Peak District railway restoration plan divides local opinion

The Monsal Trail is a much-loved walking and cycling route, but pressure is building for trains to return, restoring a direct link between Derby and Manchester

Meandering across spectacular viaducts bridging limestone cliffs that drop into the River Wye, the Monsal Trail is considered one of the most scenic walking and cycling routes in the UK.

With slopes covered in purple orchids and cowslips in May, and ox-eye daisies, bloody cranesbill and a lilac dusting of small scabious later in the year, the trail rewards walkers with stunning scenery across the Peak District.

But this haven for wildlife and geology, and attraction for rail heritage enthusiasts, is under threat. The route is at the centre of a battle between outdoor enthusiasts and those who would like to convert it back into a railway line.

After the closure of the Peak and Dales line in 1968, nearly nine miles of the now- abandoned railway were transformed into a trail, incorporating railway tunnels as well as the Monsal viaduct. In 2011 the four Victorian tunnels on the trail were opened to create a complete off-road cycling route, funded as part of the wider Pedal Peak District project to promote cycling opportunities in the national park.

Lee Cooper-Smith in his old rail van at home in New Mills, Derbyshire.
Campaigner Lee Cooper-Smith in his old rail van at home in New Mills, Derbyshire. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

But now the Manchester and East Midlands Rail Action Partnership (Memrap) is calling for the reinstatement of the Peaks and Dales line. The group says it would “reconnect isolated communities between Matlock and Buxton/Chinley and reconnect Manchester with the east Midlands, to and through the Peak District national park”.

However, almost 14,000 people have signed a petition against the proposals. Lee Cooper-Smith, who started the petition and can often be seen walking the trail with his six-month-old daughter, said its loss would have a significant impact.

“It’s such a beautiful, spectacular place that has the bonus of being incredibly accessible, which is unusual for somewhere so magnificent. It allows disabled people and those with young children in tow to access something wonderful really easily,” said Cooper-Smith, who lives 18 miles from the route in the Derbyshire town of New Mills.

For Cooper-Smith, 48, a railway enthusiast who spent three months converting a dilapidated railway carriage into an office in his back garden last year, part of the fascination of the trail is its heritage as a former railway line, where walkers are able to retrace its fascinating history and the old industries along its route.

A cyclist on the Monsal Trail
A cyclist on the Monsal Trail rides through a cutting. Photograph: Andrew Lloyd/Alamy

“The utter joy of the trail is that you feel as if you are experiencing the engineering of yesteryear, and you get a glimpse into the industrial revolution with all the cotton mills. Walking through the tunnels is very exciting,” he adds.

The trail is estimated to attract 300,000 visitors a year. In 2020, during the late summer period alone, it saw more than 200,000 visitors. At its peak, there were almost 2,000 visits a day.

Cooper-Smith said that because of the topography it was not possible to have rail and trail within the valley. “If rail wins, the trail will have to follow the B6465 road. This very action completely changes, and reduces, the unique appeal of the trail, of walking through the tunnels, along the same viaduct – it just becomes a trail. And this reduces the appeal ofa tourism asset that is partly responsible for the £2.3bn Derbyshire’s tourism trade, which many of our local businesses rely on.”

For more than 100 years, the line, created by the Midland Railway by digging several tunnels and bridging the River Wye with the Monsal viaduct, carried passengers, freight and tourists to the fashionable spa town of Buxton.

The route linking Derby and Manchester was considered one of the most scenic in the country, carving its way through Derbyshire’s great limestone hills, with several impressive feats of civil engineering to help it through the hilly terrain. But in 1968 the section between Matlock and Buxton was closed to save money. The Peak District national park authority reopened the route for recreation in 1981, with the trail cutting through limestone between Blackwell and Monsal Head.

Supporters of the restored railway say the Monsal Trail would be retained.
Supporters of the restored railway say the Monsal Trail would be retained. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

Supporters of the rail link argue that local communities lack access to wider transport links. Some politicians hail it as an ideal opportunity for “levelling up”, and a counter-petition created in 2015 to reopen the railway from Derby to Manchester has attracted more than 19,000 signatories.

