Labour pledges to toughen ‘weakened and gutted’ online safety bill

Shadow culture secretary Lucy Powell vows to target algorithms that bombard children with harmful content if party wins power

Tough new laws that would protect children from being bombarded with seriously harmful online material, will be introduced as a top priority of a Labour government.

After meeting families who have lost children as a result of exposure to harmful content, the shadow culture secretary, Lucy Powell, has won the backing of party leader Keir Starmer to legislate as one of the first acts of a Labour government, if the party wins the next election.

The move by Labour comes weeks after the Conservative government ditched plans to in effect outlaw online material that is judged as “legal but harmful”, and dropped proposals to make platforms such as Facebook and Instagram liable for significant financial penalties for breaching regulations.

Labour said it would attempt to amend the online safety bill to something closer to its original form when it returns to parliament in just over two weeks’ time.

But if it failed, Powell said Labour would legislate as soon as possible to address problems with “legal but harmful” material, impose tough new criminal sanctions on those responsible for promoting damaging content, and create a new ombudsman to adjudicate.

In particular, Labour wants to prevent the use of algorithms and online business models that bombard young people with harmful material on issues such as suicide and self-harm. In November 2017, the death of Molly Russell highlighted the tragic consequences of such exposure.

Powell said on Saturday: “I met many of the families who have lost teenagers from online activity, and I promised them we would act. We owe it to all those who have been harmed online to get this right.

Shadow digital and culture secretary Lucy Powell.
The shadow digital and culture secretary, Lucy Powell, says Labour will legislate as soon as possible to prevent ‘legal but harmful’ material. Photograph: Michael Bowles/Rex/Shutterstock

“Regulation of the online world is urgently needed but, instead of strengthening the online safety bill, the government has weakened, gutted and delayed it.

“The weakened bill will give abusers a licence to troll, and the business models of big tech will give these trolls a platform.”

A spokesperson for the Molly Rose Foundation, a charity set up by friends and family after Molly Russell’s death, said: “We welcome this development, as Molly’s case demonstrates clearly how legal but harmful content amplified by income-generating algorithms can have fatal consequences for vulnerable people.

“It is unsatisfactory that this bill has still not been passed into law. It has taken far too long to get to this point with legislation already being watered down, and this risks failing our children and young adults.”

Announcing the changes to the bill to the Commons on 5 December, the digital and culture secretary, Michelle Donelan, said that the safety of children was at its heart. But she acknowledged that concerns in her own party about threats to free speech had persuaded her to drop the provisions on “legal but harmful” material.

“They would have meant that the government were creating a quasi-legal category – a grey area – and would have raised the very real risk that to avoid sanctions, platforms would carry out sweeping take-downs of content, including legitimate posts, eroding free speech in the process,” she told MPs.

Donelan added that the bill as now progressing through parliament offered enhanced protection nonetheless.


Toby Helm

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK government criticised for failing to protect children from online harm
Organisations representing young people have criticised Tories amid fears that manifesto pledges on internet safety are under threat

Toby Helm Political editor

13, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Changes to online safety bill tread line between safety and appearing ‘woke’
Ministers drop ‘harmful communications’ offence with some arguing it was ‘legislating for hurt feelings’

Alex Hern

29, Nov, 2022 @5:13 PM

Article image
Government criticised over renewed delay to online safety bill
Internet safety groups say withdrawal of proposed legislation from next week’s Commons schedule leaves children at continued risk

Alex Hern UK technology editor

27, Oct, 2022 @5:25 PM

Article image
Online safety bill needs tougher rules on misogyny, say peers
Nicky Morgan and other Tory peers plan amendment to boost Ofcom’s powers to penalise social media firms

Tobi Thomas

04, Feb, 2023 @1:29 PM

Article image
Online safety bill must protect adults from self-harm content, say charities
Samaritans among those calling for people of ‘all ages’ to be safeguarded from suicide and self-harm material

Dan Milmo Global technology editor

14, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
‘Poisonous’: how WhatsApp is exposing UK school children to bullying and harmful content
Teachers say they are powerless to deal with damaging elements of social media and are calling for more parental vigilance

Anna Fazackerley

01, Oct, 2022 @2:51 PM

Article image
‘Abhorrent trolls’ who encourage self-harm online face criminal prosecution, says minister
Culture secretary Michelle Donelan to amend bill that, after Molly Russell case, will place duty of care on social media firms

Dan Milmo

26, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Labour pledges to strengthen the BBC’s independence and protect funding
Party would insulate broadcaster from political pressure, says shadow culture secretary, as Liz Truss prepares to wage war on it

Toby Helm, Political Editor, & Vanessa Thorpe

27, Aug, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
‘It’s heartbreaking’: mother of Archie Battersbee says he was bullied online
Exclusive: Hollie Dance, who fought legal battle to stop her son’s life support being switched off, says he received threatening messages

Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

02, Feb, 2023 @2:48 PM

Article image
Minister refuses to rule out changes to UK online safety bill
Social media bosses who breach child safety rules may face jail if Ofcom given powers to prosecute

Kiran Stacey and Dan Milmo

13, Jan, 2023 @9:59 AM