But did he die? TV's best and worst endings since The Sopranos

Dexter prompted shrugs, Lost inspired fury and Mad Men concluded with a deliciously cynical grin – but 10 years on, they’re all still chasing ‘that ending’

It’s exactly 10 years since The Sopranos ended. Its beguiling climax – left so open for interpretation that it still inspires debate to this day – was perfect for a series that enjoyed defying convention at every turn.

But have any other prestige dramas managed to top The Sopranos’ ending in the decade since? Let’s rank some stand-outs, from worst to best. Spoilers, obviously.

10. Dexter

Almost certainly the worst finale of any major drama of the last decade, perhaps ever. Having peaked with the Trinity Killer arc in series four, Dexter cack-handedly lumbered on for another four years. When it eventually ended, with Dexter as a lumberjack with a fake beard and a smile like a toddler pooing in its nappy, the shrugging it prompted could be heard from space.

9. Battlestar Galactica

For all the plaudits flung at the Battlestar Galactica revival, its legacy will forever be tarnished by its ending, where God was ultimately responsible for everything and all a 150,000-year time-jump showed us was that we might one day regret being mean to our toasters. Still better than Caprica, mind.

8. 24

If we count the Kiefer Sutherland years as its own entity, then the end of 24 is a weird one. Hauled over to London for one last mission, Jack Bauer foils a terrorist attack, listens to the serving president pray for dementia to free him of all his horrible memories, then gets captured by a different set of baddies and flown away to a fate unknown. He’s suffered worse, of course, but hopefully this time he’s old enough to know that it’s probably best to just give in and let himself be tortured to death.

7. Boardwalk Empire

Boardwalk Empire is not the only show ever to kill its primary antihero in the finale, but the bluntness with which it did so speaks volumes. Nucky Thompson is shot three times by the child of a former protege, right there on the titular boardwalk. He has a vision of himself as a younger man and that’s it. It’s as conclusive an ending as you can get, but the perfunctory way it played out felt slightly rote.

6. Girls

The main criticism levelled at Girls throughout its run was that it was a whiny snowflake of a show, full of endless inward-looking first world problems. The finale countered this by having Hannah level all those same criticisms at a younger woman even more narcissistic than herself. But just to stop the show from tipping into wonky overcompensation, it also set Hannah down a new path of experiencing endless inward-looking first world problems about motherhood. She’ll always be awful, and that’s a comfort.

5. The Wire

The final series of The Wire is notoriously the worst. Bogged down by a fake serial killer plot, and a misjudged focus on the media that came off as preachy and belaboured, it lacked the elegance that made the show so beloved in the first place. And even though a bad series of The Wire is still better than a good series of most other shows, this dip in quality meant that the finale came tinged with a sense of relief. As the Baltimore Sun itself said at the time, perhaps David Simon shot his finale load back in the third series.

4. Lost

“But the final episode of Lost is historically bad, you idiot”, you’re saying. To which I say: nope, the final episode of Lost was brilliant. True, it came loaded with unrealistic expectations; with people tuning in on the misguided notion that every single mystery in this deliberately enigmatic 121-episode series about islands and time travel and parallel universes would be tied up in a beautiful ribbon. When it climaxed with a narratively opaque yet explicitly spiritual reunion scene, it felt to some like a sucker punch. But for those willing to let the mystery be, it was a beautiful, elegiac conclusion. I will go to my grave trying to convince you of this, I swear to God.

3. Breaking Bad

On the other hand, Breaking Bad ended with a masterpiece of ribbon-tying. Yes, Walter White died, but his final scheme went off so seamlessly – from the bullying of Gretchen and Elliot to his farewell to Skylar to Jesse’s rescue and escape – that one popular theory at the time suggested it was all happening in the afterlife. Everything was dotted and crossed with such precision that you’d never guess that it literally caused Vince Gilligan to bang his head against a wall.

