Dead Lucky review – Rachel Griffiths brings poise to convoluted, soapy cop drama

SBS miniseries can’t quite transcend its garish tabloid narrative but is a welcome break from crime TV’s blue gloom

Dead Lucky, SBS’s new miniseries, has all the promise of a fine prestige show. It’s a missing girl tale set in seedy Sydney, involving A-list talent like Rachel Griffiths (of such beloved local films as Muriel’s Wedding and, more recently, 2016’s Hacksaw Ridge) and behind-the-scenes pedigree. The marketing material speaks of a cinematic, fast-paced “gripping thriller”. So why does it lack the golden glow of so much contemporary longform storytelling?

Griffiths stars as Grace Gibbs, a senior detective we first meet in work-mandated anger management sessions. She is hunting a notorious cop-killer, Corey Baxter (Ian Meadows) and still feels implicated in the murder of a colleague, Lincoln, at Baxter’s hands – the fallout of which included the collapse of her marriage. Grace’s junior detective, Charlie Fung (Yoson An), blames her for their co-worker’s death.

Baxter is active again, holding-up convenience stores and terrorising the women in his life, including his ex-partner Claire (Brooke Satchwell, in perhaps the show’s most sensitive performance of a woman in crisis fighting back). A shop owner (Simon Burke) is shot dead in a hold-up, leading Grace and Charlie’s investigation to Bo-Lin (Xana Tang), a Chinese international student. When they find $10,000 in cash in her bedroom, it seems she is connected to some other circle of crime. Bo-Lin is now both missing and a murder suspect, and she may lead Grace and Charlie to Baxter.

A still from four-part miniseries Dead Lucky, on SBS and SBS On Demand.
Dead Lucky’s art direction glitters, from shots of clouds in fast-motion reflected on a monolithic skyscraper to its neon colour palette. Photograph: SBS

If the cop-killer-pursuit-meets-missing-girl procedural sounds convoluted and soapy, that’s because it kind of is, and so are many of the visual storytelling and cinematography decisions made here. The show’s co-creators, Ellie Beaumont and Drew Proffitt, made House Husbands, and director David Caesar has overseen episodes of everything from Water Rats to Underbelly: Razor. The problem is that criminal grit – and true cultural diversity – demands a different sensibility from House Husbands. As a deadly antagonist, Baxter isn’t especially compelling, original, or realistic. The inspiration for his character, from his tatts to his tracksuits, seems to come directly from other Australian films and TV shows. The same goes for the show’s hazy impression of money laundering syndicates and professional kidnappings, despite the production employing a crime consultant.

The plot harvests familiar tropes from the nightly news and squeezes them into a multicultural, urban crime drama: stick-ups at 7-Elevens, sharehouses overcrowded with exploited international students, vulnerable migrants driven to gambling addictions, rote family violence. All of this unfolds recognisably across Lakemba, Malabar, Central Park’s Spice Alley and the dead factories of Redfern. But without some kind of deeper abstraction, what kind of genre – a cop-show composite of mundane tabloid headlines – is that?

Dead Lucky’s plot harvests familiar tropes from the nightly news and squeezes them into an urban crime drama
Dead Lucky’s plot harvests familiar tropes from the nightly news and squeezes them into an urban crime drama. Photograph: SBS

Dead Lucky’s Sydney is a shimmering architectural maquette – like an artist’s impression of a new corporate development. Here, Rob Wood’s production design glitters, from shots of clouds in fast-motion reflected on a monolithic skyscraper to the neon colour palette plucked from Chinatown lanterns and pokies icons. The design matters: not only is it a welcome break from crime TV’s usual blue gloom but it means the characters organically come out of their garish geography, rather than the city merely serving as a decorative backdrop.

Griffiths has been doing more television lately, from Barracuda (another culturally diverse SBS drama) to When We Rise (a queer activist history wrapped in a conventional teleseries format, which also aired on SBS last year). Here, her performance is as precise and controlled as ever. But thinking back to her wonderfully difficult role of Brenda in HBO’s Six Feet Under, I wonder what attracted her to this new character of Grace. The conceit is clear enough: take the familiar convention of a grumpy but blazingly gifted doctor or lawyer or cop, and give the role to a woman. But Dead Lucky shows that just gender-flipping that trope isn’t enough without more character depth, which might have involved stretching Grace to surprising levels of psychological intensity or moral ambiguity.

