When good TV goes bad: how Lost got lost - and then found its way again

Pointless polar bears and boring flashbacks drove viewers away in their millions. It took an episode so bad it changed mainstream TV for ever to get it back on track

There’s no point explaining Lost to a newcomer, because it always makes you sound dehydrated to the point of inanity. Still, here goes: a plane crashes on a mysterious island and the surviving strangers band together to try to escape back to civilisation. Also, the island is policed by the disembodied spirit of an ancient godhead, and one of the survivors is in the world’s worst band. Also, there’s a nuclear bomb that makes people travel through time. And there’s a zoo. See? Pointless.

Still, while it was on, Lost’s characters and extravagantly high concepts captivated people in their millions. Sure, you could argue that it was let down by its final episode, which hastily tried to wrap things up with woolly faux-spiritualism. But that isn’t to say that Lost jumped the shark. OK, it might have jumped the shark a bit.

Lost was such a hit that ABC didn’t want it to end. “Keep churning out episodes,” it said, “and we’ll cancel it when you stop making money.” This tactic had worked for hundreds of other shows in the past, but Lost wasn’t like other shows. Lost had a huge central mystery that needed to be solved. So, at the financial behest of its network, the showrunners found themselves having to spin their wheels indefinitely.

And they did this with flashbacks. Although they began as a way to fill in character blanks, they quickly became a crutch. With no end in sight, the flashbacks became longer and less essential. And then came Stranger in a Strange Land. It was the ninth episode of Lost’s third series, and it was utterly pointless.

‘Let me tell you all about how I got these tattoos...’
‘Let me tell you all about how I got these tattoos...’. Photograph: Mario Perez/ABC via Getty Images

The flashback? How Jack got his tattoos. That’s it. Even though the meaning of Jack’s tattoos had no significance whatsoever. Even though there is nothing duller than listening to someone explain their tattoos. That’s what they went with. Lost bottomed out with Stranger in a Strange Land, so that must be when it jumped the shark, right?

Well, yes. But that’s not all: it was so awful it caused something amazing to happen. Realising what a go-nowhere stinker they had on their hands, the showrunners took the episode to the network. “Look what you made us do!” they said. “Look what happens if we have to tell this story for ever!” Seventy-five days later, the network relented. Lost finally had its endpoint.

This had an immediate knock-on effect. Lost instantly regained focus. Once it could accelerate towards a definitive ending, the wheel-spinning was replaced with beautiful, streamlined narrative thrust. The third series climaxed with a masterful two-parter that swept away the dead wood while throwing in a plot twist so gigantic that it would become the cornerstone of the entire show.

Others noticed this, too. Stranger in a Strange Land is a prime example of what can happen when a network prizes longevity over story. But when executives saw how vastly Lost improved once it was truncated, everyone else followed suit. 24 was cut to 12 episodes. Game of Thrones was given 10 episodes a year. The first series of Breaking Bad consisted of just seven episodes. Shows were suddenly being given series that fitted their length. As a result, television flourished. The golden age of TV exists because nobody cares about Jack’s tattoos.

None of this could have happened if Stranger in a Strange Land was any good. You say it was Lost jumping the shark. I say it improved television for ever.


Stuart Heritage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how The Wire lost its spark
It began as a scintillating exploration of Baltimore’s cops and crims. When it became The Jimmy McNulty Show, though, daftness started creeping in

Phil Hoad

14, Aug, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how Empire lost its crown – and found it again
How long could the hip-hop drama get away with its flimsy plots? One season seemed enough – then Rhonda was thrown off a balcony at the start of the third

Hannah Verdier

22, May, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how 24 became torturous viewing
Kiefer Sutherland’s action show was ahead of its time, tackling terrorism on telly in the aftermath of 9/11. But by series six it had become obsolete

Andy Welch

31, Jul, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how The West Wing went south
After three sublime seasons, writer Aaron Sorkin responded to 9/11 with an unusually clumsy standalone episode that knocked the whole show off balance

Gabriel Tate

03, Jul, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how House of Cards came tumbling down
The machiavellian manoeuvring that took Frank Underwood from chief whip to president was thrilling to watch, but it left the show with nowhere to go

Stephen Kelly

16, Oct, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: why House's self-medication got the better of him
Hugh Laurie’s chronically ill sociopath paved the way for the ‘antihero savant’ genre. After season four, though, it was the viewers who suffered

Ben Gazur

04, Dec, 2017 @1:00 PM

Article image
Ross and Rachel v Homer and Marge: who’s the best TV couple?
As Valentine’s Day looms, we put the best telly romances to the test and find out which TV twosome was the ultimate teamup, once and for all

Stuart Heritage and Paul Flynn

11, Feb, 2017 @9:00 AM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how bad twists and incest fantasies put Dexter on death row
For five seasons, it marshalled its absurdities to deliver a unique, darkly funny show. Then it tangled with the Doomsday trope – and saw its world end

James Donaghy

11, Dec, 2017 @1:00 PM

Article image
When good TV goes bad: how Ally McBeal lost its lust for life
We loved Ally McBeal because it wasn’t afraid to celebrate human flaws, but the death of Calista Flockhart’s one true love knocked the wind out of the show

Julia Raeside

25, Sep, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Leftovers: Lost's co-creator reels us in again
What happens when 2% of the world’s population randomly disappears? HBO’s new show opts for sex, cults and death apps

Filipa Jodelka

15, Sep, 2014 @5:00 AM