A Christmas Carol review – Adrian Edmondson stars in a biting tale for our times

Royal Shakespeare theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon
David Edgar’s sharp script feels close to home in this exuberant, illusion-filled version of Dickens’ seasonal but socially conscious story

There are double economic reasons why theatregoers this winter will rarely be far away from a version of A Christmas Carol. The reliable popularity of Dickens’ 1843 story reassures playhouse accountants jittery about blows to the box office from Covid and the cost of living crisis, while writers and directors are drawn to the enduring resonance of the lament on wealth inequality.

As a politically engaged playwright, David Edgar (Destiny, Maydays) is ideal to mine the hard stones of social campaigning Dickens hid within his seasonal treat. But with the chancellor of the exchequer playing Scrooge to reverse his predecessor’s spooking of the markets, and old Ebenezer’s dismissal of charity and compassion seemingly the template for the home secretary, Edgar’s version bites even more than at its 2017 premiere and 2018 revival. Struggling to prevent their children starving, the Cratchits feel ever less fictionally and historically distant.

The joy of the show, though, comes from the seamlessness of Edgar’s donnish sub-text – a framing device has Dickens outlining and improvising the story to his publisher – and the exuberant visual spectacle of Rachel Kavanaugh’s staging, incorporating illusions (by Ben Hart and RSC Production Video) including one transformation that achieves a gasp of joyous shock matching the sudden audience jump in The Woman in Black.

Sunetra Sarker as the Ghost of Christmas Present in A Christmas Carol.
Sunetra Sarker as the Ghost of Christmas Present. Photograph: Manuel Harlan

Adrian Edmondson’s Scrooge seems to be twice channelling Roald Dahl: the pre-dreams Ebenezer, inflected by the great children’s writer’s curmudgeonly and bigoted public persona, but the reformed Scrooge suggesting the twinkly eccentricity of Dahl’s Willy Wonka. In line with the script’s sharp eye on our times – Edgar names two incidental characters Mrs Snapchat and Herr Uber – Edmondson stresses more than most versions that the character is not a wretched miser but a canny entrepreneur leveraging debt for profit.

Mitesh Soni’s Bob Cratchit engagingly explores the limits of positivity against poverty, and Gavin Fowler embodies Dickens’ passion to make words work politically, and touchingly doubles Scrooge as a young man, kissing his to-be-lost love under mistletoe held by Edmondson, one of several elegant time-slips. Sunetra Sarker gives audiences a sweet Christmas Present of that ghost and assorted other roles.

The stuffing of the 2022 Christmas theatre listings with takes on the same tale risks “Bah, humbug!” from customers who have had their fill, but the RSC sets the annual standard very high with a version combining childish pleasures and grownup ideas.


Mark Lawson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A Christmas Carol play inspired by social media and M1 service stations
Dramatist David Edgar was struck by the Dickensian sound of names such as Tinder and Tibshelf in adaptation of classic story

Dalya Alberge

03, Sep, 2017 @4:53 PM

Article image
A Christmas Carol review – Dickens's social ills touch the mind but not the heart
David Edgar’s lively adaptation for the RSC foregrounds the tale’s reforming message and features Phil Davis as a grotesquely good Scrooge

Michael Billington

07, Dec, 2017 @1:33 PM

Article image
Adrian Edmondson: 'Hamlet saved me from being expelled'
As the RSC’s Twelfth Night is streamed online, the actor recalls putting on Malvolio’s yellow stockings and how pub theatre led him into comedy

Adrian Edmondson

09, Apr, 2020 @12:42 PM

Article image
‘It has added political resonance this year’: why Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol still strikes a chord
Audiences can choose from a glut of Ebenezers this festive season, with the infamous miser a more pointed character than ever in these hard times

Vanessa Thorpe

13, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Adrian Edmondson and Nigel Planer reunite for actors satire
Young Ones stars to appear on stage in Vulcan 7 as has-beens stuck in a literal and TV-career wasteland

Maev Kennedy

08, Jun, 2018 @2:18 PM

Article image
Dolly Parton’s Smoky Mountain Christmas Carol review – humbug hoedown
Parton’s music is as warming as ever but a snowfall of schmaltz and minimal menace make this Dickens adaptation sickly sweet

Arifa Akbar

14, Dec, 2022 @12:18 PM

Article image
Adrian Edmondson webchat – your questions answered on Rik Mayall, hate mail and what's in a Peperami
The former Young One revealed who he’d like to thwack with a frying pan, his guitar battles with heavy metal legends and what he makes of today’s sitcoms

11, Oct, 2017 @10:13 AM

Article image
A Christmas Carol review – glorious musical version of Dickens’s festive treat
Charles Dickens takes to the stage and Ebenezer Scrooge is a woman with a moving backstory in Morgan Lloyd Malcolm’s adaptation

Arifa Akbar

12, Dec, 2022 @1:28 PM

Article image
A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story review – Mark Gatiss’s witty dash through Dickens
Gatiss’s delayed rework amps up the ghostly effects while drawing out the overlooked dark comedy in the classic tale

Arifa Akbar

03, Nov, 2021 @1:25 PM

Article image
A Christmas Carol review – Rhys Ifans' shaggy skinflint serves up a festive feast
Jack Thorne’s superb retelling mines the ghosts of Scrooge’s past in a timely production brimming with love and affection

Michael Billington

29, Nov, 2017 @11:00 PM