Apple: what is Fortnite feud about and what does App Store ruling mean?

Tech firm is ordered to remove restrictions on app developers steering buyers outside platform

A US district judge has dealt a blow to Apple’s business model by ruling that it cannot prevent app developers from including links that allow users to buy items outside the Apple App Store. The App Store is highly profitable for the tech firm, with analysts estimating that it makes annual revenues of about $20bn (£14m) and has a profit margin of 75%.

Who was suing Apple and why?

The lawsuit was brought by Epic Games, the maker of Fortnite, in August 2020 after it tried to get around the App Store payment system, which takes a cut of 15%-30% on purchases made on apps. Apple had promptly removed Fortnite from its store in response, triggering a lawsuit in which Epic accused the Cupertino company of stifling competition by controlling what apps could appear on the store and how they operate.

What was Apple’s response?

As well as countersuing Epic – accusing it of trying to steal that 30% commission with its workaround – Apple said the chunky fee cut was largely in line with other digital marketplaces such as Google Play and that only a comparatively small number of developers pay the highest figure because their apps require sophisticated Apple software to function on Apple devices.

What did the judge say?

Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers handed down an immediate injunction against Apple prohibiting developers from providing links that steer users away from in-app purchases. It means apps can guide users towards a separate website to make purchases and avoid giving a cut of up to 30% to Apple. The order allows developers to put into their apps “buttons, external links, or other calls to action that direct customers to purchasing mechanisms”.

What does it mean for Apple customers?

The ruling applies to the US, so the impact for customers in Europe is not immediately clear (Epic has filed lawsuits in the EU and the UK). There is the implication that the avoidance of the 15%-30% cut will allow savings to be passed on to consumers. And, after a ruling in Japan earlier this month, restrictions on apps such as Spotify, Netflix and Kindle are being lifted globally – so customers of so-called reader apps will have access to a link that helps them set up and manage their account. Friday’s decision at least adds games to the list in the US (games are a huge part of the Apple app store ecosystem).

Is there any good news for Apple?

The judge could not conclude that Apple was a monopolist under “under either federal or state antitrust laws”, which would have put the tech giant in deep legal trouble. The ruling also refused to allow alternative app stores on the Apple platform. Indeed, Apple won on nine out of 10 counts – it described the ruling as a “resounding victory” – but its tight control of the App Store has been loosened.


Dan Milmo Global technology editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Apple sets deadline in feud with Fortnite maker Epic Games
Apple threatens to cut off access to development tools if Epic does not back down within 14 days

Alex Hern

18, Aug, 2020 @11:26 AM

Article image
Apple bans Fortnite from App Store indefinitely as legal battle continues
Epic CEO condemns ‘extraordinary anticompetitive move by Apple’ in case that could take years

Guardian staff and agencies

22, Sep, 2021 @8:50 PM

Article image
Fortnite could face year-long Apple ban, says Epic Games
Court filings reveal Apple may delay return even if developer backtracks in App Store dispute

Alex Hern

09, Sep, 2020 @9:47 AM

Article image
Why are Apple and Epic going to court over Fortnite currency?
We look at the issues that led the two firms to pick a fight over content allowed on Apple’s App Store

Alex Hern

02, May, 2021 @3:10 PM

Article image
Apple and Google remove Fortnite video game from app stores
Move over payment guideline violations prompts maker Epic Games to take legal action

Kari Paul and Mark Sweney

14, Aug, 2020 @7:16 AM

Article image
Fortnite maker Epic plays David to Apple's Goliath in App Store showdown
Games firm launches perfectly stage-managed attack just as tech giants’ detente is fracturing

Alex Hern

14, Aug, 2020 @2:11 PM

Article image
Fortnite shoots to the top of teenagers' most-wanted games list
Players snap up clothing items as iPhone version of free video game tops iTunes chart in 13 countries

Keith Stuart

23, Mar, 2018 @1:52 PM

Article image
Australian watchdog considers regulating Apple and Google to boost app store competition
Push comes as Fortnite creator Epic Games fights a global legal battle against the tech giants over in-app payments

Josh Taylor

18, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Apple to reduce its cut from in-app purchases as it faces new lawsuit from Fortnite maker
The tech giant says it will halve its commission to 15% for smaller developers from January 2021

Josh Taylor

18, Nov, 2020 @11:00 AM

Article image
Fortnite maker Epic Games sues Apple in Australia for App Store ban
Video game company alleges Apple misuses its market power and forces apps to pay ‘monopoly prices’

Josh Taylor

18, Nov, 2020 @2:55 AM