Government ‘rows back’ on PM’s pledge to sanction tech bosses

Boris Johnson appeared to back idea at PMQs but sources say online harms bill may not include it

Government sources have rowed back on Boris Johnson’s apparent commitment to criminal sanctions for tech company bosses who fail to tackle harmful or illegal content.

However, the Guardian understands that the new culture secretary, Nadine Dorries, who has first-hand experience of online abuse, is minded to take a tougher approach on sanctions than her predecessor Oliver Dowden, though she is still taking advice.

During prime minister’s questions, Johnson appeared to agree with Keir Starmer that the delayed online harms bill would include a commitment to possible criminal sanctions.

The proposals already include deferred powers on new criminal offence and the bill already contains the power to issue fines, but any change to immediately implement criminal sanctions would be a significant hardening of the proposals.

Johnson promised to present the bill to parliament before Christmas in the wake of the killing of Sir David Amess. That prospect was also later played down by Whitehall sources, saying that would give them just five days to re-draft the bill between the pre-legislative scrutiny committee reporting and the bill being presented.

Pressed by Starmer on what measures he would take, Johnson agreed with the idea of a cross-party approach but also peppered his responses with partisan criticisms, prompting some shouts of complaint in the Commons.

Starmer began his questions by noting the tributes to Amess, the veteran Conservative backbencher who was stabbed to death at a constituency surgery on Friday, given by MPs from all parties in the Commons on Monday.

“I want to see if we can use that collaborative spirit to make progress on one of the issues that was raised on Monday – tackling violent extremism,” Starmer said, asking about progress for the online safety bill, first mooted three years ago.

Starmer said: “Will the prime minister build on the desire shown by this house on Monday to get things done, and commit to bringing forward the second reading of the online safety bill by the end of this calendar year? If he does, we’ll support it.”

Johnson replied by initially pledging the bill would complete all its stages before Christmas, before correcting himself – seemingly at the prompting of the home secretary, Priti Patel, who was sitting next to him – to say he would “bring it forward before Christmas in the way that he suggests – and I’m delighted that he is offering his support”.

Starmer then pressed on potential changes to the proposed bill, saying: “Tough sanctions are clearly needed, yet under the government’s current proposals, directors of platforms failing to crack down on extremism would still not face criminal sanctions. Why is that?”

In a later answer, Johnson appeared to agree to this, saying: “And yes, of course we will have criminal sanctions with tough sentences for those who are responsible for allowing this foul content to permeate the internet.”


Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
PM under fresh pressure on masks as metro mayors unite to call for compulsion; 42,302 daily Covid cases – as it happened
Metropolitan mayors mandate mask wearing on public transport services they control; new Covid cases at highest total for almost six months

Andrew Sparrow

14, Jul, 2021 @5:18 PM

Article image
UK Covid: Sajid Javid warns country could hit 100,000 cases per day and urges people to get jabs – as it happened
Health secretary says ‘pandemic is not over’ but confirms UK will not implement its ‘plan B’ measures just now

Kevin Rawlinson and Andrew Sparrow (earlier)

20, Oct, 2021 @5:26 PM

Article image
MPs back government proposals to reform second job rules after opposition abstains – as it happened
Latest updates: MPs back government proposals for second job reform but Labour motion voted down

Tom Ambrose (now) and Andrew Sparrow (earlier)

17, Nov, 2021 @7:58 PM

Article image
Brexit: Barnier says UK should be able to agree 'ground rules' with EU on trade given PM's standards pledge – as it happened
Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happened, including Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn at PMQs and Michel Barnier’s Brexit speech

Andrew Sparrow

26, Feb, 2020 @5:52 PM

Article image
Schools catchup plan will hold Britain back for generation, says Starmer
At PMQs, Labour leader says children will lose out under plan worth 10% of what was recommended

Peter Walker Political correspondent

09, Jun, 2021 @12:38 PM

Article image
UK coronavirus: cases jump by 1,508 in a day; government U-turns on Bolton and Trafford lockdown - as it happened
News updates: government axes plan to relax Covid restrictions in two areas; Wirral reports 80 new cases; ONS says overall UK death toll is 57,310

Andrew Sparrow (now) and Kevin Rawlinson (earlier)

02, Sep, 2020 @5:31 PM

Article image
Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen calls for urgent external regulation
Ex-employee tells UK MPs Mark Zuckerberg ‘has unilateral control over 3bn people’ due to his position

Jim Waterson and Dan Milmo

25, Oct, 2021 @5:44 PM

Article image
UK Covid: PM warns 8 March is earliest England's schools can go back, if it will not cause 'surge in disease' – as it happened
PM stresses 8 March ‘earliest’ date for schools reopening; 1,725 deaths recorded in second highest daily toll; arrivals from red list countries face quarantine

Andrew Sparrow

27, Jan, 2021 @6:26 PM

Article image
Keir Starmer says PM’s England Covid plan promises ‘summer of chaos’
Labour leader says Johnson is ‘crashing over to the other side of the aisle’ under pressure from Tory MPs

Peter Walker Political correspondent

07, Jul, 2021 @12:54 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson suggests coronavirus lockdown will be loosened on Monday
PM’s says Sunday statement will deal with plans for ‘unlockdown’, and doubles testing target

Rowena Mason and Kate Proctor

06, May, 2020 @12:44 PM