Group that spread false Covid claims doubled Facebook interactions in six months

Revelations about World Doctors Alliance pages raise questions about platform’s efforts to control misinformation

An international pressure group that spread false and conspiratorial claims about Covid-19 more than doubled the average number of interactions it got on Facebook in the first six months of 2021 in spite of renewed efforts to curb misinformation on the platform, according to a report.

Pages owned by the World Doctors Alliance – a group of current and former medical professionals and academics from seven countries – received 617,000 interactions in June 2021, up from 255,000 in January, according to a six-month rolling average.

The figures are revealed in a report by the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, which raises fresh questions for Facebook after the whistleblower Frances Haugen claimed that the company knew its products were damaging the mental health of teenage girls and fanning the flames of ethnic violence in Ethiopia.

The World Doctors Alliance includes prominent members who have falsely claimed Covid-19 is a hoax and that vaccines cause widespread harm. Researchers found members “used their qualifications to lend a veneer of credibility to claims that have been proven to be false and often dangerous”.

Graph

Imran Ahmed, the chief executive of the Center for Countering Digital Hate, said: “Facebook’s attempts to control the epidemic of misleading information on its platforms are nothing more than performative PR exercises.

“It has had more than a decade to get a handle on the rampant misinformation which has flooded its platforms. But the systems in place fall a long way short of the mark, as this research clearly demonstrates.

“With each new revelation of Facebook’s institutional failure to act, we move closer to social media’s so-called ‘big tobacco moment’, when it is forced to finally take responsibility for the demonstrable harms caused by their products.”

In March 2020, the World Doctors Alliance had a combined following on Facebook of about 4,000 users. This had increased to more than 460,000 by June this year. The increase was mostly driven by the two most prominent members of the group: Dr Dolores Cahill, a former professor at University College Dublin, and Dr Scott Jensen, a former state senator from Minnesota.

Jensen drew international attention after he said extra payments for Covid patients created an incentive for doctors to inflate patient numbers, despite no evidence of fraudulent reporting, according to a USA Today factcheck. Donald Trump then amplified this claim on the campaign trail in 2020.

Cahill, who until March was the chairperson of the rightwing Eurosceptic Irish Freedom party, has claimed Covid-19 vaccines will cause widespread harm and death. Cahill has also claimed that masks and social distancing measures are unnecessary because Covid-19 can be treated with “nutrition, vitamins and hydroxychloroquine”.

British members of the group include Dr Mohammad Adil, an NHS surgeon who is currently suspended pending a General Medical Council investigation after claiming Covid-19 was a hoax.

Graph

Researchers took a sample of the 50 most popular posts from Alliance members, and categorised them into different narratives. They found the most popular claims were “conspiratorial in nature, implying some sort of overarching ‘master plan’ involving world governments, the media and healthcare authorities”.

The ISD also found serious shortcomings in Facebook’s factchecking programme, particularly regarding content in languages other than English.

One part of the company’s strategy for dealing with misinformation involves using third-party organisations to add context to misleading claims. However, a review of the 50 most popular mentioning the World Doctors Alliance revealed that just 13% of English-language posts containing false or misleading content carried a factcheck label.

In languages other than English, the proportion was even lower: 8% of German posts, 5% of Spanish posts and just 2% of Arabic posts.

Aoife Gallagher, a researcher at the ISD, said: “The approach to factchecking content one post at a time essentially acts as a plaster on a gushing wound. Many of the influencers in the Covid and vaccine misinformation spaces produce huge amounts of content, making it impossible for factcheckers to keep up with debunking efforts.”

The ISD called on Facebook to take stronger action on “misinformation super-spreaders”, increase resources dedicated to moderation and factchecking in languages other than English, and improve AI technology to assist with moderation.

A spokesperson for Facebook said it had removed the parent group for the World Doctors’ Alliance, World Freedom Alliance, in July, as well as removing 200m pieces of misinformation during the pandemic.

The spokesperson said: “Since the pandemic began, our goal has been to promote reliable information about Covid-19, take more aggressive action against misinformation, and encourage people to get vaccinated.”

The World Doctors Alliance did not respond to a request for comment.

• This article was amended on 22 October 2021 to clarify that Dr Mohammad Adil is suspended pending a General Medical Council investigation, but was not suspended by the GMC; the adjudication of hearings and restrictions is carried out by the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service.

Contributor

Niamh McIntyre

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Facebook to remove false claims about Covid vaccines
Move marks strongest move yet to prevent platform being used for anti-vaccination rhetoric

Alex Hern UK technology editor

03, Dec, 2020 @2:51 PM

Article image
Tech giants struggle to stem 'infodemic' of false coronavirus claims
Critics say efforts are too little, too late as research reveals vast majority of false claims appear online

Julia Carrie Wong

10, Apr, 2020 @8:46 AM

Article image
Tech firms criticised for 'lack of answers' on Covid-19 disinformation
MPs say tech firms have failed to explain how they are tackling false information

Jim Waterson

30, Apr, 2020 @4:37 PM

Article image
Medical experts v anti-vaxxers: the Covid-19 information battle
Scientists face potential struggle to convince people of vaccine safety as celebrities join misinformation chorus

Ben Quinn and Niamh McIntyre

19, Sep, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Nearly one in six Britons would refuse Covid-19 vaccine – survey
Campaigners say social media firms behaving irresponsibly over anti-vaccine material

Alex Hern UK technology editor

06, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Facebook removes Save Our Rights UK Covid denial videos
Social media site pulls videos by group that Tory MP told to persist with its anti-lockdown activities

Ben Quinn and Archie Bland

28, Jan, 2021 @7:54 PM

Article image
Facebook removes Trump post over false Covid-19 claim for first time
Video in which Trump wrongly said kids were ‘almost immune’ from illness also prompted Twitter to ban president’s re-election campaign account

Julia Carrie Wong in San Francisco

06, Aug, 2020 @2:06 AM

Article image
Facebook admits: governments exploited us to spread propaganda
Report published on Thursday reveals how countries and governments exploited Facebook platform to spread falsehoods for political gain

Olivia Solon

27, Apr, 2017 @8:38 PM

Article image
Facebook removes page belonging to conspiracy theorist David Icke
Social networks still carrying former footballer’s bogus information about coronavirus

Ben Quinn

01, May, 2020 @4:59 PM

Article image
Facebook boycott grows as US activists urge European firms to act
Call for companies to withdraw advertising comes as Wiley is suspended from platform over Instagram posts

Alex Hern Technology editor

28, Jul, 2020 @3:23 PM