Samsung plans to outspend Iceland's GDP on advertising and marketing

South Korean company keeps up aggressive marketing campaign to make brand 'aspirational' in spend that dwarfs rival Apple's

Samsung Electronics is expected to spend around $14bn - more than Iceland's GDP - on advertising and marketing this year, but it doesn't always get value for money. 

The outlay buys the South Korean technology giant publicity in TV and cinema ads, on billboards, and at sports and arts events from the Sydney Opera House to New York's Radio City Music Hall. Google spent less on buying Motorola's handset business.

And Samsung, which has a market value of $227bn, has made no secret of keeping up its aggressive marketing and promotion splurge as it seeks to make its brand as aspirational as Apple's. But the money it's spending doesn't always bring the desired result.

Last month, a Samsung-sponsored short-film contest finale at the Sydney Opera House received poor reviews for blatant product placement in a series of 'behind the scenes' videos. In Britain, viewers panned a product placement deal with ITV's popular X-Factor talent show. "Is this a singing competition or an extended Samsung advert?" asked Twitter user Ryan Browne.

Earlier this year, Samsung's New York launch of its latest top-of-the-range Galaxy smartphone came under fire for being sexist, portraying giggling women chatting about jewelery and nail polish while the men discussed the new phone, and the company's new fridge and washing machine launch in South Africa drew similar complaints as it featured female dancers in swimsuits.

"Samsung's marketing is too much focused on projecting an image they aspire to: being innovative and ahead of the pack," said Oh Jung-suk, associate professor at the business school of Seoul National University. "They are failing to efficiently bridge the gap between the aspiration and how consumers actually respond to the campaign. It's got to be more aligned."

Samsung spends a bigger chunk of its annual revenue on advertising and promotion than any other of the world's top 20 companies by sales: 5.4%, according to Thomson Reuters data. Apple spends just 0.6%, and General Motors 3.5%.

"When your brand doesn't have a clear identity, as is the case with Samsung, to keep spending is probably the best strategy," said Moon Ji-hun, head of brand consultant Interbrand's Korean operation. "But maintaining marketing spend at that level in the longer term wouldn't bring much more benefit. No one can beat Samsung in terms of (ad) presence, and I doubt whether keeping investing at this level is effective."

In a statement to Reuters, Samsung said it will "continue to leverage our brand power to maintain growth momentum, while focusing on optimizing the efficiency of our marketing activities," reiterating recent comments by its co-CEO.

"Our product innovation and marketing strategy have made Samsung the world's most preferred smartphone brand," J.K. Shin, who also heads the group's mobile business, told investors recently. "Now we'll move from the most preferred brand to become one of the world's leading aspirational brands."

Innovating or following?

Samsung's 'Next Big Thing,' and 'It's Time to Change' marketing campaigns stress that its products are cutting-edge, and even trumpet its technology 'world firsts' before they're ready for prime time, such as curved smartphones, available only in South Korea, and curved TVs that cost nearly $10,000.

For a company long seen as a follower, this is now a big sell on it being an innovator.

But, while Samsung has become the world's biggest advertiser, spending $4.3bn on ads alone last year, its global brand value of $39.6bn is less than half that of Apple, which spent only $1bn on advertising, according to Interbrand and ad researcher Ad Age.

To be sure, Samsung has a more diverse range of mobile products, which along with its chips and household appliance businesses need more marketing across different target audiences. But the heavy marketing spend suggests a need to convince consumers that it belongs at the top. Apple can afford to spend less as it already has that brand recognition, and cachet.

"The stronger, more differentiated the product, the less it needs to be propped up by advertising," said Horace Dediu, founder of independent research firm Asymco and a former Nokia business development manager, referring to Apple's ad spend.

Defending its marketing budget, Samsung can point to its lead in the global smartphone market - it sells one in every three smartphones and has more than double Apple's market share. The Korean group's savvy adverts mocking Apple devotees, and heavy investment in distribution channels have strengthened its Galaxy mobile brand.

