Play ‘born of rage’ over Asian female stereotypes lambasts Miss Saigon

Kimber Lee’s award-winning drama, untitled f*ck m*ss s**gon play, will be staged at Manchester’s Royal Exchange while Miss Saigon opens at the Sheffield Crucible

The Royal Exchange theatre in Manchester is to present an award-winning play that rails against the portrayal of Asian women in the musical Miss Saigon.

The programming of Kimber Lee’s drama untitled f*ck m*ss s**gon play was announced on Tuesday, following news that a touring theatre company of British east and south-east Asian (BESEA) artists has pulled a production from the Sheffield Crucible next summer because the venue is staging Miss Saigon. In a statement, New Earth Theatre said it would not present its play Worth alongside “a musical that perpetuates deeply held notions of Asian inferiority”.

The winner of the international category of the Bruntwood prize for playwriting in 2019, untitled f*ck m*ss s**gon play will be staged in Manchester at the same time that Miss Saigon will be performed in Sheffield. The play was “born of rage” and came from “feeling invisible or misrepresented”, Lee has said. The playwright, who is based in New York, has criticised how “the presence of Asian American stories is only allowed a very narrow range in the cultural conversation” and said that writing the play was a way to take control of the narrative. The Bruntwood prize judges praised how her play switches between humour and tragedy. Lee said it uses comedy to deal with painful things, “going against another Asian stereotype which is that we’re all humourless and inscrutable”.

Lee has described her play as about a woman trying to find her way out of a maze or a trap. “I think it is going directly at some very painful questions that I have about how Asian women are represented.” The play is about “not only Miss Saigon but this tradition of performance and its treatment of Asian characters and this particular trope of Asian women”. The synopsis says that the character of Kim is “caught up in a never-ending cycle of events, she looks for the exit but the harder she tries, the worse it gets and she begins to wonder: who’s writing this story? She makes a break for it, smashing through a hundred years of bloody narratives that all end the same way.”

The play will be directed by Roy Alexander Weise as part of Manchester international festival and will run from 24 June to 22 July before transferring to the Young Vic in London. It is a co-production with the Young Vic and Headlong touring company.

Sheffield Theatres, which runs the Crucible, will be presenting Miss Saigon in July. On Monday it said it respected New Earth Theatre’s decision. “There is no denying that past versions of this story have provoked strong reactions and feelings. We have approached this new production sensitive to this and believe this is a chance for us to engage in a fresh way with a majority east and south-east Asian company reframing the story,” it said in a statement. “The creative team led by Robert Hastie and Anthony Lau have been in close conversation with members of the BESEA community and are keen to continue discussing their plans with concerned artists to keep a positive and inclusive dialogue open.”

The multi-award-winning Miss Saigon opened in London’s West End in 1989 . Inspired by Puccini’s 1904 opera Madama Butterfly and set towards the end of the Vietnam war, it follows the relationship between a young Vietnamese sex worker and an American GI who abandons her after she becomes pregnant.

Beats, a not-for-profit advocacy organisation founded by British east and south-east Asians working in the theatre and screen industry, released a statement saying “while some might rejoice in the show’s high drama and slick musical numbers, we can never shake off the disturbing fact that south-east and east Asian women are fetishised and hyper-sexualised, harassed and even physically attacked with the lingering trope of pliant availability, while south-east and east Asian men are emasculated and erased. These are damaging cliches which a work like Miss Saigon perpetuates, while also erasing the real experience of war and violence suffered by millions of Vietnamese women, men and children.”

Beats described Miss Saigon as an “unashamedly commercial” show and lamented the fact that it was being revived for the first time in a publicly subsidised theatre. The pejorative title of Lee’s play voiced, it said, “a sentiment we find it difficult not to echo”.


Chris Wiegand Stage editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Miss Saigon is offensive’: the satire savaging the ‘racist, imperialist and misogynistic’ musical
Playwright Kimber Lee was so shocked when she first saw the musical, she wrote a vitriolic sendup, called untitled f*ck m*ss s**gon play. As it finally hits the stage, she warns: ‘This is no soft pedal’

Arifa Akbar

13, Jun, 2023 @2:54 PM

Article image
The Michael Billington archive: highlights from five decades of reviews
Ken Dodd’s laugh riot, Dustin Hoffman as Willy Loman, Lucy Prebble’s dazzling debut and ‘off-with-your kit Harington’ … revisit the hits and flops assessed by our outgoing theatre critic

20, Dec, 2019 @7:49 AM

Article image
Miss Saigon review – slick machine of a musical rather than a radical rewrite
Billed as an opportunity to reframe Boublil and Schönberg’s original, this is more of a tweak but it is a visually captivating production

Arifa Akbar

14, Jul, 2023 @1:21 PM

Article image
Royal Exchange theatre, Design Museum and Fabric to get at least £1m
The £75m that will be given to 35 organisations has been described as a ‘lifeline’

Lanre Bakare Arts and culture correspondent

23, Oct, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
From Hamlet to Hullabaloo: what to see as theatres and comedy clubs reopen
As stage shows return, we pick the best post-lockdown offerings – featuring Egyptian gods, rebelling vicars, dancing youths ... and Ian McKellen playing the Dane at 82

Arifa Akbar (theatre), Brian Logan (comedy), Lyndsey Winship (dance)

16, May, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
The best theatre of 2022
In a superb year for the stage, our chief critic gives 10 shows an extra round of applause. Plus, Guardian theatre reviewers each pick their 2022 standout

Arifa Akbar

15, Dec, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Fleabag's Phoebe Waller-Bridge and Andrew Scott up for Olivier awards
TV co-stars compete for acting prizes at this year’s theatre awards, whose nominations are led by the musicals & Juliet, Fiddler on the Roof and Dear Evan Hansen

Chris Wiegand

03, Mar, 2020 @4:05 PM

Article image
Kwame Kwei-Armah announces £5 seats for his first Young Vic season
New artistic director will stage a musical version of Twelfth Night and introduces £5 tickets for every first preview at the theatre

Chris Wiegand

17, Apr, 2018 @11:01 AM

Article image
Guys and Dolls review – thrills and chaos in the giddy, gambling Big Apple
Against a spare backdrop, the cast generate energy, comedy and romance in spades in this revival of Frank Loesser’s New York musical

Catherine Love

16, Dec, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Theatre group pulls play from Sheffield venue staging Miss Saigon
New Earth Theatre said ‘damaging tropes, misogyny and racism’ in show contradict its values

Harriet Sherwood Arts and culture correspondent

21, Nov, 2022 @8:03 PM