Microsoft blocks Bing from showing image results for Tiananmen ‘tank man’

Company blames ‘human error’ after users in US, Germany, Singapore and France reported no results shown on the crackdown’s anniversary

Microsoft has blamed human error after its search engine, Bing, blocked image and video results for the phrase “tank man” – a reference to the iconic image of a lone protester facing down tanks during the 1989 protests in Tiananmen Square – on the 32nd anniversary of the military crackdown.

Users reported that no results were shown for the search query in countries including the US, Germany, Singapore, France and Switzerland, according to Reuters and Vice News.

References to the pro-democracy protest movement have long been censored in the People’s Republic of China (PRC), where the government maintains strict control over the internet, but the censorship by Bing extended to users outside China’s “great firewall”.

Microsoft said the issue was “due to an accidental human error and we are actively working to resolve this”.

Smaller search engines such as DuckDuckGo that license results from Microsoft faced similar issues around “tank man” searches and said they expected a fix soon.

Rival Google showed many results for the famous image when the “tank man” search was performed on Friday and Saturday.

The move came amid the PRC’s crackdown on Hong Kong, where it banned the Tiananmen Square anniversary vigil for the second year in a row, and growing concern over the extent to which China can exert economic pressure to enforce its censoriousness overseas.

Just last week, the American actor John Cena made a public apology for referring to Taiwan as “a country”, an offense to the PRC which insists that Taiwan is not an independent state.

US-based tech companies have long struggled to balance their desire to operate in China’s enormous market with the censorship demands of the government.

Microsoft Bing is one of the few foreign search engines that are accessible in China, because the company has agreed to censor results for sensitive terms such as the Dalai Lama, Tiananmen Square or Falun Gong.

In 2016, the New York Times reported that Facebook was working on a secret tool that would allow a third party to censor the platform for Chinese users in exchange for the PRC allowing Facebook to operate within the country.

In 2018, employees at Google exposed an internal project to build a censored search engine that the company hoped would allow it to re-enter China. Google had pulled out of China in 2010 over censorship and hacking.

A Microsoft spokesperson said: “This is due to an accidental human error and we are actively working to resolve this.”

In 2014, the Guardian reported that Bing was censoring results for Chinese-language users in the US for many of the same terms that Bing censors inside China, such as Dalai Lama, Tiananmen Square and Falun Gong.

In 2009, the New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof wrote a column about receiving seemingly censored results on Bing when he searched for topics such as the Dalai Lama, Tiananmen Square, and Falun Gong using simplified Chinese language characters.

A company spokesman told Kristof that the pro-CCP results were due to “a bug”.


Julia Carrie Wong and Reuters

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
How Google censors its results in China
For the Chinese regime, self-censorship by firms such as Google is frequently more reliable than the official 'Great Firewall'. By Bobbie Johnson

Bobbie Johnson

13, Jan, 2010 @11:44 AM

Article image
Bing censoring Chinese language search results for users in the US
English and Chinese language queries for terms such as ‘Dalai Lama’ return radically different results on Microsoft search engine

Dominic Rushe in New York

11, Feb, 2014 @9:36 PM

Article image
Microsoft apologises after Bing translates ‘Daesh’ into ‘Saudi Arabia’
The text translator’s blunder put down to crowdsourced suggestions after anger from Saudi officials and social media called for countrywide boycott

Samuel Gibbs

30, Aug, 2016 @10:20 AM

Article image
Microsoft blames 'system error' but denies censoring Chinese search results
Tech giant denies censorship and puts blame on technical error but activists say Microsoft’s claims ‘simply not true’

Dominic Rushe

12, Feb, 2014 @3:51 PM

Article image
Microsoft sued over Bing trademark

A small US design company has filed a lawsuit against Microsoft, alleging that it is unfairly using the Bing name for its search engine

Bobbie Johnson, San Francisco

21, Dec, 2009 @9:47 AM

Article image
Bing hit by costly security loophole

Microsoft has threatened legal action against a blogger after he revealed a security flaw in the company's's search engine

Bobbie Johnson, San Francisco

11, Nov, 2009 @8:02 AM

Article image
Bing: Software giant Microsoft to take on Google in the lucrative search market

Software giant Microsoft to tackle Google in lucrative search market

Bobbie Johnson San Francisco

28, May, 2009 @4:58 PM

Article image
Bing to become default search option for BlackBerrys
Research In Motion turns to Microsoft to attempt to make an impact on the mobile maps and search business. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur and agencies

04, May, 2011 @11:44 AM

Article image
Windows 10 sends identifiable data to Microsoft despite privacy settings
Operating system contacts OneDrive, MSN and other services even if a user has activated privacy-protecting options, report discovers

Samuel Gibbs

13, Aug, 2015 @10:48 AM

Article image
Google, Yahoo and Bing warned by FTC over advert labelling
Search engines told to clearly mark paid-for results to enable consumers to distinguish between them and 'natural' results. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur

26, Jun, 2013 @12:01 PM