How ‘free speech absolutist’ Elon Musk would transform Twitter

Analysis: Musk’s past musings about Twitter show desire to reshape essence of its business model

It turns out he wasn’t in “goblin mode” after all. Last week Elon Musk, in his characteristically antic manner, tweeted a series of suggestions for improving Twitter after he was revealed to have become its largest individual shareholder. They ranged from asking if the site’s HQ should be turned into a homeless shelter to whether advertising should be removed from the platform’s premium service.

Many of these tweets were subsequently deleted, including one sharing a meme depicting the attorney Saul Goodman from the series Breaking Bad with the words: “In all fairness your honor, my client was in ‘goblin mode.’”

Whether Musk was being mischievous or not at the time – it’s hard to tell with the world’s richest person – we have to take those tweets very seriously now that he has offered $43bn (£33bn) to buy the microblogging site.

Given Twitter’s pivotal role in shaping the news and political agenda on both sides of the Atlantic, its ownership is a sensitive issue, particularly if it is about to be placed in the hands of an entrepreneur with a $260bn fortune. Not only is Musk one of the site’s most popular accounts with 81.6 million followers, he is the CEO of two companies – the electric carmaker Tesla and the rocket firm SpaceX – that intersect with the regulatory and political spheres.

“The Beltway and EU will have a field day with this,” said Dan Ives of the US investment firm Wedbush Securities. “Musk owning Twitter is a nightmare for many and this will go through regulatory scrutiny on both sides of the pond.” Nonetheless, Ives doesn’t see rival bidders trumping Musk’s $54.20-a-share bid. Musk has a lot of money and a 9.2% stake, giving him a strong position as the Twitter board – which he declined to join at the weekend – ponders its next move.

Change is on the cards if he succeeds. Musk said in a letter to the board on Thursday that Twitter is “the platform for free speech around the world” but cannot achieve this “societal imperative” in its current form and “needs to be transformed as a private company”.

His main concern appears to be with Twitter’s moderation policies. In March he tweeted a poll asking users whether the site adhered to the principle of free speech. “Given that Twitter serves as the de facto public town square, failing to adhere to free speech principles fundamentally undermines democracy,” he said. “What should be done?” He has declared himself a “free speech absolutist” and, in that context, the Twitter-banned former US president Donald Trump must be hoping Musk’s bid succeeds.

However, the regulatory environment for social media is getting ever tougher. In the UK, the forthcoming online safety bill will require the platforms to monitor their content closely for harms such as pile-ons (one of Twitter’s nastier phenomena). Even if the site is under private ownership, it will not be able to swerve legislators on both sides of the Atlantic who want to make the internet a safer place.

Other suggestions from Musk are less contentious. Last week he asked users if they wanted an edit button to rewrite posts after launching, prompting the company to confirm it was working on such a function anyway. He also mooted changes to the premium service, Twitter Blue, such as removing advertising, which raises the prospect of a radical commercial departure for a business that makes 90% of its $5bn annual revenue from ads.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

Investors’ main concern with Twitter is growth, in terms of advertising revenue and subscribers, with the likes of TikTok providing fierce competition for users’ attention. Given Musk’s emphasis on freedom of speech, presumably user growth will come into focus if the company ends up under his ownership.

According to Twitter’s latest quarterly results, daily active users rose by 25 million over the year to 217 million as the company stuck to its target of 315 million by the end of next year.

The drama of the last week should have added a few more users and, given the likely hurdles Musk needs to clear before he wins control of the business, the platform is in no danger of losing its relevance yet.


Dan Milmo Global technology editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Elon Musk completes Twitter takeover amid hate speech concerns
Shares delisted and top execs reportedly fired as world’s richest man closes deal to buy social media platform

Dan Milmo, Jasper Jolly, Alex Hern in London and Kari Paul in San Francisco

28, Oct, 2022 @4:25 PM

Article image
Can Elon Musk really walk away from $44bn Twitter takeover?
World’s richest man is arguing that Twitter has more spam accounts than it claims, lowering its value

Dan Milmo Global technology editor

10, Jul, 2022 @2:51 PM

Article image
Elon Musk claims he has acquired Twitter ‘to help humanity’
Tweet comes as advertisers fear one of his first moves as chief will be to restore Donald Trump’s account

Alex Hern UK technology editor

27, Oct, 2022 @3:46 PM

Article image
What happens now that Twitter v Elon Musk trial has been delayed?
All you need to know about the latest developments in the twisting takeover saga

Dan Milmo

07, Oct, 2022 @10:56 AM

Article image
Twitter takeover temporarily on hold, says Elon Musk
Tesla owner says $44bn deal has been paused until he gets more information about fake accounts

Dan Milmo and Alex Hern in London and Dani Anguiano in Los Angeles

13, May, 2022 @12:37 PM

Article image
Could Elon Musk’s Twitter plans prove a costly mistake?
Analysis: Experts warn against reinstating banned accounts and neglecting moderation

Dan Milmo Global technology editor

26, Apr, 2022 @4:13 PM

Article image
Elon Musk may have to complete $44bn Twitter takeover, legal experts say
Tesla chief wants to terminate deal but he could be compelled to go through with it or pay a break fee

Dan Milmo Global technology editor

10, Jul, 2022 @2:21 PM

Article image
Twitter trolls bombard platform after Elon Musk takeover
Platform says 300 accounts carried out 50,000-plus tweets in ‘organised effort to make users think firm has changed content policy’

Dan Milmo Global technology editor

30, Oct, 2022 @10:54 AM

Article image
The Twitter shareholders set to make millions from Elon Musk’s takeover
Analysis: From founder Jack Dorsey to dotcom pioneer Martha Lane Fox … the big players in line for big payouts

Graeme Wearden

26, Apr, 2022 @5:49 PM

Article image
Elon Musk completes Twitter takeover and ‘fires top executives’
The $44bn deal will give world’s richest man control of social media platform with more than 230m users

Kari Paul in San Francisco and Dan Milmo Global technology editor

28, Oct, 2022 @8:40 AM