Best of Enemies review – stylish staging of a landmark TV clash

Noël Coward theatre, London
The 1968 debate between Gore Vidal and William F Buckley Jr is depicted with verve and feels uncomfortably up-to-date

Could a grainy broadcast debate between two opposing US thinkers in 1968 really have turned politics into a televisual popularity contest? James Graham’s fabulous, frenetic play concerns the clash between Gore Vidal, speaking for the New Left, and William F Buckley Jr on the New Right, in the lead-up to the presidential elections. It seems to trace a line from that moment to the birth of pugilistic, celebrity-led TV politics that feeds our culture wars, fuels Twitter’s silos and has enabled the likes of Donald Trump (as it is heavily hinted) and Matt Hancock of the jungle.

In a production directed by Jeremy Herrin, some of those associations seem strained, but this is a fascinating moment captured with immense intelligence and verve.

Originally staged in 2021 at the Young Vic and based on a 2015 documentary, this West End transfer is well-oiled and still feels enveloping and immersive. The writer has made small changes to the script, which has Graham’s wide socio-political scope and sharp humour but intellectual depth, too.

Bunny Christie’s set features glass boxes and multiple screens replaying the action as well as archive footage so that the stage looks like a giant 3D TV set come to life. It is, in its effects, TV as theatre and theatre as TV. Graham’s story rewinds and flashes back and zooms in and out from pivotal speeches, which feel like television edits and montages, all clean, clever and wondrous in their execution. The whirligig of action around the debate has a bubblegum energy with cameos from Andy Warhol and Aretha Franklin.

David Harewood returns as the rightwing conservative, Buckley, and perfects the balance between swaggering intellectual and a man with a fragile ego who must be stroked by his strategist wife. Harewood’s casting as a white American who debates with James Baldwin is striking in its inversion but his views on race are not quite given the space to give this casting greater meaning. Zachary Quinto plays his opponent with more archness than Charles Edwards’ Vidal at the Young Vic; he is all dark glances and mannered drawl, a champagne leftie with a whiff of the super-villain at first but he grows into the part and owns it completely by the end.

Both actors are restricted by the highly stylised roles they play, but they never become impersonations. That is partly because the verbatim aspect of the script contains so much genuine, articulate anger and clashing ideologies that they hold us rapt. The question of whether this game-changing debate lowered or elevated the discourse is floated in the drama. Was this a slanging match or televised intellectualism? Sadly, we know the answer to that now.


Arifa Akbar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Best of Enemies review – James Graham’s superb study of media and politics
David Harewood and Charles Edwards go head-to-head as William F Buckley Jr and Gore Vidal respectively in an enthralling play based on a 1968 TV debate

Mark Lawson

10, Dec, 2021 @1:58 PM

Article image
He played Martin Luther King. Next up: a fiery white rightwinger
David Harewood cast as William Buckley in James Graham’s new play of fiery 1968 debates with Gore Vidal

Vanessa Thorpe

31, Oct, 2021 @8:15 AM

Article image
Playwright James Graham: ‘Was I too easy on Dominic Cummings? I go back and forth’
He has written powerful dramas about the likes of Rupert Murdoch and Dominic Cummings. The playwright explains why he’s now tackling 11 vitriolic TV debates that gripped America

Dorian Lynskey

15, Nov, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Labour of Love review – James Graham's witty take on party's thorny past
Martin Freeman and Tamsin Greig give sparkling performances as a reforming MP and his constituency agent fighting through Labour’s fluctuating fortunes

Michael Billington

03, Oct, 2017 @10:59 PM

Article image
Sketching review – James Graham's London landscapes inspired by Dickens
Graham and eight previously unproduced writers present stories that capture the oddity and excess of the capital

Michael Billington

03, Oct, 2018 @10:12 AM

Article image
Tammy Faye: A New Musical review – Elton John’s hymn to biblical kitsch
Songs belt out deliriously in this romp through rise and fall of the Bakker televangelists and latterday gay icons – so thick and fast the James Graham script and Jake Shears lyrics are sometimes overwhelmed by glitz

Arifa Akbar

27, Oct, 2022 @8:43 AM

Article image
Brexit Shorts: Giving voice to a divided Britain through new dramas
The Guardian’s pioneering dramatic collaboration inspired by last year’s EU referendum offers characters who lay bare our complex national responses

Chris Wiegand

23, Jun, 2017 @11:44 AM

Article image
James Graham on his uplifting 2020 musical: 'We want to look forward'
The playwright has collaborated with the Guardian and the National Theatre on a new short film, We Begin Again, looking back at – and beyond – this turbulent year

Lanre Bakare

17, Dec, 2020 @12:06 PM

Article image
The Best Man review – Gore Vidal's brutal political dogfight
Martin Shaw and Maureen Lipman star in an entertaining 1960 drama set during a Democratic party convention

Michael Billington

06, Mar, 2018 @12:00 PM

Article image
This House five-star review – James Graham's thrilling political play returns
Graham captures the daily machinations of politics, and raises questions about our current parliamentary system, in this account of Labour’s 1970s struggles

Michael Billington

30, Nov, 2016 @11:00 PM