Does America need the American Idol reboot right now?

With a new network and new judges after a two-year break, the show returns to TV more optimistic, gentle, and subtly patriotic than ever

Since singing competition shows are television’s most inexhaustible genre, American Idol is back after a blink-and-you-missed-it two years off the air. This time, the show is on ABC instead of Fox, and there’s a brand new trio of judges: Lionel Richie, Katy Perry, and Luke Bryant. Ryan Seacrest, recently accused of sexual assault by a former stylist (a charge he denies), is still the host, and in the premiere episode claims he’s “waited a lifetime for this”, which is hard to believe given that babies born in 2002, when Seacrest began hosting Idol, will be able to vote in the next presidential election.

Idol was always the best of the singing competition shows and, at least in the US, the form’s progenitor. The crop of talent was better than that of The Voice and The X-Factor and the format, with intimate auditions set across the US, allowed for the contestants’ real, observable growth. Where other shows, including The Four, Fox’s Idol replacement, throw singers in front of a studio audience right away, Idol auditions dispense with the hubbub and introduce us to the talent pool before hair, make-up and ill-advised song suggestions get in the way. Indeed, one of the great joys of the show is looking back at contestants like Katharine McPhee and Carrie Underwood singing sans music before a dumbstruck Simon, Paula, and Randy.

Luckily, in the first episode of Idol’s 16th season, very little has changed. Nor has the show lost its penchant for heavy-handed inspiration, opening with a five-minute long, cross-country montage – narrated by Underwood herself – recounting Idol’s history of discovering everyone from “the dreamers to the lullaby singers”. As the music swells and shots of middle America whiz by, it becomes evident that the reboot is indulging in a bit of patriotism-lite, positioning music as a bridge between the right and the left in these divisive times.

American Idol, of course, will not save us. And without the biting interplay between its former judges or any sense of novelty, the show is a safer, more cordial shell of its former self. But still, there is a lot to like, primarily the contestants, who include Ron, a James Bay-singing Congolese immigrant, and many talented singer-songwriters from the deep south.

The judges are very pleasant if not especially insightful. While the show grows its legs one imagines they will too, but in the premiere there’s not quite enough substantive feedback to balance out the cutesiness. After one audition, Perry plants one on a never-kissed 19-year-old boy; before another, she and one of the episode’s most impressive vocalists lob the term “wig” back and forth, confusing Bryant and Richie, evidently not schooled in gay terminology.

A still from the premiere episode of American Idol, showing contestant Ron Bultongez during his audition.
A still from the premiere episode of American Idol, showing the contestant Ron Bultongez during his audition. Photograph: Eric Liebowitz/ABC

Perhaps Idol producers sensed that 2018 calls for a dollop of optimism and positivity, because there are also very few bad auditions, save for one or two mildly disillusioned aspiring pop stars. Instead, this new version of Idol centralizes, even more than its predecessor, the contestant’s dreams of making it big and the tribulations they’ve faced along the way. It’s not an entirely unwise decision, given that Idol’s one of the only talent shows that can boast more than a few Hollywood exports, but season 16 could use some levity and spunk to tamp down its twinkly sheen.

American Idol is, of course, a most American show, driven by a persistent faith in the American dream. Integral to its appeal is the democratic voting process, which always made viewers feel like they had a hand in things, and the uplifting narratives culled from far and wide, from Fort Worth, Texas, home of the original Idol, Kelly Clarkson, to High Point, North Carolina, home of the best Idol, Fantasia Barrino. Among the reboots purporting to have interesting things to say about contemporary America – Roseanne, Will & Grace, and Queer Eye among them – Idol has undoubtedly taken the most abstract and sentimental approach.

While the uplift makes for happy viewing, Idol is nevertheless far from the water-cooler phenomenon it once was. The show doesn’t need Nicki and Mariah at each other’s throats or another William Hung to get wind in its sails. But by the time the third or fourth reliably good guitar-wielding hopeful walks through the door, the premiere starts to feel a bit like an open mic night, and you half wish Simon was around to shake things up.


Jake Nevins

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
American Idol finale: less a fond farewell and more a welcome retreat
After 15 seasons it’s time to say goodbye to the reality juggernaut, but with interest at an all-time low is this really the end or just a cynical ratings ploy?

Rob LeDonne

07, Apr, 2016 @2:33 PM

Article image
American Idol: a final farewell to the 'Death Star' of reality TV
The former ratings monster’s last season is about to start but with directionless shows such as The Voice and MTV’s The Challenge serving as replacements, its schmaltzy sentimentality might well be missed

Dave Schilling

06, Jan, 2016 @7:42 PM

Article image
Kelly Clarkson's return to American Idol makes us long for a bygone era
Kelly Clarkson’s emotional performance for the last season of American Idol, the show that launched her to instant fame in 2002, was tinged with nostalgia

Brian Moylan

26, Feb, 2016 @11:00 PM

Article image
Tell it to the judge: why American Idol needs no-nonsense Katy Perry
If anyone can turn the US reality show’s fortunes around, it’s a proper pop star who rides 16ft-tall golden lions

Issy Sampson

26, May, 2017 @12:30 PM

Article image
Big star judges can't save bland new singing competition show The Four
The new American Idol-aiming show boasts a panel of celebrity judges, including Diddy, and a prized time-slot, but it adds nothing to an already oversaturated genre

Jake Nevins

05, Jan, 2018 @5:02 PM

Article image
American Idol: where would country music be without it?
From Carrie Underwood to Kellie Pickler, the talent show unearthed a plethora of country music talents until The Voice came along and took up its mantle

Grady Smith

13, May, 2015 @7:35 PM

Article image
Watch Kanye West perform Gold Digger on American Idol
Star rapper auditions for J-Lo, Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr to promote new series of talent show … and gets their thumbs-up

Guardian music

05, Jan, 2016 @9:57 AM

Article image
Watch a preview of Kanye West's 'faux-dition' for American Idol
The rapper has stepped up to impress the judges on the show, to celebrate the TV series’ final run, in a clip shared by Kim Kardashian

Guardian music

24, Dec, 2015 @10:49 AM

Article image
American Idol's La’Porsha Renae draws anger for anti-LGBT comments
Asked about her home state Mississippi’s new anti-gay law, the American Idol runner-up called being LGBT a ‘lifestyle choice’ she didn’t agree with

Nigel M Smith

11, Apr, 2016 @7:59 PM

Article image
Fox cancels American Idol amid steady ratings decline
The reality competition show once regularly pulled in more than 30 million viewers an episode but struggled to crack 10m in its most recent season

Sam Thielman in New York

11, May, 2015 @2:51 PM