Facebook steps up fight against climate misinformation – but critics say effort falls short

New efforts will let vast amounts of false material slip through the cracks, according to climate advocates

Facebook has announced new efforts to combat climate crisis misinformation on its platform, including by expanding its climate science center to provide more reliable information, investing in organizations that fight misinformation, and launching a video series to highlight young climate advocates on Facebook and Instagram.

But critics say the new push, announced on Thursday, falls short and will allow vast amounts of climate misinformation to slip through the cracks.

Facebook has long been criticized for allowing misinformation about the climate crisis to proliferate on its platform. Mark Zuckerberg, the CEO, admitted in a 2021 April congressional hearing that climate misinformation is “a big issue”. In the past, the company has said such misinformation accounts for “a very low percentage of total misinformation on the service” but declined to share figures.

Climate change and misinformation experts have said lies on the platform can spread quickly. The climate denial watchdog groupInfluenceMap in October 2020 found dozens of climate denial ads had been viewed more than 8m times after slipping through the social network’s filters.

In March 2021, 13 environmental groups, including the Union of Concerned Scientists and Greenpeace, sent Zuckerberg a letter calling on him to commit to monitoring climate disinformation and provide more transparency about the scale of the problem.

“Climate change disinformation is spreading rapidly across Facebook’s social media platform, threatening the ability of citizens and policymakers to fight the climate crisis,” the groups wrote.

One recent study conducted by Friends of the Earth, an environmental organization, found about 99% of climate misinformation about the February 2021 power outages in Texas went unchecked.

The study found misleading reports that wind turbines were at fault in the outage had run rampant on the social media platform. It also showed how such theories make their way from the fringes of Facebook to the mainstream, finding that though the windmill claim was debunked on local and major news outlets, the falsehoods became talking points for prominent politicians within four days.

Facebook has rejected the study’s findings, calling its characterization “misleading”. A spokesman said Facebook had flagged dozens of inaccurate posts at that time and limited their distribution in newsfeeds. “Many of the examples in the report cited as not having labels are simply positions that the organization disagrees with,” the spokesman said.

But Michael Khoo, co-chair of the climate disinformation coalition for Friends of the Earth, argues that the data “shows that Facebook and other tech platforms must take far stronger action to limit the super-spreaders, and not put the burden on ordinary users”.

While the study focused on the Texas incident in particular, Khoo said it underscored a broader issue of Facebook not policing climate misinformation strongly enough.

Past studies have revealed other climate crisis-denying posts and resources outpacing accurate information on the platform. In 2021 June, one of the most-viewed sites on Facebook was a subscription page for the Epoch Times, a far-right newspaper known for climate denial.

“Facebook knows the super-spreaders of climate disinformation and should put an end to their repetitive lies,” Khoo added. “We cannot solve social media disinformation by playing an endless game of Whac-a-Mole with known liars.”

Facebook has been criticized recently for the outsized role of “super-spreaders” in sharing disinformation on a variety of topics. In July, Joe Biden referenced a study showing just a handful of Facebook accounts were responsible for pushing the majority of vaccine misinformation on the platform. The president accused Facebook of causing unnecessary deaths.

Facebook in March 2021 began to automatically label posts regarding the climate crisis with facts from its climate science information center, which it is expanding amid the measures announced on Thursday. Through the center, Facebook said, it connected people to “authoritative and up-to-date information about climate change”.

The features announced on Thursday, Facebook said, would further reduce misinformation on the platform.

Khoo, of Friends of the Earth, argued Facebook could do far more. “For a company that makes $85bn a year, a $1m program that outsources the problem they’ve created shows that Facebook is not serious about solving climate disinformation,” he said.

Evan Greer, deputy director at the digital rights organization Fight for the Future, said that Facebook faced other critiques when it comes to combating climate misinformation, noting that the platform had been accused of suppressing posts and information from reliable organizations in the field.

In 2020 July, a prominent climate scientist said the platform was restricting her ability to research and factcheck posts containing climate misinformation. The company reportedly flagged the posts the scientist’s posts as “political”.

Facebook declined to comment further.


Kari Paul

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Facebook announces UK trial to tackle climate misinformation
Labels to be attached to posts directing users to Facebook’s Climate Science Information Center

Alex Hern

18, Feb, 2021 @2:54 PM

Article image
Facebook suspends environmental groups despite vow to fight misinformation
Facebook blames mistake in system for restrictions on groups including Greenpeace USA

Oliver Milman

22, Sep, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
Facebook bans misinformation about all vaccines after years of controversy
Company will remove posts with false claims about vaccines on Facebook and Instagram

Kari Paul in San Francisco

08, Feb, 2021 @11:44 PM

Article image
Facebook policy chief: social media must step up fight against extremism
Speaking at SXSW, Monika Bickert calls for social networks to build ‘counter-speech’, responding to extremism and hate speech with broad opposition

Olivia Solon in Austin, Texas

12, Mar, 2017 @1:21 PM

Article image
Coronavirus: Facebook will start warning users who engaged with 'harmful' misinformation
Users who have liked, shared or commented on posts with false claims will be directed to WHO’s ‘myth busters’ page

Julia Carrie Wong in San Francisco

16, Apr, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Facebook video spreads climate denial misinformation to 5 million users | Dana Nuccitelli
Dana Nuccitelli: Facebook is still struggling to contain its fake news problem

Dana Nuccitelli

25, Jul, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
New Facebook controls aim to regulate political ads and fight fake news
Moved intended to stall spread of false information and ‘prevent future abuse in elections’

Alex Hern

06, Apr, 2018 @7:00 PM

Article image
Facebook funnelling readers towards Covid misinformation - study
Research findings undermine firm’s claims it is cracking down on inaccurate news

Emma Graham-Harrison and Alex Hern

19, Aug, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
Facebook explains error that caused global outage
Engineers’ command accidentally disconnected company’s network from rest of world, blogpost says

Guardian staff and agencies

05, Oct, 2021 @11:46 PM

Article image
Fossil fuel firms' social media fightback against climate action
Industry funds ‘grassroots’ resistance to tougher rules while touting green credentials, study shows

Sandra Laville and David Pegg, with analytics from Michael Barton , Sam Cutler and team

10, Oct, 2019 @11:00 AM