Private schools offer unjustifiable benefit | Letters

There is no place for state acquiescence in paid-for education

Your editorial makes good political sense in the short to medium term (“Our schools need radical change to overcome elitism”). If enacted, its proposals could begin to erode some of the unjustifiable privileges enjoyed by independent schools ever since Clement Attlee’s Labour government bottled out of integrating them into the state system at the end of the Second World War when their fortunes were at a nadir. But the “radical” proposals are not radical enough. State acquiescence in private education cannot be justified on ethical grounds. Education and health are fundamental rights; no one should have favoured treatment or be deprived of good provision on the arbitrary grounds of income or social class.
Professor Colin Richards
Spark Bridge, Cumbria

Your editorial rightly criticises the tax status of private schools. One unwanted consequence of their demise, however, would be the unleashing of many rather incompetent teachers who wouldn’t have a clue how to manage difficult pupils within the state sector. I speak from the experience of having children educated in both systems, and 40 years of teaching and leading local authority schools.
Hilary Richardson (Mr)
Croydon, London

Ghoulish calculation

Andrew Rawnsley writes that, faced with a winter of strikes, “the government is minded to try to butch it out” (“This winter of discontent will harden the feeling that Tories have broken Britain”, Comment). The refusal of some ministers to negotiate pay offers will, indeed, result in disruption to normal and Christmas activity, but the refusal to let the health secretary, Steve Barclay, negotiate with the health unions will result in deaths. One side want to talk to stop that happening. The other side have decided that it is a price worth paying in a ghoulish calculation that they can turn to their political advantage.
David Tayler
Walmer, Deal, Kent

Testament of a great memoir

Rachel Cooke writes that Vera Brittain’s name “has certainly faded since the late 1970s” (“A strange sisterhood”, New Review). Yet Testament of Youth is one of the most significant, widely read and acclaimed First World War memoirs, has never been out of print, continues to inspire young readers and has produced a film starring Alicia Vikander and Kit Harington. Brittain’s life and work have been the subject of BBC documentaries, biographies and even Mastermind. A forthcoming opera at next year’s Buxton International Festival is loosely based on her life.
Kathryn Ecclestone
Martindale, Penrith

Food banks can’t do it all

Miranda Bryant’s powerful piece on “Food bank Britain” showed how desperately poor people are coming to food banks in ever-increasing numbers (Special Report). Food banks are now distributing about twice as many parcels as they were this time last year, and demand continues to grow. However, they can never be more than sticking plasters.

They keep the most destitute alive but cannot, despite their best efforts and the tremendous support they receive, resolve the problem.

The UK poverty crisis can only be addressed by government action involving at minimum an end to benefit caps and sanctions and a real increase in the amounts paid to a level where people can live without depending on charity. This will cost serious money. Government must be prepared to establish the necessary taxation.
Peter Taylor-Gooby

A river runs through it

Rowan Moore is right to highlight how the Thames is “London’s greatest opportunity”, and the importance of investment (“How the Thames was sold down the river”, New Review). And, if you look down the river to the estuary region, that’s exactly what’s happening. The Thames runs through some of the most deprived parts of the country. These are areas with huge potential that the Thames Estuary Growth Board is unlocking by attracting global investment and creating partnerships that upgrade infrastructure and provide opportunities, revitalising communities. Backed by government, this programme is anticipated to generate 1m new homes, 1.3m jobs and £190bn for the economy by 2050, along with the UK’s first hydrogen ecosystem saving 5.9 million tonnes of CO2 emissions a year.

The potential is enormous and it would be mistake to think there’s no plan or strategy for the Thames estuary. We’re ready to deliver.
Kate Willard, chair, Thames Estuary Growth Board, London WC2

Pupils don’t need to worship

The Department for Education spokesperson is wrong to suggest that collective worship in schools can be justified on the basis that it provides an opportunity “to reflect on the concept of belief and the role it plays in society” (“Schools call for end to ‘archaic’ daily worship following UK census results”, News). That is one of the roles of religious education. The Commission on RE, of which I was a member, called for an education in religion and world views that is “objective, critical and pluralistic”.

It is difficult to see how that can be achieved when there is a legal requirement for compulsory, daily collective worship that is “wholly or mainly of a broadly Christian character”. The commission’s recommendations should be the basis of changing the law. Collective worship in community schools should be replaced by assemblies that promote pupils’ spiritual, moral, social and cultural development.
Dr Joyce Miller
Berwick-upon-Tweed Northumberland

Rediscovering Tippett

Stephen Pritchard is right to mention the neglect in recent times of the oratorio A Child of Our Time by Michael Tippett, the composer with whom I was closely associated for the last 24 years of his life (“It’s a wonderful life for some”, New Review).

This work’s relevance to many situations in which people have been victimised made it popular among black people in the US, poor people in Brazil and, in Japan, relatives of those lost at Hiroshima.

But things are about to change. Schott is re-publishing Tippett works gradually in new editions on computer. Highest on the list is a new production of his last opera, New Year.

It’s a feature of musical history that composers have been neglected, only to be rediscovered long after their deaths. This was the case with Purcell, Monteverdi and Handel, whose place in musical history is now firmly established. And that’s part of the fascination of music.
Meirion Bowen
London N10

• The heading above the letter about Vera Brittain was amended on 12 December 2022 to correctly refer to Testament of Youth as a memoir, rather than a novel.

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Boarding schools are no longer repressive | Letters
Whether or not you approve of private education, today’s independent schools are a far cry from their predecessors

15, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
We must help poorer pupils, but not through selection | Nicky Morgan, Lucy Powell and Nick Clegg
More grammar schools are not the answer to improving social mobility and preparing Britain for the future

Nicky Morgan, Lucy Powell and Nick Clegg

19, Mar, 2017 @12:05 AM

Article image
Private schools are ripe for reform | Letters
Unfairness will not be reduced by widening access to university; we need political action based on a long-term vision

07, Jul, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
There’s a better way for private schools to help the state sector
There’s a better way for private schools to help the state sector | Laura McInerney

Laura McInerney

11, Dec, 2016 @12:05 AM

Article image
Pastoral care is essential in schools | Letters
The days of dedicated school nurses and educational psychologists are gone, to the detriment of children and society

04, Apr, 2021 @5:00 AM

Inequality is the source of our schools gap | Editorial
Editorial: Address directly the plain fact of vast income inequality, and educational equity may follow


10, Oct, 2009 @11:08 PM

Article image
Relieving Britain’s private schools of their state handout shame is surely an act of charity | Catherine Bennett
The independent sector’s tax status has no moral ground. Keir Starmer knows it and at heart so do they

Catherine Bennett

03, Dec, 2022 @6:00 PM

Will Hutton: Good riddance to grammar schools
Will Hutton: David Cameron's brave education U-turn finally offers hope to those pupils being left behind.

Will Hutton

19, May, 2007 @11:16 PM

Article image
The Observer view on grammar schools | Observer editorial
Selection is bad for children and bad for society

Observer editorial

10, Sep, 2016 @11:03 PM

Article image
Fees for state schools is an evil idea | Victoria Coren Mitchell
Victoria Coren Mitchell: General taxation, not charging the wealthy, as Anthony Seldon proposes, is the only fair and proper way to fund education

Victoria Coren Mitchell

26, Jan, 2014 @6:30 AM