Craig Wright: scepticism surrounds bitcoin inventor's identification

Despite assertion by an Australian entrepreneur that he is Satoshi Nakamoto, critics demand technical proof

For years the identity of the pseudonymous Satoshi Nakamoto, creator of bitcoin, the world’s leading digital currency, has eluded even the best cryptographers.

So when Craig Wright, an Australian computer scientist and entrepreneur, outed himself on Monday as the inventor of the cryptocurrency it seemed to be the end of a mystery that began with the first bitcoin in 2009.

Wright’s claim, made in interviews to the BBC, the Economist, GQ and on his blog, has fired furious debate. After his assertion he is Nakamoto, some sceptics demand technical proof.

If Wright is who he claims to be, researchers believe he would own the original 1m bitcoin, worth an estimated £300m. One bitcoin is worth about £300 and there are said to be 15.5m in circulation.

The BBC reported that Wright, 45, had given technical proof by demonstrating that he had access to cryptographic keys linked to the same blocks of bitcoin Nakamoto sent to another cryptographer and pioneer, Hal Finney, who has since died, in the currency’s first transaction in 2009.

The broadcaster also reported that prominent members of the bitcoin community, including its development team, had confirmed the claim. “I was the main part of it but other people helped me,” it quoted Wright as saying.

Wright’s claim was backed up by Jon Matonis, one of the founding directors of the Bitcoin Foundation, who said: “During the London proof sessions, I had the opportunity to review the relevant data along three distinct lines: cryptographic, social, and technical. It is my firm belief that Craig Wright satisfies all three categories.”

One bitcoin is worth about £301.
One bitcoin is worth about £301. Photograph: Alamy

Gavin Andresen, chief scientist at the Bitcoin Foundation, published a blog backing the claim. “I believe Craig Steven Wright is the person who invented bitcoin,” he wrote.

However, the Economist reserved judgment, emphasising that Wright had declined its requests to provide further proof. “Our conclusion is that Mr Wright could well be Mr Nakamoto but that important questions remain,” it said. “Indeed, it may never be possible to establish beyond reasonable doubt who really created bitcoin.”

Techcrunch.com reported the tech community was “pouring scorn” on reports that Wright is Nakamoto.

Bitcoin allows consumers to make electronic transactions without commercial banks as intermediaries and outside the reach of central banks. It is a system popular with criminals.

Bitcoins are “mined” by using computers to calculate increasingly complex algorithmic formulas and uses public-key cryptography. Users have private and public keys, so a person who can demonstrate they have the private keys linked to public keys known to have been used by Nakamoto could cite this as proof. Wright said in interviews he planned to release information that would allow others to cryptographically verify his claim.

The identity of Nakamoto has been the subject of speculation since he outlined the ideas behind bitcoin in an academic white paper in October 2008. The software was developed the following year. But in 2011 Nakamoto stopped all communications with the bitcoin community, saying he had “moved on to other things”.

Other individuals have previously been wrongly outed as Nakamoto. In December Wright was named as the probable bitcoin creator by Wired and Gizmodo. Shortly after police raided his Sydney home and office as part of a tax investigation, said to be unrelated to bitcoin.

This year Wright reportedly approached the author Andrew O’Hagan, to whom he is also said to have given evidence of his involvement in bitcoin for a forthcoming article in the London Review of Books.

In a taster, O’Hagan reveals : “There are three computers and seven screens in his study; rows of computing books and seven dead laptops stacked on top of a bookshelf. The room is lit with two Tiffany lamps and there’s a climbing machine by a green Persian rug.

“He made me a cup of tea and then beckoned me over to his main computer: it was time for him to show me the proof that he was Satoshi. His manner was still that of a man who mildly resented having to prove anything.”

Dorian Satoshi Nakamoto
Dorian Satoshi Nakamoto, who was previously identified by Newsweek as the founder of bitcoin. Photograph: Zuma/Rex

In his blog on Monday Wright posted a technical explanation, including examples of code, of the process by which he claimed to have created the currency. “Satoshi is dead,” he wrote. “But this is only the beginning.”

He said he chose the pseudonym as a homage to Tominaga Nakamoto, a 17th-century Japanese philosopher, merchant and advocate of free trade.

Until recently, Wright was the director of more than a dozen companies, some involved in cryptocurrency, until he divested himself of 12 of them in the space of a week in July 2015.

In a statement on Monday he said: “I didn’t take the decision lightly to make my identity public and I want to be clear that I’m doing this because I care so passionately about my work, and also to dispel any negative myths and fears about bitcoin and the blockchain.

“I cannot allow the misinformation that has been spread to impact the future of bitcoin and the blockchain.”

David Glance, an associate professor of computer science at the University of Western Australia, who has worked with Wright in the past, told the Guardian he remained “highly sceptical”. “I would wait until we’ve actually seen absolute proof that it’s the case,” he said.

Contributors

Caroline Davies and Michael Safi

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bitcoin is a fraud that will blow up, says JP Morgan boss
Jamie Dimon claims cryptocurrency is only fit for use by drug dealers, murderers and people living in North Korea

Angela Monaghan

13, Sep, 2017 @10:26 AM

Article image
Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto denies being Craig Wright (maybe)
Email which could be from account once associated with Nakamoto denies his real identity is that of Australian academic and entrepreneur

Alex Hern

10, Dec, 2015 @10:25 AM

Article image
Bitcoin: Craig Wright promises new evidence to prove identity
Proof of identity may not be enough to win round high-profile backer Gavin Andresen, who has now questioned Wright’s claim of being Satoshi Nakamoto

Alex Hern

04, May, 2016 @3:08 PM

Article image
Craig Wright U-turns on pledge to provide evidence he invented bitcoin
Wright, who claimed to be Satoshi Nakamoto, creator of bitcoin, says he is ‘sorry’ and ‘does not have the courage’ to proceed further with his claims

Alex Hern

05, May, 2016 @12:55 PM

Article image
Who is Craig Wright and how likely is it that he's behind bitcoin?
Separate investigations by US tech publications suggest an Australian could be at the heart of the cryptocurrency and may even be ‘Satoshi Nakamoto’. How certain are the claims – and why was he raided by police on Tuesday?

Paul Farrell, Elle Hunt and Nick Evershed

09, Dec, 2015 @7:16 AM

Article image
Time to regulate bitcoin, says Treasury committee report
MPs in UK say ‘wild west’ cryptocurrency industry is leaving investors vulnerable

Angela Monaghan

19, Sep, 2018 @5:01 AM

Article image
Irish drug dealer loses £46m bitcoin codes he hid in fishing rod case
Clifton Collins fears fishing gear was taken to dump by his landlord after he was jailed

Rory Carroll Ireland correspondent

21, Feb, 2020 @1:31 PM

Article image
Waste from one bitcoin transaction ‘like binning two iPhones’
Study highlights vast churn in computer hardware that the cryptocurrency incentivises

Alex Hern UK technology editor

17, Sep, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Bitcoin price soars above $5,000 to record high
Rising price of the cryptocurrency, now worth four times as much as an ounce of gold, has led to warnings of a bubble

Julia Kollewe

12, Oct, 2017 @4:10 PM

Article image
Programmer has two guesses left to access £175m bitcoin wallet
Stefan Thomas is not the first person to forget a password, but memory lapses are rarely so potentially costly

Rupert Neate Wealth correspondent

12, Jan, 2021 @7:19 PM