Mlima’s Tale review – haunted by the elephant who would not forget

Kiln theatre, London
Ira Mandela Siobhan plays a pachyderm in Lynn Nottage’s indictment of the ivory trade, leaving traces on those who murdered him and sold his tusks

The gargantuan tusks are hinted at but never shown. No puppetry or animatronics are used to present Mlima, one of the last “great tuskers” in Kenya. Instead, the legendary elder is brought to life by Ira Mandela Siobhan’s lithe body, dancing his way across the sand-coloured stage. His ground-brushing tusks are intimated by silhouettes of the actor’s limbs and his arms are slathered with chalky paint, an echo of the ivory that makes him so valuable. His billowing ears are suggestions from a wicker chair back, a shadow, elbows triangled outwards.

It is said that if you don’t give an elephant a proper burial, it will haunt you forever. In Lynn Nottage’s wide-reaching and damning indictment of the ivory trade, the memories of dead elephants knot themselves throughout. Directed by Miranda Cromwell, Mlima’s Tale whisks us from the poacher’s attack to the black-market business of selling the tusks. In physical interactions that make arresting tableaux yet are occasionally unhandy in practice, the ever-lurking ghost leaves a white chalky trace on the faces and clothes of the living, marking their part in his murder.

A daisy chain of shifty deals … L to r, Ira Mandela Siobhan, Natey Jones and Gabrielle Brooks in Mlima’s Tale.
A daisy chain of shifty deals … L to r, Ira Mandela Siobhan, Natey Jones and Gabrielle Brooks in Mlima’s Tale. Photograph: Marc Brenner

One character leads us to the next, guiding us along the daisy chain of shifty deals to get Mlima’s tusks out of the country. The cast of five (one more than in the original American production) shapeshift as we constantly meet new characters; Natey Jones is brilliant as an indignant poacher and hip-thrusting dealer, while Brandon Grace transforms from avoidant park owner to chic, guilt-free buyer. But the constant mutations, marked by a swish of a curtain, make it hard for tension to build. While Nottage’s story encapsulates the complex struggles of conservation and the deep-rooted tentacles of corruption, we rarely pause long enough in each vignette to delve deeply into the players of the brutal drama.

Yet the strength of this constant forward propulsion is in the revelation of the huge swathe of people who have to turn their head and accept a bribe for the illegal ivory trade to continue. “What price are you willing to pay for beauty?” a prospective buyer is asked. Nottage never lays the blame on a single character or presents anyone without good reason for their actions, but perhaps it is this buyer, the one creating the demand, who holds the most responsibility. If so, we are all guilty. For who among us hasn’t bought something beautiful and chosen not to look too deeply at how it got there?


Kate Wyver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The week in theatre: Boys from the Blackstuff; Vanya; Mlima’s Tale – review
Alan Bleasdale’s 80s TV classic about jobless workers hits home in James Graham’s adaptation; Andrew Scott is not alone in his one-man Chekhov; and Lynn Nottage adds imagination to a tale of ivory smuggling

Susannah Clapp

01, Oct, 2023 @9:30 AM

Article image
Modest review – rollicking tale of star Victorian artist
Elizabeth Thompson takes on the whiskered lads of the Royal Academy in a show that bubbles over with charisma

Arifa Akbar

05, Jul, 2023 @2:41 PM

Article image
The Son review – Florian Zeller's frightening tale of teen depression
Fear and fleeting joy punctuate an exploration of family dynamics, charting the upheaval of divorce and adolescence

Michael Billington

27, Feb, 2019 @12:44 PM

Article image
The Invisible Hand review – thrilling tale of money lust and morality
A US bank employee is captured in Pakistan in Indhu Rubasingham’s pacy revival of Ayad Akhtar’s chillingly ingenious play

Mark Lawson

08, Jul, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Sweat review – breathtaking drama about life in the American rustbelt
Based on interviews with residents of small-town Pennsylvania, Lynn Nottage’s play vividly describes the betrayal and resentments of striking female factory workers in an era of industrial decline

Michael Billington

20, Dec, 2018 @10:35 AM

Article image
The Secret Life of Bees review – blazing songs light up civil rights drama
A young white woman and her Black housekeeper flee across the American south amid the historic struggle, buoyed by astonishingly powerful music

Arifa Akbar

20, Apr, 2023 @12:43 PM

Article image
The Exorcism review – devilishly tricksy haunted-house tale
Shifting between eerie ghost story and broad comedy, Ross Sutherland’s intriguing solo show about demonic possession never quite makes its intentions clear

Brian Logan

05, Nov, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Retrograde review – toxicity meets integrity in exceptional Sidney Poitier drama
Ryan Calais Cameron’s terrific three-hander dramatises a meeting in 1955 Hollywood, mapping the dilemmas that actors of colour still face

Arifa Akbar

27, Apr, 2023 @12:42 PM

Article image
When the Crows Visit review – an uncomfortable watch devoid of hope
For all its good intentions, Anupama Chandrasekhar’s play about patriarchal violence against women in India relies too heavily on shock

Kate Wyver

30, Oct, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Es & Flo review – devoted couple contend with the brutality of dementia
Tender portrait of a woman caring for her love – joy and affection seep through performances that ache with the tragedy of seeing your partner slip away

Kate Wyver

09, Jun, 2023 @9:32 AM