YouTube and music labels clash again over 'meagre' artist royalties

Industry body RIAA takes aim at ‘some technology giants’ but Google claims ‘apples to oranges’ comparisons sell its contribution short

YouTube is at loggerheads with music labels – again – after US industry body the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) criticised Google’s video service for the low royalties it pays out to music rightsholders.

In its annual report on the US recorded-music market, the RIAA called out the “meagre” royalties paid out by YouTube and other free streaming services.

However, Google has responded by criticising “apples to oranges” comparisons to subscription-based music services like Apple Music and Spotify’s premium tier.

The row came as the RIAA revealed that Americans’ spending on recorded music rose 0.9% to $7bn in 2015, with streaming overtaking music downloads to become the largest chunk of those revenues.

Streaming revenues in the US rose 29% to $2.4bn last year, including a 52% rise in paid subscriptions to $1.22bn, with more than 13 million Americans paying for a streaming service by the end of 2015.

However, RIAA chief Cary Sherman said that the money labels are making from free, advertising-supported, “on-demand” services is not growing fast enough.

“In 2015, fans listened to hundreds of billions of audio and video music streams through on-demand ad-supported digital services like YouTube, but revenues from such services have been meagre – far less than other kinds of music services. And the problem is getting worse,” wrote Sherman in a blog post.

“This is why we, and so many of our music community brethren, feel that some technology giants have been enriching themselves at the expense of the people who actually create the music.”

Google responded with a sharply-worded statement of its own, defending its impact on the music industry.

“To date, Google has paid out over $3bn to the music industry – and that number is growing year on year,” said the company in a statement.

“This revenue is generated despite the fact that YouTube goes way beyond music to include popular categories such as news, gaming, how-to, sports and entertainment.”

YouTube pointed to the recent launch of its standalone YouTube Music app as evidence of its intention to “deliver even more revenue to both artists and the music industry more broadly”, and hit back at comparisons to services like Spotify and Apple Music.

“Past comparisons to other audio-only, subscription music services are apples to oranges.”

Sherman made another comparison in his blog post about 2015, however, noting that the sales of 17m vinyl albums that year made more money than the “hundreds of billions of streams” on ad-supported streaming services – $416m and $385m respectively.

Almost exactly the same criticism was levelled at YouTube by Geoff Taylor, Sherman’s counterpart at British industry body the BPI, in November 2015.

There are apples-to-oranges caveats here: think of the costs of producing and distributing 17m vinyl albums, and the likely impact on the profits they generate for labels. Still, the comparison is a telling sign of the tension between music rightsholders and YouTube, even though the latter remains an important promotional partner for labels.

YouTube has also launched a subscription service of its own, YouTube Red, which includes music as well as exclusive shows from YouTube stars like PewDiePie. It launched in the US in late 2015, and is expected to cross the Atlantic soon.


Stuart Dredge

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
YouTube star Connor Franta to release new music compilation – on CD
Popular vlogger to release Common Culture Vol. 4 through his own Heard Well label, which boasts fellow stars Lohanthony and Jc Caylen as curators

Stuart Dredge

24, Dec, 2015 @12:04 PM

Article image
YouTube to block indie labels who don't sign up to new music service
Starting internal tests of subscription service but faces accusation of 'catastrophic error of judgement'

Stuart Dredge and Dominic Rushe

17, Jun, 2014 @2:03 PM

Article image
Will YouTube really block indie labels if they snub its new music service?
Ugly dispute with indie labels is provoking anger online, so what are the facts – and rumours – about YouTube's streaming plans? By Stuart Dredge

Stuart Dredge

18, Jun, 2014 @9:49 AM

Article image
YouTube subscription music licensing strikes wrong notes with indie labels
Trade association WIN gives online video giant 24 hours to rescind 'indefensible' letters for upcoming Spotify-style service. By Stuart Dredge

Stuart Dredge

22, May, 2014 @8:41 PM

Article image
Nikki Sixx launches campaign to get YouTube to ‘do the right thing’ over music royalties
Mötley Crüe and Sixx:AM co-founder wants to swell the chorus of criticism of Google service from musicians and persuade it to up its payouts

Stuart Dredge

25, Apr, 2016 @3:00 AM

Article image
Talks with indie labels stall over YouTube music subscription service
Independent labels from around the globe lambast YouTube with scathing comments over 'unnecessary and indefensible' actions. By Samuel Gibbs

Samuel Gibbs

23, May, 2014 @2:45 PM

Article image
YouTube owner Google poised to take stake in Vevo
Deal thought to be worth about £42m for stake of close to 10% in music video website founded by Universal and Sony. By Mark Sweney

Mark Sweney

17, Jan, 2013 @12:39 PM

Article image
YouTube 'stupid' to pick a fight with indie labels, says Billy Bragg
Musician compares Google-owned site to Big Brother after allegations of bullying tactics in row over music licensing. By Stuart Dredge

Stuart Dredge

04, Jun, 2014 @4:35 PM

Article image
YouTube is built on the back of stolen content says Trent Reznor
Nine Inch Nails musician and Apple Music executive joins music industry’s debate over Google’s video service, but YouTube hits back

Stuart Dredge

15, Jun, 2016 @9:13 PM

Article image
YouTube trains its sights on traditional TV: 'It's a no-growth business'
Head of content and business operations, Robert Kyncl says the future for online video is small screens: ‘It’s all mobile, mobile, mobile’

Stuart Dredge

02, Jun, 2015 @6:40 PM