Jack Dee threatens to quit BBC Radio 4's I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue

Comedian threatens to leave after listeners complain 'the lovely Samantha', a fictional scorekeeper, is demeaning to women

Comedian Jack Dee allegedly threatened to quit the BBC's long-running comedy panel show I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue after he was told to cut out crude jokes, according to regular panellist Tim Brooke-Taylor.

Brooke-Taylor, who appears alongside Graeme Garden and Barry Cryer in the show chaired by Dee, labelled BBC executives pathetic for taking offence at the show's innuendos.

The row is reported to have begun after a listener complained that one of its best-known gags – about a fictional scorekeeper known as "the lovely Samantha" – who was introduced in 1985 by the original chair, Humphrey Lyttelton – was demeaning to women.

Dee's agent denied the comedian had threatened to resign.

Brooke-Taylor, 73, told Cotswold Life magazine: "We've had terrible trouble with the BBC about the show. Someone complained about Samantha – that it was being rude to women – and told us we had to be careful about that. The writer who writes Jack Dee's links, said: 'Well, in that case I'm leaving', and Jack said: 'Well, I'm leaving, too'. It's just so pathetic, so many things are double entendre that kids don't realise what we're on about."

Lyttelton gave "Samantha" an empty chair so she could sit at his side during recording sessions in front of an audience. She became a target for double entendres and innuendos – a tradition Dee has maintained since taking over the show in 2009 after Lyttleton's death.

Brooke-Taylor also claimed the BBC was unhappy about the panel doing non-broadcast live shows around the country. "The BBC has tried to stop us doing it – but don't get me going on the BBC."

The BBC said it had received four complaints about "Samantha" since the start of 2013. "We have regular discussions with production teams and contributors to all long-running Radio 4 programmes on how we can best keep the much-loved shows clever, relevant and fresh to listeners," a spokesman said.

Jack Dee's agent said: "There had been a discussion about some of the show's more risqué content following a particular complaint, but this certainly didn't result in Jack threatening to resign. The discussion was completely amicable and the Clue team felt supported by the BBC as a result."

The radio show, which regularly attracts 2.5 million listeners, has won prizes at the British Comedy Awards and the Sony Radio Awards. It features instantly recognisable rounds such as One Song to the Tune of Another and Mornington Crescent. A new series of I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue begins on 30 June.

Contributor

Alexandra Topping

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Jack Dee is the perfect host for I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue

Ryan Gilbey: The grumpy comic has taken over from the late Humphrey Lyttleton and proved a hit. But are some presenters simply irreplaceable?

Ryan Gilbey

05, Jul, 2010 @2:20 PM

Article image
I’m Sorry, I [Still] Haven’t a Clue … how radio’s smuttiest show has beaten the censors for 50 years
Innuendo, tone-deaf singing and dreadful wages: as the cherished BBC panel game celebrates its half century, we look back at its finest moments – and its future

Mark Lawson

11, Apr, 2022 @4:47 PM

Radio 4 quiz cancelled as Humphrey Lyttelton goes into hospital

Radio 4's comedy show I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue has been cancelled after presenter Humphrey Lyttelton was admitted to hospital. By Jemima Kiss

Jemima Kiss

21, Apr, 2008 @11:56 AM

Leader: In praise of ... I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue
Leader: The show commences it's 50th series this evening, and yet there is nothing dusty or exhausted about a programme that still asks silly people to do silly things, and gets away with it every time.

Leader

12, Nov, 2007 @12:17 AM

Radio head: Zoe Williams on I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue

Zoe Williams: Anyone who thinks the show isn't the same without Humph, no it isn't. It has a dark new heart

Zoe Williams

16, Jun, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue is greatest radio comedy, says panel
Long-running Radio 4 panel game beats classics Hancock’s Half Hour and Round the Horne

Caroline Davies

17, Nov, 2020 @12:01 AM

What to do with I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue

Humphrey Lyttelton's death raises the question of what to do when a programme loses its heart and soul. Should another presenter take over?

Elisabeth Mahoney

02, May, 2008 @10:00 AM

Article image
Radio catchup: London Season, Independents Day, Rose Tremain drama and Jack Dee on Clue
Celine Bijleveld: Radio 4 admits There's More to Life than London, 6 Music celebrates independent labels and Jack Dee walks comfortably in some very big shoes

Celine Bijleveld

08, Jul, 2010 @4:23 PM

Jazzman and radio host Lyttelton dies at 86

Humphrey Lyttleton, jazz trumpeter and presenter of Radio 4 comedy show I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue, has died in hospital. By Thair Shaikh

Thair Shaikh

26, Apr, 2008 @5:11 PM

If I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue is such a daring show, why won't they let a woman take the chair? | Sam Leith

Sam Leith: I'm Sorry returns to the airwaves for the first time since the death of its chairman, Humphrey Lyttelton

Sam Leith

14, Jun, 2009 @11:01 PM