A still from four-part miniseries Dead Lucky, on SBS and SBS On Demand.
Brooke Satchwell as Claire, a woman in crisis fighting back. Photograph: SBS

Instead, the writing leans into Grace’s relatability: she’s a newly single mum dealing with her ex’s irritating new partner; she’s a tough, dynamic woman cramped by a sexist boss. And yet the very recent BBC America production Killing Eve dealt more deftly and deeply with the idea of intuitive, talented women who are hampered by male-dominated power structures. Grace is meant to be driven by her rage and sorrow for the missing, abused women for whom she’s seeking justice. Indeed, the missing girl premise is an overworked plot device of crime TV in dire need of feminist revision. And yet Dead Lucky evades murky, malicious misogyny as a key theme and skips across all manner of other social issues instead: cultural rifts between generations of migrants, good old revenge and redemption, poverty-stricken sadness.

This is an experienced TV team. But perhaps that’s the limitation. Too schooled in the staples, rather than subverting those genres and forms, the script and its execution has similar issues to other recent crime shows such as Deep Water and Mystery Road. Freighted with seriousness, Dead Lucky is a straight cop drama rather than a truly sinister saga. There’s a little too much redemption and narrative completion, and a hell-bent commitment to getting the baddies. But life – as well as other storytelling ideas at the moment – rarely feels that pat.

Series like Foxtel’s The Kettering Incident (which dives deep into genre, serving a mystery that is truly mysterious), Fargo (with its absurd sensibility) and Killing Eve (with its hysterically on-point motioning to the weirdest edges of human psychology) show that audiences are hungry for screen stories that truly explore the shadows. Here’s hoping future iterations of Dead Lucky – if there are any – try harder to get to those outer reaches.

• Dead Lucky is showing on Wednesdays at 9.30pm on SBS and is available to stream on SBS On Demand

• This article was edited on 27 July 2018 to correct attribution for the show’s aesthetic to production designer Rob Wood

Contributor

Lauren Carroll Harris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Safe Harbour review – tense, compelling asylum seeker drama offers no easy answers
Ewen Leslie leads a uniformly excellent cast in SBS’s engrossing four-part miniseries

Luke Buckmaster

07, Mar, 2018 @12:41 AM

Article image
Rachel Griffiths: 'I think I have been a very poor and bad feminist'
The outspoken Australian actor joins an all-star cast for When We Rise, a TV miniseries exploring the gay rights movement in the US

Alexandra Spring

01, Mar, 2017 @12:47 AM

Article image
The Gloaming review – shades of Twin Peaks in fog-swamped crime drama
Ewen Leslie and Emma Booth investigate a grisly murder in Stan’s moody and noirish new genre series

Luke Buckmaster

30, Dec, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Hungry Ghosts review – spirits and families collide in love letter to the Vietnamese diaspora
SBS’s new miniseries is unconventional and fascinating, combining all the hallmarks of a good thriller while reflecting on the continuing trauma of war

Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen

24, Aug, 2020 @1:31 AM

Article image
New Gold Mountain review – lush neo-western takes a new route through gold rush Australia
Beautiful, heightened drama series following the Chinese community in 1850s Ballarat gives a fresh, cinematic spin on history

Luke Buckmaster

12, Oct, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Six Feet Under: 20 years on, the drama set in a family funeral home still feels ahead of its time
It was groundbreaking and ambitious on release, but even after two decades, the lives – and deaths – of the Fisher family are just as compelling as they ever were

Isabelle Oderberg

14, Oct, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Mystery Road season two review – a new riddle for Aaron Pedersen's troubled detective
Jay Swan grapples with a headless corpse and a compromised archaeological dig in this new instalment of the award-winning Australian crime drama

Luke Buckmaster

15, Apr, 2020 @3:46 AM

Article image
'It's like a turducken of mums': Benjamin Law on fact, fiction and The Family Law
Balancing empathy and humour is always difficult but what if you’re writing a TV comedy based on your own life? Benjamin Law explains how he did it

Stephanie Convery

14, Jun, 2017 @6:00 PM

Article image
Deep Water: were 30 unsolved Sydney deaths really gay hate crimes?
A miniseries inspired by real events and a true-crime documentary anchor an ambitious, multifaceted SBS investigation

Steve Dow

28, Sep, 2016 @11:42 PM

Article image
Homecoming Queens: friends turn chronic illness into comedy script
TV series touches upon pair’s experience with alopecia and breast cancer respectively

Stephanie Convery

14, Apr, 2018 @10:53 PM