Office worker launches UK's first police facial recognition legal action

Ed Bridges, from Cardiff, says ‘intrusive’ technology is used on thousands of people

An office worker who believes his image was captured by facial recognition cameras when he popped out for a sandwich in his lunch break has launched a groundbreaking legal battle against the use of the technology.

Supported by the campaign group Liberty, Ed Bridges, from Cardiff, raised money through crowdfunding to pursue the action, claiming the suspected use of the technology on him by South Wales police was an unlawful violation of privacy.

Bridges, 36, claims he was distressed by the apparent use of the technology and is also arguing during a three-day hearing at Cardiff civil justice and family centre that it breaches data protection and equality laws.

Facial recognition technology maps faces in a crowd and then compares them to a watchlist of images, which can include suspects, missing people and persons of interest to the police. The cameras scan faces in large crowds in public places such as streets, shopping centres, football crowds and music events such as the Notting Hill carnival.

Bridges, a former Liberal Democrat councillor, believes his image was captured while shopping in Cardiff, and later at a peaceful protest against the arms trade.

Dan Squires QC, representing Bridges, said: “What AFR [automated facial recognition] enables the police to do is to monitor people’s activity in public in a way they have never done before.”

He said: “The reason AFR represents such a step change is you are able to capture almost instantaneously the biometric data of thousands of people.

“It has profound consequences for privacy and data protection rights, and the legal framework which currently applies to the use of AFR by the police does not ensure those rights are sufficiently protected.”

Squires said that Bridges had a reasonable expectation that his face would not be scanned in a public space and processed without his consent while he was not suspected of wrongdoing.

The court heard that thousands of people have had their biometric data taken in the past two years by AFR technology used by South Wales police.

But Squires argued that the number of people arrested through AFR did not justify the huge number of people scanned.

The court heard that on the day Bridges was shopping in Cardiff only two arrests were made for minor offences as a result of the AFR operation.

Bridges claims he spotted AFR cameras while he was out shopping in December 2017. He said he also saw the cameras while at an arms trade demonstration in March 2018.

Speaking before the hearing began on Tuesday, Bridges said: “We don’t live in an authoritarian state. We live in a democracy. The police started using this technology against me and thousands of other people in my area without warning or consultation.

“It’s hard to see how the police could possibly justify such a disproportionate use of such an intrusive surveillance tool like this.”

Three UK forces have used facial recognition in public spaces since June 2015: the Metropolitan, Leicestershire and South Wales police.

Liberty compares scans by facial recognition cameras to taking people’s DNA or fingerprints without their knowledge or consent. It says there is no legal framework governing the use of the technology and evidence shows it discriminates against women and people from a BAME background.

Megan Goulding, a lawyer at Liberty, previously said: “Facial recognition technology snatches our biometric data without our knowledge or consent, making a mockery of our right to privacy … It belongs to a police state and has no place on our streets.”

South Wales Police argues its use of AFR does not infringe the privacy or data protection rights of Bridges as it is used in the same way as photographing a person’s activities in public, and it does not retain the data of those not on its “watch list”.

Information about AFR, on a website set up by South Wales police, says it will help the force “become smarter” and make its patch safer.

The force has said it works to “ensure that the deployment of this technology is proportionate whilst recognising the need to balance security and privacy”.

The case continues.


Steven Morris and agency

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Police face legal action over use of facial recognition cameras
Campaigners say technology risks turning UK citizens into ‘walking ID cards’

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

14, Jun, 2018 @8:45 PM

Article image
Facial recognition tech prevents crime, police tell UK privacy case
South Wales force defends use of technology after office worker claims rights breach

Steven Morris and agency

22, May, 2019 @3:50 PM

Article image
South Wales police lose landmark facial recognition case
Call for forces to drop tech use after court ruled it breached privacy and broke equalities law

Dan Sabbagh

11, Aug, 2020 @5:24 PM

Article image
South Wales police to use facial recognition apps on phones
Force testing app that lets officers run snapshot through ‘watchlist’ to identify suspects

Ian Sample Science editor

07, Aug, 2019 @6:48 PM

Article image
Met police to use facial recognition software at Notting Hill carnival
Civil liberties groups say plan to scan faces of thousands of revellers at London event has no basis in law and is discriminatory

Vikram Dodd Police and crime correspondent

05, Aug, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Facial recognition tech: watchdog calls for code to regulate police use
Barrister for information commissioner tells court formal legal framework is required

Steven Morris and agency

23, May, 2019 @2:39 PM

Article image
Police use of facial recognition is legal, Cardiff high court rules
Ruling comes as London mayor acknowledges Met police role in its deployment in King’s Cross development

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

04, Sep, 2019 @5:37 PM

Article image
UK’s facial recognition technology ‘breaches privacy rights’
South Wales police accused of using system with ‘racial bias’ that breaks data protection law

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

23, Jun, 2020 @4:23 PM

Article image
Anger over use of facial recognition at south Wales football derby
Protest held before Cardiff v Swansea as fans say technology is taking away their rights

Steven Morris

12, Jan, 2020 @2:05 PM

Article image
Watchdog rejects Met's claim that he supported facial recognition
Biometrics commissioner says force was wrong to say he backed use of the technology

Damien Gayle

12, Feb, 2020 @5:53 PM