Memrap claims the reopened railway would provide sustainable public transport for the 13.25 million annual visitors to the Peak District national park – 90% of whom have no other option than to arrive by car. They also claim research has found that the Derbyshire economy is suffering from a steady “bleeding” effect, due to the lack of proper connectivity between Derby and Manchester, along the corridor running south to north through the county.

A spokesperson for the group said: “The campaign aims to correct this with our proposal for reinstating this railway, which once linked Derby and Manchester directly, with proper attention to and respect for the Monsal Trail and the national park through which it must once again pass. It would – this time – serve the national park better than it did previously.”

High Peak MP Robert Largan said the reinstatement of the line could be a great example of levelling up.

“Re-instating the railway to Bakewell, Matlock and beyond could potentially be a huge boost for Buxton. That’s why I’m sponsoring a bid for a feasibility study, so this possibility can be properly looked at,” he said.
“Of course, there are complications when it comes to the much loved Monsal Trail and I certainly wouldn’t support the trail being closed. That’s why the work that Buxton Town Team are doing to consider alternative trail provision is so important,” he added.

But earlier this week the pro-railway campaign was dealt a blow when the Department for Transport ruled against offering it any funding. Memrap had put in for a slice of the £500m Restoring Your Railway programme, which was launched in January 2020 as part of the government’s levelling-up agenda.

Despite the setback, Memrap chief executive Stephen Chaytow vowed to continue pursuing the reopening of the railway. “While we are naturally disappointed not to have secured the funding we were seeking through Restoring Your Railway, we continue to pursue other, existing avenues via the appropriate agencies,” he said.

Later this month, the Dartmoor Line, which successfully bid for government funding, will reopen almost 50 years after it was axed. The £40.5m line is the first to be reinstated as part of the initiative.

This article was amended on 14 November, 2021 to include an updated comment from Robert Largan, MP.


Nazia Parveen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Steam trains, sculpture and street food: fill your boots hiking Derby and the Derwent Valley
With its Unesco-protected mills, rolling dales and outstanding pubs, Derby is one of the Midlands’ most underrated cities

Sarah Baxter

22, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Peace in the Peak District: walking the Limestone Way
Immerse yourself in a landscape of ancient tracks on a quiet trail created by locals to show off a gentler side of the region

Hugh Thomson

09, Jun, 2021 @5:30 AM

Article image
Poetry in motion: my car-free break in Shakespeare country
Stratford makes a grand opener for Warwickshire’s showreel of medieval forests, Tudor houses and civil war battlefields

Phoebe Taplin

31, Mar, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
10 of the UK's best alternative mountain and hill walks
Snowdon, Helvellyn and Ben Nevis are great climbs, so long as you don’t mind the queues on the trails. Carey Davies finds these walks just as challenging and scenic – but without the crowds

Carey Davies

24, May, 2019 @11:05 AM

Article image
A wild Peak District walk to a great pub: The Three Horseshoes, Staffordshire
Craggy, harsh and wild, this stroll could be straight out of the Lord of the Rings films

Phoebe Taplin

21, Oct, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Peak District: Rewilding the rivers

Andy Pietrasik goes for a walk along the rivers Wye and Lathkill in Derbyshire with the man responsible for restoring the natural habitat on waters long renowned in angling history

Andy Pietrasik

25, Mar, 2013 @8:00 AM

Article image
A musical adventure in the Peak District

Folk artist Bella Hardy reveals how Edale – and atmospheric walks on the Pennine Way in the Peak District – provides inspiration for her music

Maddy Costa

04, Mar, 2013 @8:00 AM

Article image
Bath's Combe Down railway tunnel to reopen for cyclists and hikers
Transformation of steam-age relic into part of Two Tunnels path began over drinks in a Bath pub seven years ago

Steven Morris

22, Mar, 2013 @3:17 PM

Article image
New tourist train opens up Yorkshire dales
Over the summer trains will run from Skipton to Appleby, offering walkers and cyclists a chance to explore stunning parts of North Yorkshire and Cumbria

Teresa Machan

29, Jun, 2020 @7:34 AM

Article image
A great walk to a great pub: the Pack Horse, Hayfield, Peak District
Following in the footsteps of the mass trespassers who battled their way up Kinder Scout in 1932 – then raising a pint to them in the friendly local

Kevin Rushby

11, Feb, 2022 @7:00 AM