Facebook denies censoring conservative stories from trending topics

Social network has found no evidence that allegations it ignores news from right-wing sites are true, says head of search

Facebook has denied reports that it censors conservative publications from its “trending topics”.

A report by Gizmodo said staff who aggregated content for Facebook were encouraged to ignore news from fringe conservative sites such as Breitbart until it appeared on more mainstream sites such as CNN.

Tom Stocky, the company’s vice president of search, wrote in a Facebook post that “we take these reports extremely seriously, and have found no evidence that the anonymous allegations are true”. He added that what was being alleged would be not be “technically feasible”.

He wrote: “We have in place strict guidelines for our trending topic reviewers as they audit topics surfaced algorithmically. Reviewers are required to accept topics that reflect real world events, and are instructed to disregard junk or duplicate topics, hoaxes or subjects with insufficient sources. Facebook does not allow or advise our reviewers to systematically discriminate against sources of any ideological origin and we’ve designed our tools to make that technically not feasible.”

As well as reporting that Facebook discriminates against conservative sites, Gizmodo alleged that Facebook manipulates trends to ensure that weighty news appears on the list even when there’s little conversation around it. One example given was Black Lives Matter, the American civil rights movement. “Facebook got a lot of pressure about not having a trending topic for Black Lives Matter,” a former aggregator told Gizmodo, so “they realised it was a problem, and they boosted it in the ordering. They gave it preference over other topics.”

Stocky also denied that report. “We looked into that charge and found that it is untrue. We do not insert stories artificially into trending topics, and do not instruct our reviewers to do so.”

After the initial report, editors of the conservative sites expressed their outrage at the suggestion they had been overlooked by Facebook’s aggregators.

Breitbart News’s editor in chief, Alex Marlow, said the report confirmed “what conservatives have long suspected: Facebook’s trending news artificially mutes conservatives and amplifies progressives”.

Marlow added: “Facebook claims its algorithm simply populates ‘topics that have recently become popular on Facebook’ in its trending news section, but now we know that’s not true.”

Hugo Gurdon, the Washington Examiner’s editorial director, said: “We’ve read the report, and it is obviously of considerable interest to us. We plan on working with Facebook to ensure Washington Examiner’s valuable content gets the attention it obviously deserves.”

It’s the second time in a week that Facebook has had to answer difficult questions about how its trending topics work. A previous report by Gizmodo alleged that the journalists who work on the trending product were never explicitly told to avoid outlets like Breitbart, The Blaze or World Star Hip Hop, but would regularly avoid the sites anyway. Similarly, they were discouraged from mentioning the rival social network Twitter in their summaries, instead referring to “social media”.

But at least one story which might previously have been swept under the carpet was trending on Facebook on Tuesday morning: under the headline “Facebook Trending” was a link to Gizmodo’s original news story.


Alex Hern

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Facebook bans women for posting 'men are scum' after harassment scandals
Comedian Marcia Belsky’s 30 day ban for response to misogynistic abuse directed at friend prompts protest resulting in hundreds of suspensions

Samuel Gibbs

05, Dec, 2017 @2:23 PM

Article image
Facebook developed secret software to censor user posts in China, report says
Software developed with Mark Zuckerberg’s support will allow third parties to monitor and suppress the visibility of posts

Samuel Gibbs and agencies

23, Nov, 2016 @3:08 PM

Article image
Facebook announces launch of Ray-Ban Stories smart glasses
Wayfarer-style specs feature pair of cameras for photos and videos, as well as a microphone and speaker

Alex Hern UK technology editor

09, Sep, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
Nudity and Facebook's censors have a long history
Social network’s deletion of Pulitzer-prize winning Vietnam photograph is just latest in a long list of controversies

Samuel Gibbs

09, Sep, 2016 @2:03 PM

Article image
Facebook censors Le Monde's mammogram screening photo
Social networking company apologises after picture of woman having mammogram with her breast exposed falls foul of its anti-nipple policy

Alex Hern

12, Oct, 2016 @8:51 AM

Article image
Donald Trump's move against Twitter factchecking could backfire
President’s planned weakening of social media law may not have effect he thinks it will

Alex Hern

28, May, 2020 @12:31 PM

Article image
Facebook to consider public interest before removal of posts violating guidelines
Move comes after repeated criticism of Facebook from news organisations, charities and others over important posts being taken down without notice

Alex Hern

24, Oct, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
Angry about Facebook censorship? Wait until you hear about the news feed
Peeved about Facebook’s curation of trending topics? Its news feed is reinventing censorship for a technological age, and humans need not apply

Alex Hern

11, May, 2016 @2:37 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on censoring the internet: necessary, but not easy | Editorial
Editorial: Who should protect us online? And who will guard us from these guards?


21, Aug, 2017 @5:34 PM

Article image
Facebook denies pro-Brexit bias
If you were ‘in favour of leaving the EU’, Facebook wanted you to tell people. Remaining, not so much

Alex Hern

15, Jun, 2016 @7:46 AM