Emilia review – a feminist take on the life of Shakespeare’s Dark Lady

Arts Centre Melbourne, Melbourne
The Australian production of this Olivier-winning play has been beset by problems, but it’s back on – with some stirring performances and clumsy moments

Emilia Lanier née Bassano was one of the first English women to publish a book of poetry, the rumoured “Dark Lady” in Shakespeare’s sonnets and, as asserted by some, Shakespeare himself. This all-but-erased historical figure is the subject of Morgan Lloyd Malcolm’s Olivier award-winning play, which was first commissioned for Shakespeare’s Globe before heading to London’s West End. Three actors play the 16th century poet at different ages, with known facts about Emilia’s life overlaid with conjecture on her rich interiority, motivations and how her words were used against her and for her.

The Australian premiere of Emilia has been blighted by misfortune: Heidi Arena, who plays William Shakespeare, sustained an injury on opening night while several actors were sidelined by Covid, meaning performances were cancelled across six nights. But Emilia is up and running again: Arena is back to reprise her role – albeit in crutches – while Kuda Mapeza stands in for Manali Datar as the youngest Emilia, reading from a script.

There’s some source material to play with when it comes to reimagining Emilia’s life and the play hews closely to what is known about her. Where it reinvents history is in its casting – a lineup of entirely women and non-binary actors perform all roles, with 10 of them inhabiting both male and female characters with aplomb. Historians have alluded that Emilia, Italian by way of her father, could’ve been Jewish. This point of difference, stark in an era when Jewish people were banned from entering England, is updated for a contemporary reality, with Emilia played by three Black women: Mapeza, Cessalee Stovall and Lisa Maza.

“We are only as powerful as the stories we tell. We haven’t always been able to tell them,” opens Maza, in the first of two striking monologues that bookend the play. As the eldest Emilia in a Greek chorus of past, present and future selves that echo each other as Emilia’s life unfolds, Maza is a central, commanding presence on stage – even when she’s on the periphery.

Cessalee Stovall in Emilia.
‘Blistering in her anger’ … Cessalee Stovall in Emilia. Photograph: Dylan Hornsby/Good Gravy Media

Under Petra Kalive’s direction, the play charts Emilia’s passage into the gentry class: when she was given away at the age of seven to Susan Bertie, Countess of Kent, after the death of her father; and her schooling in the etiquette of being a woman of a higher social standing, communicated in a highly entertaining dance sequence featuring Sonya Suares, Jing-Xuan Chan and Sarah Fitzgerald as noblewomen. In a funny little nod to the unhistorical casting, Suares performs moves synonymous with Bharatanatyam, an ancient Indian classical dance.

Mapeza does an admirable job as the younger Emilia, her bright-eyed naiveté and fierce resolve belying the script she constantly has to refer to. Playing Emilia from childhood to becoming a writer, from being the mistress of one lord to becoming the reluctant wife of another, her performance sets the tone for Emilia’s exploration of thwarted female desire and ambition.

The age difference between Emilia and her lordly lover, Henry Carey, was 45 years; Geneviève Picot’s convincingly lecherous turn as the latter helps underline the troubling power dynamic. Emilia’s later paramour, none other than Shakespeare himself, is played farcically by Arena until his demeanour switches seamlessly into something altogether more sinister when his duplicity is uncovered.

Stovall & Emma J Hawkins in Emilia.
Cessalee Stovall as Emilia and Emma J Hawkins as Lady Margaret Clifford. Photograph: Dylan Hornsby/Good Gravy Media

The regal Stovall takes over from Mapeza when Emilia comes into her own as a teacher, writer and activist, and confronts Shakespeare about plagiarising her work. Blistering in her anger, Stovall brings a seething undercurrent of rage to the role. Right towards the end, Maza assumes her mantle as the oldest Emilia.

