Perhaps that’s for the best; now she must be taken seriously. The lasting impression of Giuffre was her immense bravery in facing such towering institutions alone. The sheer strength she possesses is incredible. Forget Prince Andrew; when the dust settles on this, she’s the one who deserves to be remembered.


Stuart Heritage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Prince Andrew served with lawsuit from Jeffrey Epstein accuser Virginia Giuffre
A US court document showed paperwork was filed at Royal Lodge and a response is due by 17 September

Adam Gabbatt

10, Sep, 2021 @7:01 PM

Article image
BBC cuts Prince Andrew joke from RuPaul’s Drag Race
Joke in Australian version at expense of Queen’s scandal-hit son deemed not suitable for British audiences

Jim Waterson Media editor

11, May, 2021 @4:36 PM

Article image
Prince Andrew: The Musical review – plays the Epstein scandal for laughs in a way that is … not OK
This romp through Andrew’s life and scandals is full of entertainment. But it makes light of a genuine horror and lets the royal off the hook far, far too easily

Lucy Mangan

29, Dec, 2022 @10:05 PM

Article image
‘Set up for failure’: the wild story behind the car crash interview which destroyed Prince Andrew
From Beatrice attending his meetings to proposing cinema get-togethers at Buckingham Palace, a new documentary digs into how the Newsnight debacle happened

Rachel Aroesti

27, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Prince Andrew scandal: Virginia Giuffre pleads for UK public support
American tells BBC she was told to have sex with royal by Jeffrey Epstein’s friend Ghislaine Maxwell

Caroline Davies

03, Dec, 2019 @7:32 AM

Article image
Can the Virginia Giuffre and Jeffrey Epstein deal protect Prince Andrew?
Lawyers make case for why the 2009 settlement might cover the royal and why it might not

Edward Helmore in New York

04, Jan, 2022 @7:09 PM

Article image
Ghislaine Maxwell calls Prince Andrew photo with Virginia Giuffre ‘a fake’
Former girlfriend of Jeffrey Epstein questions authenticity of infamous 2001 photograph during interview from Florida prison

Matthew Weaver

22, Jan, 2023 @4:48 PM

Article image
Prince Andrew accuser Virginia Giuffre tested in hospital for Covid-19
Giuffre, 35, from Florida, says she is ‘so scared right now’ and having trouble breathing

Ben Quinn

07, Apr, 2020 @10:49 AM

Article image
Met police drop investigation into Prince Andrew in Virginia Giuffre case
Officers made decision after reportedly talking to Giuffre and a review of documents

Haroon Siddique and Hannah Ritchie

10, Oct, 2021 @10:40 PM

Article image
Virginia Giuffre ‘unlikely to accept purely financial settlement’ with Prince Andrew
Giuffre wants vindication of herself and her claims, says her lawyer David Boies

Caroline Davies

13, Jan, 2022 @9:45 AM