"The Galaxy brand has established itself, and the Samsung brand is now much stronger than Android or any of the other OEM brands, except Apple," said Benedict Evans, an independent technology and media consultant in London. "The underlying problem is that Samsung has established itself as a dependable quality brand, not a differentiated or premium quality product, so it does best where it's not competing directly with Apple."

Samsung works with a number of advertising agencies, including Publicis Groupe, Interpublic Group, and MDC Partners.

Low gear

Samsung's latest marketing splash has been on its Galaxy Gear smartwatch, which has been almost universally panned by reviewers. The device has been aggressively marketed through adverts and collaboration with fashion shows - yet only 800,000 Gears have been shipped since its launch two months ago. Compare that to the more than 5m Note 3 smartphones that have been shipped since its late September launch, and it suggests fewer than a fifth of the Note buyers are also getting the accessory device.

Undeterred, Samsung has vowed more Gear promotions for the crucial year-end holiday season as it seeks to lead the wearable computer market and prove its innovation credentials.

"Probably Samsung knows better than anyone that Gear will not become a mainstream product. Still, they are trying to convey the message that 'we are first with such technology,' which they hope will help build their brand as an advanced technology firm," said Interbrand's Moon.

A deep-pocketed Samsung - it earned operating profits of $9.6bn in the third quarter alone - is still pushing the envelope to win over consumers.

This month, the big-spending official sponsor of the past eight Winter and Summer Olympics launched a fantasy-inspired soccer marketing campaign ahead of the mid-2014 World Cup in Brazil - selecting 11 of the world's top players, including Argentine striker Lionel Messi, for a virtual match to save Earth from aliens - with the help of Galaxy devices.

Agencies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Microsoft, Apple and Samsung to launch Christmas advertising blitz
Analysts say digital giants' advertising spend will be on a scale not seen 'outside presidential elections'

Juliette Garside, telecoms correspondent

14, Oct, 2012 @1:03 PM

Article image
Motorola smartphone ad banned after complaints from Samsung fans
Advertising watchdog rules Motorola must withdraw claim that its Atrix handset is the world's most powerful smartphone. By Mark Sweney

Mark Sweney

24, Aug, 2011 @6:20 AM

Article image
Apple marketing chief attacks Android before Samsung launch
Apple's Phil Schiller says Android operating system isn't as good as iPhone and phone services 'don't work seamlessly together'. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur

14, Mar, 2013 @2:46 PM

Article image
Samsung announces new Galaxy smartphone launch
Expected Galaxy S IV, to be revealed in New York in March, is rumoured to have a 4.9in screen and a 13 megapixels camera. By Juliette Garside

Juliette Garside, telecoms correspondent

25, Feb, 2013 @4:43 PM

Article image
Samsung may hit Apple with iPhone 4S ban
Apple could face court injunctions to halt sale of new iPhone 4S as Samsung says it breaches patents it owns. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur and agencies

05, Oct, 2011 @11:29 AM

Article image
For Apple and Samsung smartphone size really matters
Media Monkey: Apple's iPhone 4 and Samsung's Galaxy S II in a battle of the slimmest smartphone – with help from the ASA

Monkey

14, Sep, 2011 @6:29 AM

Article image
Samsung introduces adblocking to its Android devices
World’s largest smartphone manufacturer releases update to its default web browser enabling users to block advertising

Jasper Jackson

01, Feb, 2016 @11:02 AM

Article image
Fall of the iCurtain: Apple brings iTunes to Samsung smart TVs
Surprise move signals wider opening up of Apple ecosystem as tech firm seeks new revenue

Alex Hern

08, Jan, 2019 @2:17 PM

Article image
Apple looks for US ban on eight Samsung phones – and could snare Galaxy S3

iPhone maker's legal move following court ruling could hit rival's flagship phone, as analysts warn of effect on Android. By Charles Arthur

Charles Arthur and agenies

28, Aug, 2012 @8:55 AM

Article image
Samsung Galaxy II sales hit 3m

Smartphone boost but firm hit by slow PC and TV sales as patent challenges loom with Apple

Charles Arthur and agencies

05, Jul, 2011 @12:59 PM