The transition between the three Emilias is gentle and affectionate, each of them supporting the other like a warm embrace, but the shifts between scenes can be tonally clumsy – a hackneyed exchange between middle-aged Emilia and Shakespeare’s ghost feels dissonant after a preceding tragic event.

A staircase spun around on its axis is the lone prop, used effectively as a birthing chamber, bedroom and writing room. The play delights in cheeky anachronisms: Converse sneakers peek out from under the actors’ formalwear. Punctuating the more sombre moments of the play with an air of levity are profane quips such as “you really fucked it”, while insults like “old turd” and “bastard” are liberally thrown around.

Drawing on Emilia’s own radical politics, the play’s message is clear. In Lloyd Malcom’s script, women’s confinement to the margins of history and their ostracisation from any pursuits which weren’t connected to motherhood find contemporary resonances in questions around representation, double standards and mansplaining. But the excessive signposting and proselytising throughout by the older Emilias imbues the play – which is likely already preaching to the converted – with a heavy didacticism. Even with knowing nods and winks thrown the audience’s way, there’s no space allowed for them within the narrative.

When Maza’s incredibly rousing closing monologue about anger, rebellion and reclamation brings certain audience members to their feet, it is well-deserved – but it rehashes well-worn territory.

Sonia Nair

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Happy Days review – Judith Lucy is wonderfully disturbing in Samuel Beckett’s masterpiece
Sumner Theatre, Melbourne Theatre Company
The former stand-up is a natural fit for the role of Winnie, a tragic woman attempting to stave off hopelessness in the face of great horror

Tim Byrne

06, May, 2023 @2:59 AM

Article image
A Christmas Carol review – David Wenham is a superb Scrooge for the ages
Comedy Theatre, Melbourne
This adaptation from London’s Old Vic is a night of pure theatrical warmth, with a performance of incredible clarity and generosity at its centre

Tim Byrne

19, Nov, 2022 @2:08 AM

Article image
Sunday review – a masterful and moving portrait of a woman who railed against conformity
This world-class production anchored by superb central performances brings Sunday Reed back to shimmering, incandescent life

Tim Byrne

20, Jan, 2023 @11:57 PM

Article image
Cyrano review – Virginia Gay shines in this bold, queer reimagining
Southbank Theatre, Melbourne Theatre Company
After being scuppered by a snap lockdown in 2021, Gay’s highly anticipated take on Cyrano turns out to have been worth waiting for

Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen

13, Oct, 2022 @4:30 PM

Article image
Monsters review – Stephanie Lake production is supposed to scare but sinks into silliness instead
This ambitious dance-theatre hybrid, about a woman searching for her missing sister, falls apart when the allegorical becomes literal

Tim Byrne

28, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Jacky review – incredibly uncomfortable, thoughtful theatre
Fairfax Studio, Melbourne Theatre Company
By Arrernte playwright Declan Furber Gillick, Jacky follows two Indigenous brothers who clash over the expectations of white people around them

Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen

29, May, 2023 @1:46 AM

Article image
Hubris & Humiliation review – this queer take on Jane Austen is startlingly good
Lewis Treston’s witty and polished play blends Regency language and Australian slang to deliver a dizzying amount of jokes and sizzling romantic tension

Cassie Tongue

26, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
I have always loved the theatre – but as a Vietnamese woman, it hasn’t loved me back
Growing up wanting a career on the stage, Julia Faragher quickly learned how limited her roles would be. A new production of Laurinda gives her hope

Julia Faragher

24, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Julia review – new play about Julia Gillard misses an opportunity
Justine Clarke is electrifying delivering the former PM’s misogyny speech, but the work fails to reckon with the complexities of her legacy

Cassie Tongue

05, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Do Not Go Gentle review – a profound exploration of ageing and dementia
Patricia Cornelius’s play co-opts Captain Robert Falcon Scott’s ill-fated expedition to the south pole to follow a band of adventurers who are actually in an aged care home

Steve Dow

28, May, 2023 @1:30 AM