The week in TV: Doctor Foster; Tin Star; Safe House; Back; Cold Feet; Diana and I

Dr Foster is back and getting mad with her husband again, while Tim Roth as an ex-London cop finds Canada less wholesome than expected

Doctor Foster (BBC1) | iPlayer
Tin Star (Sky Atlantic/Now TV) | Sky on Demand/Now TV
Safe House (ITV) | ITV Hub
Cold Feet (ITV) | ITV Hub
Back (C4) | All 4
Diana and I (BBC2) | iPlayer

Alan Ayckbourn, writing about creating what might be termed cerebral farce, once ventured that it “explores the extreme reaches of tlhe credible and the likely, and proceeds by its own immaculate internal logic, [to leave] the audience wondering how on earth they came to be where they are now”. Something similar is happening back in Parminster, two short years on, where a similarly skilled craftsman, Mike Bartlett, is retethering the guy ropes of credibility with the return of Doctor Foster for a second series.

It started with a light heart. Suranne Jones’s Dr Gemma Foster, the 2015 poster lass for wronged wives everywhere, was managing her own medical practice and getting on spiffingly with her son Tom, the only shadow being the imminent return of Feckless Bastard Simon, his twentysomething bride and their new brat. Still, lightness… Dr Gemma asked son Tom to take new bride Kate a present, and he asked, pithily, “Is it a bomb?”, all smiles. Even when neighbour Chris begged her, “Please … don’t make a scene! Gemma!” at Cheat Simon’s homecoming/wedding party, there was a certain airiness of touch. At least, for those who had somehow managed to forget the last soiree over which Chris had presided, a magma meltdown of revenge and spat secrets to rival the last reel of Abigail’s Party, if not the last act of Hamlet.

It was only upstairs, fuelled by wine and industrial levels of passive-aggressive goading by smug Simon and his smug new wife, that we really began to see the Gemma of old. The skull beneath the skin, yes, but also the intelligence, and the sexiness, and the cynical calculations of the doctor’s brain, quietly spinning, working out whether, in fact, squirrelly Simon had in fact suffered enough, breezing back with his mimsily pretty missus to a home town wreathed in forgetfulness and forgiveness: and concluding, gothically, No. Quite right – yet she sets about redressing matters in diametrically wrong ways, again her trademark spirited melange of forensic planning, rash spontaneity and professional foot-shootery. At one stage Gemma snaps (at a child!), “It’s not Dr Foster any more,” but we don’t learn what it is, and she has kept her wedding ring: has she been in stasis throughout, refusing herself the luxury of the hateful phrase “moving on”? The questions line up, but by the end of that fraught first hour, fag in mouth, she’s lining up syringes, and a jar of acid for the ring. And every step – the key phrase from above is that “immaculate internal logic” – credible. Just.

At heart this is a sad tale: not dark comedy, or farce, but an everyday tragedy of just how much can be invested in a relationship, a marriage, and what happens when one partner takes all that fragile trust, so vulnerably proffered – and, essentially, defecates on it. That this relatively mundane sadness has been raised so successfully to high drama is testament to the strengths of both Bartlett and Jones (who this time associate produces): it deserves to soar as it did in 2015.

Tim Roth as sheriff Jim Worth in Tin Star.
On the Rockies? Tim Roth as sheriff Jim Worth in Tin Star. Photograph: David Bukach/Sky UK

Strong alcoholic drink also featured, if far more bleakly, in the other absolute standout of the week, Tin Star, in which Tim Roth excels (naturally) as Jim Worth, an ex-London detective transplanted to Little Big Bear in the Canadian Rockies. He is struggling, successfully enough and two years dry, with his alcoholism: he has a lovely, wry family, and an easy way with him, yet there are darkling hints of an alter ego. Little Big Bear is struggling less successfully with the building of a huge oil refinery, presided over by the magnificently simpering Christina Hendricks: the population is actually seen to increase, via the town-border sign, from 1,578 to 2,157 in one jump, with ramifications, via incoming ne’er-do-wells, for crime.

The opener seems to jog along in pithy fashion, nice scene-setting for Sheriff Jim’s culture-clash with the rocky-redder necks among the maples. But suddenly, there’s a savage startler, a gulper, and a boy of five is left dead, shot in the head. By the end of the second episode, Worth (Roth) is back on the whiskey. There will, surely, be revenge: the tin star on the title credits is subtly speckled with what I had thought to be rust. I have revised that thought, and this grips the windpipe already.

As doesn’t, not really at all, the return of Safe House. Fine enough cast, though Stephen Moyer has none of the subtleties of a Christopher Eccleston, opting instead for vague gruff transatlantic tree trunk. Two things are already clear: as before, the “safe” house will be set somewhere remote, fascinating, mysterious and thus not at all safe – here the Lake District has been swapped for one of Wales’s less low-key peninsular beauty spots – and the witnesses will again stupidly endanger everyone by switching on their expressly forbidden mobiles.

