Strictly crowns Katya Jones and Joe McFadden in a sea of schmaltz

It was a sparkling sugar-rush of nerves for the BBC Strictly Come Dancing final, a culmination of the winning formula of fake tan, sequins and a little controversy

As the Strictly Come Dancing final unfolded, amid all the glitz, camaraderie and spangles, a mutinous thought formed in the showbiz ether – had this series missed the Ed-factor?

Well, perhaps a bit. Few could forget the former shadow Labour chancellor Ed Ball’s appearance in the last series, including his now infamous Bafta-nominated Gangnam Style routine, where he danced as though demonstrating the tragic effects of lifelong undiagnosed rickets.

However, as the 2017 final got going, it soon became clear that even mentioning Balls was just “So 2016!” The night belonged to the finalists, singer Alexandra Burke and her partner, Gorka Marquez; former magician’s assistant and widow of Paul Daniels, Debbie McGee and Giovanni Pernice; former Holby City actor, Joe McFadden and Katya Jones; and Hollyoaks actor, Gemma Atkinson and Aljaz Skorjanec.

Joe McFadden holds on to dance partner Katya Jones
Joe McFadden holds on to dance partner Katya Jones in the Charleston performed for their final dance. Photograph: Guy Levy/BBC/PA

They all faced the de-fanged near-powerless judges (only viewers’ votes count in the final) Craig Revel Horwood, Darcy Bussell, Bruno Tonioi, and new head judge for 2017, Shirley Ballas, who were all lined up on their panel like the cast of a failed Grimm’s fairy tale. Then there were the presenters Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman – it continues to be remarkable how, since the departure of the late Sir Bruce Forsyth, these mere women have managed to host this primetime show, and in such an expert entertaining way. It could only speak of witchcraft.

All the contestants showed what they could do with their three final dances of the series, proving from the off that, with grace, style, athleticism, Strictly has become the equivalent of the showbiz Olympics. Sure, Strictly’s television dominance this year had been helped by The X Factor committing what amounted to weekly ratings hari-kari over on ITV. (I’m not saying that The X Factor’s viewing figures are low, but a strong rumour went around that, one week, a suburban man putting the bins out too early got more people watching). However, Strictly also proved yet again that it understood its own winning formula – drown the contestants in a vat of fake tan and what a cynic might term even faker bonhomie, and let the controversy and sequins fly.

This year, the major controversy came in the reactivation of what is sadly becoming the annual Strictly race row – in that, despite four past non-white winners, including last year’s Ore Oduba, non-white contestants generally tend to vanish with disquieting swiftness, and seemingly due to the viewers’ votes. This year, Chizzy Akudolu had gone out first, while Aston Merrygold, and Davood Ghademi, had gone out shockingly early, and Burke ended up in the bottom two dance couples, despite coming at the top of the leaderboard after the judges had given their marks.

At which point, one could raise a facetious eyebrow and muse, gosh, what could it all mean? However, is it fair to also factor in how predominantly white most weekend primetime television is? In short, could the race be less of a Strictly-problem than it is a general British light-entertainment issue?

Debbie McGee dances the Argentine Tango with her dance partner Giovanni Pernice
‘Debbie performing moves in her Argentine Tango that reminded a younger and lesser woman such as myself that … I’ll never to be able to do the splits.’ Photograph: Guy Levy/BBC/PA

Apart from that, and the other now-routine row about the fact that some of the contestants had previous dancing experience, this had been a remarkably good-humoured series, topped off by a zesty competitive final.

Highlights included Joe and Katya performing their tin soldier– themed Charleston as though determined to out-do last week’s Tango in which Katya had lifted Joe’s entire body in a human wheelbarrow move usually seen at school sports days during particularly eventful dads’ races. There was also Gemma and Aljaz moving through their show-dance as though living inside their own sparkly romantic snow globe, and Alexander and Gorka performing a jive as though the floor had been electrified and then flooded with Prosecco. And Debbie performing moves in her Argentine Tango that reminded a younger and lesser woman such as myself that, one, I’ll never to be able to do the splits, and two, if I tried, I would saddle the already beleaguered NHS with a gynaecological emergency.

Ultimately, it was McFadden, the favourite, who triumphed, though all the finalists and the other contestants (even the ones who had gone out deservedly early, after dancing like a communal “walk of shame”) were quick to say that they all felt like winners. At this point, the Strictly final descended into what could only be described as a sugar-rush of schmaltz combined with a brawl on the entertainment deck of a cruise ship. So, basically Strictly business as usual, and why not? It’s what the people want.


Barbara Ellen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Too big for her boots? Alexandra Burke’s confidence should be feted | Rebecca Nicholson
Her Strictly performances were exceptional but the British public’s love of an underdog did her no favours. More’s the pity

Rebecca Nicholson

18, Mar, 2018 @6:02 AM

Article image
Fab-u-lous! Ore’s jive wins Strictly’s big night of magic and schmaltz
BBC presenter sees off Louise Redknapp and Danny Mac in the final as Len Goodman bellows his last ever score

Barbara Ellen

17, Dec, 2016 @10:30 PM

Article image
The Apprentice and Strictly Come Dancing finals to deliver record BBC1 audiences

A bumper weekend for ratings as research reveals new tribes of viewers for reality TV shows

Vanessa Thorpe, arts and media correspondent

19, Dec, 2010 @12:07 AM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing final: film-maker Dooley paso dobles to triumph
After a series fraught with scandal, the final and its winner were pleasingly joyful | Barbara Ellen

Barbara Ellen

15, Dec, 2018 @10:49 PM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing semi-final results – as it happened
The competition got serious with a two-dance semi-final, but which of the five remaining celebrities performed best under pressure, and who didn’t make the Grand Final?

Heidi Stephens

10, Dec, 2017 @7:59 PM

Article image
Strictly extends lead over X Factor
BBC1 dance show widens gap over ITV talent competition to 2 million, despite return of Simon Cowell and Cheryl Fernandez-Versini. By John Plunkett

John Plunkett

27, Oct, 2014 @10:57 AM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing scores X Factor double | TV ratings - 27/28 October
BBC1 show pulls in 9.6 million on Saturday and 9.2 million on Sunday – beating its rival on both days for the first time. By John Plunkett

John Plunkett

29, Oct, 2012 @11:56 AM

Article image
Eamonn Holmes: Strictly no reality show fan | Media Monkey
Media Monkey: Sky breakfast presenter hits out at Strictly Come Dancing, The X Factor and The Apprentice


01, Nov, 2010 @11:00 AM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing 2018 results: Seann Walsh and Katya Jones survive – as it happened
After a week of controversy, the 13 remaining couples found out who was leaving the dancefloor. Join Heidi Stephens as she followed all the Sunday night actionStrictly a show trial: why all the fuss about Seann and Katya’s snog?

Heidi Stephens

14, Oct, 2018 @7:29 PM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing steps ahead of The X Factor
BBC1 dance show is ahead of ITV1 singing rival for the first time this year, pulling in an average of 10.2 million viewers. By Jason Deans

Jason Deans

31, Oct, 2011 @11:02 AM