YouTube viewers to help uncover how users are sent to harmful videos

Extension on Firefox browser will allow users to record information about videos recommended by site

YouTube viewers are being asked to become “watchdogs” and record their use of the site to help uncover the ways in which its recommendation algorithm can lead to online radicalisation.

Mozilla, the non-profit behind the Firefox web browser, has produced a new browser extension, called RegretsReporter, which will allow YouTube users to record and upload information about harmful videos recommended by the site, as well as the route they took to get there.

“For years, people have raised the alarm about YouTube recommending conspiracy theories, misinformation, and other harmful content,” said Ashley Boyd, Mozilla’s head of engagement and advocacy. “One of YouTube’s most consistent responses is to say that they are making progress on this and have reduced harmful recommendations by 70%. But there is no way to verify those claims or understand where YouTube still has work to do.

“That’s why we’re recruiting YouTube users to become YouTube watchdogs. People can donate their own recommendation data to help us understand what YouTube is recommending, and help us gain insight into how to make recommendation engines at large more trustworthy.”

More than two years ago, the Guardian revealed how YouTube’s recommendation algorithm, the workings of which are not fully understood outside the company, gave “dangerously skewed” video suggestions.

In the years since, users have repeatedly expressed surprise and dismay at the harmful content they are encouraged to view. After watching a YouTube video about Vikings, one user said they were recommended content about white supremacy; another found You’ve Been Framed-style footage led to grisly clips from real-life fatal accidents.

“More than 70% of all videos viewed on YouTube are suggested by the site’s recommendation engine,” Mozilla said. “But even the basics of how it works are poorly detailed. The organisation says it wants to research the answers to questions like what type of recommended videos lead to racist, violent, or conspiratorial content, and whether there are specific YouTube usage patterns that lead to harmful content being recommended. The company says it will share findings from the research in an open-source fashion.”

In a statement, a YouTube spokesperson said: “While we welcome more research on this front, we have not seen the videos, screenshots or data in question and can’t properly review Mozilla’s claims. Generally, we’ve designed our systems to help ensure that content from more authoritative sources is surfaced prominently in recommendations. We’ve also introduced over 30 changes to recommendations since the beginning of the year, resulting in a 50% percent drop in watchtime of borderline content and harmful misinformation coming from recommendations in the US.”

The campaign is a high-stakes move for Mozilla. The organisation gains most of its revenue from a deal with Google under which Google Search is set as the default search engine on the Firefox browser, and though it has been trying to diversify its income streams, a revenue squeeze in January this year led to 70 staff members being laid off.


Alex Hern

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Firefox: 'no UK plans' to make encrypted browser tool its default
Critics say DoH privacy technology could enable easier spread of child abuse images

Alex Hern

24, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
The ultimate internet glossary: from 4chan to Zynga
Know your lolz from your lulzsec, and your belfies from your selfies? Hannah Jane Parkinson is here to help with an almost definitive list of digital geekery

Hannah Jane Parkinson

11, Sep, 2014 @11:00 PM

Article image
Firefox on Windows 8 Metro only had 1,000 daily users
Mozilla has pulled its Firefox software for Windows 8 ‘Metro’ interface owing to low user numbers, with one executive saying it never had more than 1,000 daily active users. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur

17, Mar, 2014 @12:47 PM

75% of the people who download Firefox don't become active users

Mozilla, the organisation behind the Firefox browser, is asking for help. It says: "we need to improve our ability to retain users".

Jack Schofield

08, Aug, 2007 @6:30 PM

Microsoft offers to help Firefox run on Vista

Sam Ramji, Director of Microsoft's Open Source Software Lab, has posted an invitation to a Usenet newsgroup, In part, it says:

Jack Schofield

22, Aug, 2006 @1:29 PM

Talk time: Blake Ross

Blake Ross helped design and develop the Firefox browser for Mozilla.

Interviewed by Hamish Mackintosh

07, Apr, 2005 @12:05 PM

Fox holed

Mozilla's open source web browser Firefox has got a pair of serious vulnerabilities, it has emerged. This from Information Week:

Bobbie Johnson, technology correspondent

10, May, 2005 @9:57 AM

Article image
Blocking web ads is 'as bad as Napster', says data firm
Publishers’ revenues are being hit by ad blocking software now used by 150 million internet users - but what can they do about it? By Alex Hern

Alex Hern

09, Sep, 2014 @6:30 AM

Article image
Interview with Mitchell Baker, creator of web browser Firefox

Trapeze artist and lawyer Mitchell Baker, Mozilla's 'chief lizard wrangler', has steered the project to its present strong position

Jack Schofield

28, Feb, 2008 @12:13 AM

Article image
Firefox 3 launch overwhelms Mozilla's servers

Mozilla's attempt to set a one-day download record with its release of Firefox 3 saw its servers unable to handle the pressure

Bobbie Johnson

18, Jun, 2008 @10:20 AM