The new series is enlivened by the presence of Jason Watkins, Dervla Kirwan, a decent backstory, a Straw Dogs subplot. But my money’s still on the baddies rolling up, half an hour into the finale and doubtless in driving rain, past the miles of DayGlo chevrons helpfully advising “Safe House This Way”.

Robert Webb as Andrew and David Mitchell as Stephen in Back.
Fostering memory: Robert Webb as Andrew and David Mitchell as Stephen in Back. Photograph: Mark Johnson/Channel 4

Back, which began on C4, can be read in a few ways. Back as in, David Mitchell and Robert Webb (left) are back, together, hurrah: the Peep Show guys reunited, and playing quasi simulacra (the sober, moral but sarky one, and the smiley shallow one). Back – as in Stephen’s dad, a pub landlord and inveterate foster father, has died, and the mourners suddenly include Andrew (Webb), who was fostered for about 10 minutes back in the lost 80s, and they will replay their memories of those days with wildly differing degrees of enthusiasm and accuracy. Back – as in, you can never really go there.

It’s a triumph, in that writer Simon Blackwell looks to be embarking on a grown-up exploration of memory that manages to be in parts explosively funny, too. Mitchell’s character (as ever) reveals himself as too clever to pull off real pathos: Webb’s (as ever) as too misguided to garner real dislike. Painfully sharp but also oddly touching, if you let it.

In contrast, the return of Cold Feet for a seventh series felt, dispiritingly… welcome enough but a bit of a chore, like the bath you can’t be bothered to get out of. Adam is still with Tina and there was some interminable stuff about moving in together that got way too specific about Manchester’s commuter routes. The good news is that Robert Bathurst’s David, often the richest untapped vein, is set fair for adventure amid the desperately rich housewives of the Cheshire set.

Diana and I, one of the better of the glut of caterwauls, was still dreadful. Purportedly a drama about the effect of Princess Diana’s death on the lives of a few Britons – a florist, a journalist, a lad whose mother had just died, an Asian bride in a horrid marriage – it (perhaps inadvertently) confirmed that, apart from direct family, the only lasting seismic effects of that week were on greedy media, grasping commerce and the emotionally already fragile.


Euan Ferguson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The week in TV: Doctor Foster; Curb Your Enthusiasm; Tunes for Tyrants; Porridge; The Last Post
Mike Bartlett’s drama came to a tantalisingly open ending, and Larry David made a bracingly welcome return

Euan Ferguson

08, Oct, 2017 @5:59 AM

Article image
The best TV this week: Doctor Foster is back on the roster
Suranne Jones’s wronged woman returns to BBC1, while American Horror Story starts its seventh season and Mitchell and Webb reunite for a new dark comedy

The Guide

01, Sep, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Rewind TV: The Escape Artist; Ambassadors; A Very English Education – review
David Tennant should have foreseen his wife's fate but Mitchell and Webb manage to avoid the obvious, writes Andrew Anthony

Andrew Anthony

02, Nov, 2013 @6:00 PM

Article image
The week in TV: 11.22.63; Camping; Scott & Bailey; Abused: The Untold Story – review
James Franco tries to change the course of history while Julia Davis delights with the wickedly funny Camping

Barbara Ellen

17, Apr, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in TV: I Am Victoria; Cruel Summer; The Boy Who Can’t Stop Dancing; Jerk
Suranne Jones takes falling apart to another level

Barbara Ellen

08, Aug, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
The week in TV: Dark Money; The Left Behind and more
Dark Money set up a terrible dilemma, but couldn’t quite deliver, while The Left Behind packed powerful insight into Islamophobia

Euan Ferguson

14, Jul, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio: Comedy Showcase; Alice Is Still in Wonderland; This American Life
Radio 2 was on the comic money while Siouxsie Sioux was an engaging guide to Alice in Wonderland

Miranda Sawyer

22, Nov, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
The week in TV: Eden: Paradise Lost; Citizen Jane; Utopia: In Search of the Dream; Trust Me; Diana: In Her Own Words
For a year, the Scottish wilderness was lost on the tiresome contestants of Eden, who in turn went unseen by us

Euan Ferguson

13, Aug, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in TV: Upstart Crow; Mum; Billions; Peston on Sunday
BBC2 was full of fun, with Ben Elton’s fine riff on the bard, and Lesley Manville showing that she can do laughter as well as tears

Euan Ferguson

15, May, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in TV: Pose; The Riots 2011: One Week in August; Deceit; Ghosts
The New York drag drama wraps up in style; a meticulous documentary picks its way through 2011’s chaotic summer of riots; and a grimly off-key true crime drama lets everyone down

Barbara Ellen

15, Aug, 2021 @8:30 AM