Kinder Scout 90 years on: UK’s national parks still largely white and middle class

Right to roam only covers 8% of England and national parks remain inaccessible to people from working-class backgrounds

Ninety years ago, the Kinder Scout mass trespass took place, a protest on the highest point in the Peak District in which walkers mainly from Greater Manchester trespassed en masse calling for greater access to the moorlands.

The mass trespass was instrumental in leading to the passage of national parks legislation and helped pave the way for the establishment of Britain’s first long-distance footpath, the Pennine Way. But the dreams of those trespassers have still not been fulfilled. In 2000 the Countryside and Rights of Way Act established a partial right to roam in England and Wales, yet it covers just 8% of England, with the rest still privately owned and inaccessible to the public. This month the government quashed a review of the right to roam in England’s countryside. The environment minister Rebecca Pow says there are no plans to release results of the review, a decision condemned by campaigners. Speaking on Saturday at a memorial event in Hayfield, Caroline Lucas, the Green party MP for Brighton Pavilion, said the decision was “disappointing” and “frankly shameful”.

The historic event of the Kinder mass trespass parallels issues of access to the great outdoors that are now faced by people of colour and those from working-class backgrounds. The British countryside is demographically more white than cities, with a Natural England study showing that only 1% of visitors to national parks are from BAME backgrounds. A 2019 Defra landscapes review of national parks and areas of outstanding natural beauty (AONB) said: “It has felt as if national parks are an exclusive, mainly white, mainly middle‐class club.” The review proposed systemic reform of the governance of national park and AONB boards, stating that only a “tiny fraction” on such boards were of black, Asian or minority ethnicities. A research report by the Countryside Charity revealed the gulf between socially deprived areas and the countryside, highlighting issues such as poor public transport as barriers in access.

Anita Sethi on the Kinder in Colour walk.
Anita Sethi on the Kinder in Colour walk.
Photograph: Joel Goodman/The Guardian

The first time I walked in the footsteps of the Kinder Scout mass trespassers, known as the Manchester Ramblers, was after being racially abused on a TransPennine journey by a man who told me to go back to where I’m from – and so I did: I’m from the north and decided to make a journey of reclamation walking the Pennine Way.

I once again walk up Kinder Scout, this time one of a group of ramblers joining the Kinder in Colour walk, an initiative commemorating the mass trespass and highlighting the issues of inequality and inaccessibility that still remain, bringing people of colour to walk together. The event organisers include Sam Siva, also an organiser with Land in Our Names, a land racial justice collective, and Nadia Shaikh who describes the event as a “coalition”, bringing together other groups campaigning for better access to the countryside including Muslim Hikers, Black Girls Hike, Land in Our Names, Right to Roam and Landscapes of Freedom.

The event centres on ritual and healing. “We want to heal the land and ourselves,” say the organisers. “We want to share space so that our joy, healing and resistances are infused with the same spirituality that we feel when we connect to the land.”

Anita Sethi hiking up Kinder Scout
Anita Sethi hiking up Kinder Scout Photograph: Anita Sethi/none

The history of the countryside is rooted in colonialism, class and exclusion. The walk seeks to change that. Shaikh says accessibility has been considered in the planning: the starting point for the 3km circular walk, for example, is in Edale, taking into account the fact there is a train station there.

Anant, from Manchester, who is also part of the Mad Walkers and Manchester Walkers groups, believes more minority ethnic people should be encouraged to come out walking in the great outdoors. I walk with people of all ages, including a family with young children who are climbing a mountain for the first time. I speak to people from Survivor Alliance who tell me: “We love going out. We’re healing and recovering from the traumas we went through. When we are out we feel free. It’s amazing to meet people and enjoy nature”.

As we walk, there is hope and defiance in the air that the dreams of the brave trespassers for access to nature for all might yet be realised.


Anita Sethi

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

In praise of… Kinder Scout

Editorial: The wild moorland plateau of Kinder Scout would be wonderful anywhere, but its place on the roof of the Peak District national park makes it especially welcome as Britain's newest national nature reserve


15, Oct, 2009 @11:05 PM

Article image
'The litter was a shock': 2020's Covid-driven rush on UK national parks
In lockdown, beauty spots such as Snowdonia attracted new visitors – but also fires, parking rows and ‘fly-camping’

Helen Pidd North of England editor

01, Jan, 2021 @10:30 AM

Article image
The right to swim: mass trespass of Kinder reservoir planned
Ninety years ago, Peak District ramblers defied the law to push for open access. This Sunday wild swimmers take their own stand

Helen Pidd North of England editor

23, Apr, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best of the UK’s national parks
To mark National Parks Week, we’ve rounded up the best ways to enjoy some of the country’s most celebrated landscapes, with expert’s tips, favourite campsites, activity guides – and our national parks picture quiz

Georgia Brown

28, Jul, 2014 @2:11 PM

Article image
Welcome back! UK's national parks brace for staycation invasion
As the Covid crisis eases, the UK’s beauty spots are learning from last year’s litter and parking rows about welcoming record crowds

Sarah Johnson

28, Mar, 2021 @9:45 AM

Article image
Kinder Scout, the old battleground of ramblers' rights, to be fenced off

Sheep-proof barrier to be erected at scene of 1932 Mass Trespass in Peak District

Martin Wainwright

15, Nov, 2010 @4:09 PM

Article image
High on Kinder Scout, land at the end of its tether
Country diary: Kinder Scout, Derbyshire Far from being a dismal, greasy world of chocolate peat, the plateau appeared luxuriantly green

Ed Douglas

19, Aug, 2016 @4:30 AM

Article image
What do you love about England's national parks?

Open thread: Share what you love about the country's national parks and areas of outstanding natural beauty

Adam Vaughan

09, Mar, 2012 @12:25 PM

Article image
More affordable housing 'should be built in national parks'
Carl Lis OBE, chair of National Parks England, warns young people being priced out of scenic areas

Patrick Greenfield

29, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘We didn’t feel it was for us’: the UK’s minority ethnic walking groups tearing down barriers
Hiking groups set up by and for ethnic minorities, often during lockdowns, are gaining in popularity

Amelia Hill

06, Jul, 2022 @1:22 PM