UK product safety laws won’t prevent another Grenfell tragedy, report warns

Regulators lack the resources to certify the safety of goods sold online by third parties

The UK’s product safety regime is not up to the job of preventing a tragedy such as the Grenfell Tower fire as shopping moves online and regulators take on new responsibilities following Brexit, MPs have warned.

A third of products are now bought on the web, yet a gap in the law means that digital giants such as Amazon and eBay are not responsible for the safety of items sold by third parties. The budgets of council-run Trading Standards services have also been cut to the bone, according to a report from the Public Accounts Committee (PAC).

Meg Hillier, the PAC chair, said flaws in the current set-up had been horrifically exposed by the Grenfell fire, which was caused by a fridge-freezer. There was also reason for serious concern about “everyday risks” such as toxic children’s toys and the rise of “smart” household gadgets that could “open a door to hackers”.

With “massive” new responsibilities following Brexit as well as oversight of building materials from 2022, Hillier said it added up to a worrying picture.

“We simply cannot be confident that the UK’s product safety regime will prevent the next tragedy or widespread harm or loss of life, or even know where it’s coming from,” she said. “UK consumer protection must be properly funded to get up to a speed and strength fit for the task.”

The nature of the safety risks people faced was “changing significantly and fast” as they bought more online. That websites like Amazon were not held accountable for sales by other brands was a “significant source of potential product safety harm”, the report said.

Responding to the findings Lesley Rudd, the chief executive of the charity Electrical Safety First, said the absence of vital laws governing online marketplaces posed “one of the biggest risks to product safety in the UK”.

“An unregulated marketplace for electrical goods in combination with enforcement body cuts and an increase in online shopping is contributing to the perfect storm, meaning dangerous products are more likely to end up in people’s homes,” said Rudd.

Until three years ago product safety rules were enforced by Trading Standards officers, but issues with household appliances as well as changes resulting from Brexit saw the creation of the Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS).

The OPSS, which is part of the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), regulates product safety at a national level and is also tasked with identifying risks and intervening on nationally significant product issues. The organisation, which has a budget of £14m, works alongside local Trading Standards offices which still undertake most enforcement activity.

While the OPSS had reacted well to issues such as faulty Whirlpool appliances and unsafe PPE, a lack of data slowed its response to dangers posed by the small high-powered magnets being swallowed by children that caused 40 paediatric admissions last year.

The PAC committee said the government had not set out how product safety would be regulated after Brexit. From 2023 the UK will no longer recognise the EU’s CE mark signifying compliance with standards and more checks will be required at the border.

Against the backdrop of a growing workload, MPs were concerned that regulators lacked the “capacity and skills to meet the challenges it faces”. It questioned the sustainability of Trading Standards services – in England their budgets have been cut by nearly 40% over the past decade. There was also a need for specialist science and engineering knowledge as technologies changed.

A spokesperson for BEIS said it was committed to ensuring only safe products could be legally placed on the market and that a database was being set up so councils could share critical product safety information. “While we recognise the concerns raised, we are addressing this by building an even more agile and advanced product safety framework,” they said.


Zoe Wood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Christmas tree lights bought online could pose fire hazard
Which? tested 13 products sold by third-party sellers – with only one passing all tests

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

16, Dec, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
'Killer' children's car seats available for purchase in UK
Products withdrawn from Amazon and eBay after Which? finds unsafe seats for sale

Ruth Quinn

16, Feb, 2019 @10:40 AM

Article image
Amazon and eBay profiting from online VAT fraud, says watchdog
Parliamentary report criticises ‘too cautious’ HMRC and says loss to public purse likely to far exceed £1.5bn estimate

Rajeev Syal

18, Oct, 2017 @7:12 AM

Article image
Amazon and eBay failing to stop Covid-19 profiteers, says Which?
Consumer group finds huge mark-ups on hand sanitiser, thermometers and baby formula despite crackdown

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

25, Mar, 2020 @6:01 AM

Article image
Hotpoint tells customers to check fridge-freezers after Grenfell Tower fire
Owners of FF175BP or FF175BG models should contact company after one was identified as cause of tower block blaze

Angela Monaghan

23, Jun, 2017 @2:26 PM

Article image
Argos extends eBay tie-up to bring click-and-collect service to 650 stores
Deal means 65,000 eBay sellers are expected to offer goods for collection at UK Argos stores by the end of the year

Sarah Butler

03, Jul, 2014 @11:58 AM

Article image
Nearly half of toys from third-party online sellers found to be dangerous
UK industry body warns of ‘wild west of safety’ after investigation into toys being sold on major sites

Zoe Wood

05, Oct, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
Argos and eBay join forces for click-and-collect service

Six-month trial will allow goods bought from at least 50 eBay merchants to be picked up at 150 of Argos's UK stores

Rebecca Smithers, consumer affairs correspondent

24, Sep, 2013 @2:29 PM

Article image
Dangerous fake electric goods sold on Amazon and eBay, research says
One in three UK consumers have mistakenly purchased a counterfeit electrical item online, according to new findings

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

06, Jun, 2018 @2:12 PM

Article image
Fraudsters hijack eBay parcels in a postcode lottery
Refunds to buyers rely on Royal Mail tracking using postcodes rather than signatures, and it’s helping thieves

Anna Tims

22, Sep, 2019 @6:00 AM