What did Black-ish's police brutality episode get right?

The ABC sitcom took on the divisive subject last night and shone light on conversations that are taking place across the US

The memory is so clear that it’s hard to believe it was 25 years ago. Living in suburban Louisville, Kentucky, it was the first time – outside of watching the television miniseries, Roots – that I was confronted with the brutal evidence of white supremacy in America. On my television screen was a black man, Rodney King, being beaten unconscious by several police officers.

At 15, I didn’t know what to make of it. Of course, I wasn’t totally naive. I’d been in the car many times with my dad when he was being pulled over by a cop. I’d watched with confusion the series of careful movements he made, the words of submission that came from his mouth. I listened intently to the admonitions he gave me, and later my brother, once we started driving.

Even still, it wouldn’t be until seven years later, after reading about Amadou Diallo (shot 41 times by police), that I would realize that what was happening to unarmed black people across the country were not isolated incidents – a bad apple or two – but something more insidious: a system that is rotten at the root.

So as I anticipated watching last night’s episode of ABC’s Black-ish, I was very interested in how they would approach the issue of injustice on, of all things, a sitcom. Would they placate their white viewers or would they tell the raw, unfiltered truth about the heart-wrenching process that many of us go through when we hear about yet another child, man or woman being treated unjustly?

Fortunately, they didn’t do either of these. What the cast and crew of Black-ish did was something far more significant. The show expertly highlighted the range of responses these events stir in black families.

When racism and white supremacy bears fruit in the form of dead or abused black bodies, the response from those affected will always be varied and complex. Dre’s mother and father were angered but not even remotely surprised by the events that unfolded on the show (a jury decided to not indict a cop who’d killed an unarmed black teenager; protests and riots followed). Their response drew on their experiences in previous riots, and they hilariously attempted to prepare the family.

Dre, the father, was angry. He was resolute in his belief that most cops are bad and thought that giving his children a “heads up” on what the real world held for them was the only way to protect them. Rainbow, the mother, disagreed. Rainbow held on to the hope that justice would be served. Despite it all, she didn’t believe that things were “that bad”. The teenage children also had some unique responses. The daughter tried to ignore what was happening until her brother decided that he wanted to join the protest. Then, her fear of losing him fueled a breakdown causing her to acknowledge how she was being affected.

And the youngest two, Diane and Jack? That’s where the myriad responses highlighted seem to land on the same page. The grandparents, the parents and the older siblings all want to protect the hearts and minds of the babies. They just don’t agree on how to go about doing that. And that is likely the struggle of most black families in America today.

See, social media didn’t exist 25 years ago when Rodney King was beaten. It was fairly easy for my mother and father to shut off the TV and not talk about it. And that’s what they did. But as the show so aptly noted, that’s not possible today. My daughter, as devastating as this is for me to know, will be exposed whether I like it or not. A teenager today can just as easily watch an unarmed black man being shot by a cop on their newsfeed as they can learn the latest dance.

So whether, like Dre, your heart is ripping apart because you feel helpless in stopping this systematic devaluing of black people, or like Rainbow, you feel like we need to always hold on to the hope that maybe, just maybe, the system will work at least once for us, we all want to shelter our children from the hurt that comes when racism rears its ugly head. We all care about how our children are processing the images they see and the impact of those images on their own sense of value and worth.

This range of nuanced and complex responses from each character is what resonated with me the most in this episode. It was the most true. To think that all black people respond the same way to these issues is, at worst, dehumanizing.


Tracey M Lewis-Giggetts

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Black-ish takes on police brutality in a 'very special episode'
The latest episode, which puts the family firmly in the age of #BlackLivesMatter, is not the first show to tackle black Americans’ relationships with police

Brian Moylan

24, Feb, 2016 @4:49 PM

Article image
Fall 2014 shows embrace minority leads as networks realise that diversity sells
The most-viewed channel’s newest shows have largely white casts while ABC and NBC bet big on a range of Latino, African American and Asian characters

Brian Moylan

11, Sep, 2014 @6:29 PM

Article image
Rachel Lindsay becomes first-ever black Bachelorette
The lawyer and former Bachelor contestant is the first African American lead of either show in the franchise, which has been criticized for its lack of diversity

Guardian staff

14, Feb, 2017 @7:49 PM

Article image
Superheroes, singers and spaceships: what can we expect from TV next?
This year’s upfronts have revealed a Katy Perry-starring American Idol reboot, more DC and Marvel shows and the return of Seth MacFarlane

Charles Bramesco

19, May, 2017 @4:43 PM

Article image
The Muppets upstage Tyra Banks – what we learned at the TCAs, week two
Kermit and Miss Piggy – apparently in the midst of a breakup – were the main draw as the industry event continued in Pasadena, where Empire also shined

LaToya Ferguson

10, Aug, 2015 @8:41 PM

Article image
A 24 season without Jack Bauer? What we learned at the TCAs
SF is booming, the traditional sitcom is coming back, and an X Files reboot could soon be gracing our screens. Here’s a roundup of the news from the conference where the major networks announced their news

LaToya Ferguson

20, Jan, 2015 @5:09 PM

Article image
Scandal's police brutality episode was TV wish fulfillment writ large
The Lawn Chair focused on a racially charged shooting and managed to create a gripping if slightly unbelievable slice of TV as timely as it was hard-hitting

LaToya Ferguson

06, Mar, 2015 @10:04 PM

Article image
Lady Gaga goes mainstream with a twist on Thanksgiving TV special
Singer-songwriter famous for meat dress and other outlandish outfits tries tradition on for size as US celebrates annual holiday

Hadley Freeman in New York

25, Nov, 2011 @4:41 PM

Article image
Shonda Rhimes: another stirring speech from TV's master craftswoman
The Scandal showrunner delivered a powerful commencement speech at Dartmouth on Sunday, but she's had plenty of practice at creating powerful monologues

Anne T Donahue

10, Jun, 2014 @5:11 PM

Article image
Oscars 2021: looming TV ratings disaster could be calamitous for Academy
The starry telecast keeps the Academy afloat – but plunging viewers suggest the institution is out of sync with the public

Andrew Pulver

16, Apr, 2021 @12:35 PM