The Last Tycoon review – glamour, glitter and Nazism in Hollywood's golden age

F Scott Fitzgerald’s novel goes behind the facade of Tinseltown in the 1930s to explore the exploitation, sexism and Third Reich appeasement – but the TV adaptation rings hollow

There is a hulking metaphor sitting on Monroe Stahr’s pristine film set: a giant Shiva head, the deity’s face lovingly crafted. But what is behind its glorious facade? Just the rough inner workings exposed, the bits of wood and wire holding the fakery up. And this, we are led to believe, sums up Hollywood in its golden age, where The Last Tycoon (Amazon Prime) is set, because nobody seems to have anything nice to say about it. Pat Brady (Kelsey Grammer), the boss of a 1930s movie studio, urges his daughter Celia to “please, please find another business”.

The series is based on F Scott Fitzgerald’s last (unfinished) novel. Stahr, played by Matt Bomer, is a genuine movie man. Pictures appear to him like visions; he instinctively knows how to rescue a turkey. But he hasn’t made his perfect film … yet. He thinks a film about his late wife, Minna Davis, might be the one. “It could be our Oscar,” he tells Brady, who is part boss, part father figure. The problem is the Germans, or one German in particular. “There is no bigger film fan than the Führer,” says Georg Gyssling, an emissary from the Third Reich who is pale and powdery as mildew. The Germans won’t want to watch a movie about an actress who, as everyone knows, married Stahr, a Jew. Or indeed anything else that is “offensive to the German people”. The film must be cancelled. Brady, like other studio bosses, capitulates – it’s the Depression, and Germany is the second biggest foreign market. “You can’t have art without commerce,” he says, like a true Hollywood mogul.

Elsewhere, you can’t have commerce without exploitation, and the film crews aren’t happy – they’re organising. “I said the word the bigwigs all hate: union,” says one of the leaders at a secret meeting (try saying it to Jeff Bezos, the big boss at Amazon). There’s a camp of homeless people beside the lot and the bank is about to pull the studio’s funding. So there’s a lot going on – maybe too much – and that’s without the grieving Stahr’s late-night hookups with his boss’s wife, the ingenues trying to get his attention, and the small matter of his heart defect (“One of these days his heart’s just going to explode!”). The Last Tycoon is a bit silly when it’s trying to be dramatic, and some of the lines are jarring when they’re trying to be profound. You may start to care about the characters three or four episodes in. And goodness, it looks beautiful – the people, the costumes, the whole seductive world. But like the giant Shiva head, which Stahr orders back to the mill to be finished, it’s all a bit hollow.

Contributor

Emine Saner

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
I Love Dick review – I can't get enough, please can we have more?
Amazon’s pilot season includes Jill Soloway’s skewering of artist types, starring Kevin Bacon as the titular cultural theorist. It shouldn’t even have to audition

Tim Dowling

20, Aug, 2016 @5:00 AM

Article image
Alias Grace review – a blessed adaptation of Margaret Atwood's extraordinary novel
This cerebral true-crime miniseries, brilliantly adapted by Sarah Polley, is just as well done – and just as suited to our times – as The Handmaid’s Tale

Lucy Mangan

04, Nov, 2017 @6:30 AM

Article image
The OA review – head-spinning drama skips between life and death
Netflix’s mysterious new offering blends angels, parallel realities and nightmarish imprisonments in a tale of gargantuan imagination and ambition

17, Dec, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Marvelous Mrs Maisel review – standup sitcom it's a pleasure to sit down for
Wannabe comedian Midge is back on coruscating form in this superb 50s-set comedy

Jack Seale

07, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Romanoffs review – Matt Weiner's Mad Men follow-up is a family saga gone awry
This unwieldy anthology series about descendants of Tsar Nicholas II tackles grand themes with a big budget and lashings of overstatement

Rebecca Nicholson

12, Oct, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Kevin Can F**k Himself review – the sitcom wife finally snaps in Breaking Bad-lite
The brilliant Annie Murphy skewers TV cliches in this meta-sitcom that takes a detour into drug-fuelled crime drama. But can it deliver on its ingenious premise?

Lucy Mangan

27, Aug, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Wilds review – Lost meets Mean Girls in Amazon's teen thriller
A party of schoolgirls wash up on a deserted island with a seemingly dangerous side, in a series that marries coming-of-age drama with apocalyptic mystery

Lucy Mangan

11, Dec, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Cruel Summer review – Pretty Little Liars meets Memento in dark teen thriller
Don’t expect an easy ride from Amazon’s 90s mystery about a horrific kidnapping. But do expect to be hooked

Lucy Mangan

06, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Milk and Honey review – bee farming meets escorting in rural Galilee
This exotic Israeli import is a sunny, funny, morally questionable comedy-drama about sex in the countryside

Tim Dowling

02, Dec, 2017 @6:45 AM

Article image
Ozark review – Jason Bateman and Laura Linney go wild in the country
A mob accountant relocates his family to rural Missouri in this darkly comic new drama, which simmers with menace but brims with natural beauty

Tim Dowling

22, Jul, 2017 @5:00 AM