2. Mad Men

A prediction: the gleeful cynicism of this finale will never be topped. Don Draper has spent a decade sinking to lower and lower depths. He’s two marriages down, his children hate him, his drinking is out of control, his career is a shadow of what it once was. Eventually hitting rock bottom, he travels to California and learns to meditate. As he closes his eyes and begins to om, a smile stretches across his face. Has he finally discovered inner peace? No, he’s figured out how to steal all this blissed-out iconography and sell it back to idiots as a Coca-Cola advert. Nothing ever changes, and we’re all trapped inside ourselves, that’s what Mad Men taught us. A near perfect ending.

1. The Sopranos

And yet The Sopranos is still the very best of them all. Its final scene, so innocuous at first glance, is a painstaking masterpiece of writing and directing inspired by everything from The Godfather to the end of 2001: A Space Odyssey. The family meets in a diner, and sets about eating onion rings like communion. Tony puts Don’t Stop Believin’ on the jukebox. A mysterious man in a Member’s Only jacket lurks in the background. An uneasy tension grows. Outside, Meadow has trouble parking her car. She enters, Tony looks up and that’s it. Ten seconds of black and the show is over. Either Tony died, shot by a rival, or he’s resigned to living out the rest of his life on high alert. Whatever the case, he loses. But he did definitely die, though.

Contributor

Stuart Heritage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘I’ve never forgotten it’: the very best (and very worst) TV endings of all time
From The Sopranos’ unbeatable conclusion to the nonsensical anticlimax of Game of Thrones, here are the most memorable TV finales of all time – for varying reasons …

Chitra Ramaswamy, Scott Bryan, Phil Harrison, Kate Abbott, Stuart Heritage, Alexi Duggins, Rebecca Nicholson, Mark Lawson, Michael Hogan, Micha Frazer-Carroll and Lucy Mangan

07, Feb, 2023 @3:23 PM

Article image
From ER to The Sopranos: what were the most shocking TV deaths?
Run ins with household appliances and mob hits have all claimed well-loved TV characters, but sometimes the most affecting deaths came out of thin air

Graeme Virtue, Phil Harrison, Dale Berning Sawa, Michael Hann, Mark Lawson, Jake Nevins, Leah Harper, Gwilym Mumford, Lanre Bakare, Rebecca Nicholson and Sarah Hughes

19, Feb, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Sopranos: from enduring TV hit to the hottest show of lockdown
2020 has seen HBO’s mafia series win fresh fans, as a new generation relate to the emotional struggles of its antihero protagonist, and its stars preserve its legacy

Michelle Kambasha

19, Dec, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
From Gypsy to The Sopranos, what do real psychotherapists think of TV shrinks?
The Sopranos put a mobster through analysis. Now Gypsy is making a psychotherapist the star of the show. Does TV get it right – or is gross malpractice just dramatically inevitable?

Zoe Williams

18, Jul, 2017 @6:16 PM

Article image
The Many Saints of Newark review – Sopranos prequel keeps it in the family
Michael Gandolfini is goosebump-inducing as the young Tony Soprano, amid race riots and antagonism towards rival African American gangs

Peter Bradshaw

21, Sep, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
James Gandolfini: his best Sopranos scenes, in clips

As Mafia boss Tony Soprano in the HBO series The Sopranos, James Gandolfini had many classic scenes. Here are just a few

Richard Vine

20, Jun, 2013 @1:34 PM

Article image
The Sopranos: what have the cast bada-been up to since?
Who murdered a cop? Who made £6m from a painting? And who’s flogging Sopranos merch from the back of their car for 20 bucks a pop?

Phill Langhorne

10, Jun, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Sopranos star Michael Imperioli: ‘I thought they were going to fire me’
He played trigger-happy, heroin-addicted gangster Christopher Moltisanti. As Michael Imperioli takes the TV classic on tour, he remembers the time he almost killed the leading man

Rob Walker

04, Nov, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
David Chase on why he wrote The Sopranos: 'I needed help. I needed therapy'
As his mobster-in-therapy masterpiece is named the best TV of the century, its creator says he was just thrashing out his own issues with his domineering, suffocating mother

Emma Brockes

16, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Sopranos: David Chase and mobster Johnny Sack on how they made a TV classic
‘Fox turned down the first draft because I didn’t put any murders in it. People watch mob shows because they like to see murders’

Interviews by Rich Pelley

08, Mar, 2021 @3:12 PM