George Takei’s Allegiance review – shocking history given musical uplift

Charing Cross theatre, London
The Star Trek actor appears in an epic story of Japanese Americans interned after Pearl Harbor but there is never enough emotional force

This musical, inspired by George Takei’s early life, tells of how approximately 120,000 Japanese Americans – men, women and children – were forced into internment camps in 1941, following the attack on Pearl Harbor.

The Kimura family, comprising father Tatsuo (Masashi Fujimoto) and his California-born children, Sammy (Telly Leung) and Kei (Aynrand Ferrer), along with their grandfather (Takei), are taken to a camp in Wyoming. They become ideologically split after being forced to prove allegiance to their country although as Sammy says: “We are Americans.”

Given the importance of this appalling moment in US history and its resonance with the debates on immigration, identity and nationhood today, this production should carry enormous weight. That it does not is frustrating.

Potent ideas are touched on: Sammy demonstrates his passionate patriotism by enlisting while others in the camp like Frankie (Patrick Munday, very good), refuse to fight for a country that has defined them as “enemy aliens” and inflicted harm on their families. Takei’s character grows vegetables and gives the surplus to the army: patriotism clearly comes in different forms.

Charming … George Takei in George Takei’s Allegiance at the Charing Cross theatre.
Charming … George Takei at the Charing Cross theatre. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/the Guardian

But none of this carries the emotional force it should. Transferring from New York, the show bills itself as an “uplifting Broadway musical” and therein lies the problem, perhaps.

Directed by Tara Overfield Wilkinson, with a book by Marc Acito, Jay Kuo and Lorenzo Thione, it feels long at almost two and a half hours but its scenes move too fast and breezily, telegraphing the camp’s horror but also containing heavy helpings of schmaltz. Love stories bloom while some die and their ghosts return to watch their loved ones, and sing.

Takei is charming in his part but these characters do not become individual or full-bodied enough. The show throws out song after song (music and lyrics by Kuo) and too many of them are unmemorable. The music is rousing, sometimes with a distantly martial beat, but at other times oddly bouncy. The performances are uniformly strong though, as well as the singing, especially from Ferrer whose voice is both powerful and delicate. But we end up simply not feeling strongly enough for a story that should appal and outrage us.


Arifa Akbar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Green Fairy review – absinthe musical lacks spirit
Cliche-drenched lyrics and a lightweight storyline put a cork in the emotional reckoning at this unremarkable story’s heart

Kate Wyver

05, Nov, 2019 @3:53 PM

Article image
Seagulls review – Chekhov musical makes Nina a singer-songwriter
Beth Hyland attempts to shift the male-and-his-muse gaze in her story about misogyny in the music industry

Catherine Love

01, Nov, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Beggar's Opera review – the original jukebox musical reimagined
An updated version of John Gay’s classic features gags about the royal wedding and Brexit, but the music has missed a trick

Rowena Smith

17, Aug, 2018 @4:00 PM

Article image
Ruthless! review – showbiz schemers play dirty in ultra-camp musical
An over-the-top paean to stage ambition ends up in thrall to the world it tries to parody

Michael Billington

29, Mar, 2018 @3:00 PM

Article image
The Light in the Piazza review – Fleming shines over feelgood musical
Full of lazy, hazy nostalgia for classic romantic encounters in Italy, this picturesque show is rescued from cliche by Renée Fleming’s soaring star quality

Erica Jeal

19, Jun, 2019 @2:37 PM

Article image
Rothschild & Sons review – rags-to-riches musical can't match Fiddler's magic
The story of a banking dynasty is intricately done and beautifully sung, but the central character lacks the doleful warmth of Tevye

Lyn Gardner

30, Jan, 2018 @10:27 AM

Article image
Ain’t Misbehavin’ review – Oti Mabuse musical has sass, soul and swing
A crack cast fire up this romp through Fats Waller’s music, directed by Tyrone Huntley with moves by the Strictly dancer

Lyndsey Winship

26, Apr, 2019 @1:19 PM

Article image
Summer Holiday review – Cliff Richard musical becomes bus ride in Bolton
The audience enjoy a Cliff singalong on the top deck as they soak up the feelgood hit of the summer

Mark Fisher

05, Jun, 2018 @10:07 AM

Article image
An Officer and a Gentleman review – jukebox musical never takes off
The hit movie romance has been adapted into a musical, but its gender politics have dated and it lacks grit

Lyn Gardner

21, Apr, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Curtains review – the arresting case of Kander and Ebb's musical whodunnit
Jason Manford is a charming, showtune-obsessed homicide cop in this fun companion to Chicago and Cabaret

Mark Lawson

18, Dec, 2019 @12:23 PM