Silicon Valley's biotech firms: 'Theranos gave us a black eye'

Despite signs of crisis among science startups, many still think that biotech will create companies so powerful that they will ‘win’ the 21st century

It was noon on a Thursday at a gathering of science startups in San Francisco. The public market for biotechnology stock had dropped 25% in two months. The private sector’s star startup, Theranos, valued at $9bn, has begun to implode. The most popular food tech startup, Hampton Creek, which is trying to reinvent mayonnaise, has reportedly stretched the truth of their science.

And yet there was no sign of trouble on that sunny afternoon.

“The fourth industrial revolution is happening right now, right here,” the IndieBio incubator program director Ryan Bethencourt said, gesturing toward his startups. That day, IndieBio’s 14 startups, which had each received $250,000 in funding, were hoping to raise millions more.

How do tech investors, who are often just guys from Stanford University’s Sigma Nu fraternity with little science background (“crossover investors”, as Bethencourt calls them) get sold on investing into biotech startups and how smart is their money? Last year was the biggest ever for venture capital funding into the biotech sector with over $7.4bn invested, according to a report from MoneyTree, but this year is looking to be much more difficult.

A bouncer on the sidewalk let attendees pass into the cavernous rustic wood and copper refurbished warehouse, full of gold balloons and orchids.

In the warehouse, Bethencourt stood by a red velvet rope set up in the middle of the room. It separated those 400 attendees from the startup founders, who hawked their technology – engineered shrimp replacement and cheaper cell assay technologies – to the VIPs. Bethencourt nodded at a bouncer to unclasp the rope as people came toward him: “He can get in, yeah you’re good” or “Hey, sorry guys.”

“It sucks Theranos has given us a black eye,” Arvind Gupta said. “But who gives a shit? The truth is still: whoever wins in biology wins the 21st century.”

Gupta, wearing tennis shoes with a plant pattern, started talking about his companies, a set of futuristic, ambitious startups that each waver on that knife edge between real and imaginary.

“Today, you’re going to see someone present for the first time ever a cure for cancer – I almost can’t say it,” Gupta said, covering his mouth. “These aren’t apps to help you buy wine without leaving your couch.”

“We’re not even gonna talk about it, but I’m one of the only people in the world that’s eaten a dinosaur,” Gupta said, of his startup Gelzen that recreates animal protein in gummy form. “We can’t even talk about it here because it’s too far out there.”

Investors took their seats. Gupta, whose title “the architect” flashes on screen, starts: “Biology is the most powerful technology ever created. DNA is software, protein are hardware, cells are factories. The world has a huge number of trillion-dollar problems wanting to be solved and biology is the only way to do that.”

Bethencourt goes by “hustler in chief”. The words “speed is safety” flash on the screen.

The dinosaur protein gummy bear maker stands on stage: “Evolution is a constraint,” he says, holding a gummy bear aloft.

Another presenter says he’s reprogramming cancer to die: “It’s like blowing up the death star from the inside. This may sound like science fiction, but in the last few weeks, we’ve made it science fact!”

A woman presents a fake shrimp made from plant material and of which a chef at Google has already ordered 200lb. “Our shrimp outperforms its ocean counterpart,” she said. “We de-risk the supply chain.”

The audience, a few drinks in by 2pm, started getting rowdy. One of the bouncers had to kick someone out, and he went stumbling through the crowd toward the door.

A pasta company consultant, Andrew Pederson, was on assignment for Barilla Foods. “Look around,” he said. “Who’s in food and agriculture here? Who’s in medicine? Who has the expertise to make any judgments about these companies?”

Food and agriculture is new and unfamiliar, so it’s appealing Pederson said, especially as the app economy seems overblown and overvalued. “They’re right this space is gonna grow. It’s going to be huge,” he said. “But look at this party. I’ve never seen anything like it. So many people in this room are gonna get hosed.”

Rohit Sharma, a venture capitalist with True Ventures, thinks biotech is safer for investing than the rest of the tech industry right now. “In biotech, we’re not in the same up and down cadence as the rest of the industries. Companies are more aware of the longevity of their endeavor in biotech,” Sharma said. “And behind each cycle of computing there’s a bump in biotech, which is just starting now.”

A few days later, at the IndieBio headquarters, Bethencourt, who previously made a name for himself as a body hacker bent on fusing his body with technology, led a tour of the lab. “We build companies out of the valley of death,” Bethencourt said. “That’s what we do in biotech. That’s what we’ll do if it all crashes.”

For good measure, he added one of the catchphrases: “What other people call impossible, we call inevitable.”

Gupta agreed. “Hype tends to precede the reality in biotech, but the reality does follow,” he said.



Nellie Bowles in San Francisco

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Theranos could be banned from running labs for two years, regulators warn
Blood-testing startup accused of not resolving issues found during inspection earlier this year that created ‘immediate jeopardy to patient health and safety’

Jemima Kiss in San Francisco

13, Apr, 2016 @7:46 PM

Article image
Elizabeth Holmes to be sentenced this week as Theranos saga nears conclusion
The blood testing company’s founder could serve up to 20 years in prison after she was convicted in January on four counts of fraud

Kari Paul in San Francisco

14, Nov, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Theranos to close its labs and blood-testing centers and lose 340 staff
Embattled founder Elizabeth Holmes once boasted her $9bn business would change the world, but Theranos’s decline is now a cautionary tale

Agencies, and Olivia Solon in San Francisco

06, Oct, 2016 @7:00 PM

Article image
Theranos and its founder Elizabeth Holmes charged with 'massive fraud'
Federal agency calls disgraced firm, which allegedly deceived investors of $700m, ‘an important lesson for Silicon Valley’

Julia Carrie Wong in San Francisco

14, Mar, 2018 @6:48 PM

Article image
Theranos blood-testing lab poses 'immediate' risk – US government
‘Immediate corrective action’ is needed at the blood-testing firm’s California lab, a health agency has told the Silicon Valley unicorn

Nicky Woolf in San Francisco

27, Jan, 2016 @11:16 PM

Article image
Silicon Valley's poorest workers tell government 'we can't live like this'
Despite the tech boom, cafeteria staff, security workers and bus drivers have told US labor secretary Thomas Perez they feel like ‘second-class citizens’

Julia Carrie Wong in San Francisco

28, Jan, 2016 @10:25 PM

Article image
How wealth of Silicon Valley's tech elite created a world apart
Private shuttles taking workers to and from Google, Apple, Facebook and Twitter in San Francisco are becoming symbols for alienation and division as residents struggle with crowded municipal bus services and poor facilities

Rory Carroll

25, May, 2013 @11:04 PM

Article image
Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes charged with criminal fraud
Ramesh Balwani, former president of blood-testing startup, also charged and
pair appear in federal court hours after Holmes quits as CEO

Olivia Solon in San Francisco

15, Jun, 2018 @10:13 PM

Article image
Billionaire claims he has been harassed after blocking access to public beach
Silicon Valley venture capitalist Vinod Khosla sues two California agencies as part of protracted legal battle over public access to beach on his property

Olivia Solon in San Francisco

17, Oct, 2016 @8:38 PM

Article image
Scraping by on six figures? Tech workers feel poor in Silicon Valley's wealth bubble
Big tech companies pay some of the country’s best salaries. But workers claim the high cost of living in the Bay Area has them feeling financially strained

Olivia Solon

27, Feb, 2017 @11:00 AM