Brass Eye’s outtakes show the brutal TV comedy was the tip of an iceberg

With rare footage and personal insights, the documentary Oxide Ghosts is a must-see for fans of Chris Morris’s satire, which is 25 years old

Its original broadcast was postponed by a nervous Channel 4, it led to questions in the House of Commons and to a (Labour) culture secretary professing herself “shocked and appalled” on the 10 O’Clock News. It is also “one of the greatest comedies ever shown on television,” says David Walliams, who on Sunday night hosted a screening of a film about the making of Chris Morris’s legendary series Brass Eye – 25 years old this year. Oxide Ghosts: The Brass Eye Tapes splices together off-cuts and outtakes from the show, and is made by Brass Eye’s director, Michael Cumming, who excavated the material from his own chest of floppy discs and VHS tapes. It’s touring now, and for Brass Eye fans – that’s me! – it’s a must-see.

Why? Because it reveals the broadcast series – six short episodes only, plus the notorious “Paedogeddon” special – as just the tip of an iceberg of astonishing material. Scenes such as the West End musical about Peter Sutcliffe and the footage of Morris with a spacehopper on his head scoring made-up drugs on a street corner were often prime cuts of much longer sequences, shown here. Then there are whole unseen items, every bit as harsh/funny as the broadcast material – like the “Lady Parliament” sketch, in which Morris convenes an all-female panel to adjudicate on animal cruelty, then bamboozles and patronises the panel to a hasty conclusion.

But you can also enjoy Oxide Ghosts for a peep behind the veil that tends to conceal the show’s reclusive star. There are flashes of how he persuaded his celebrity stooges to appear on the programme – or failed to, in the case of Jeffrey Archer. A sense arises of the risks to which its creators were exposed when making the show, as Morris fashions an impromptu stab-proof vest from a Vogue magazine, and as Reggie Kray commissions a heavy to visit the production office after Morris pranked him on a phone call to Maidstone jail.

Chris Morris at the Four Lions film premiere.
Chris Morris at the Four Lions film premiere. Photograph: Nigel Roddis Photography/Rex/Shutterstock

Then there’s the corpsing, which can’t help but humanise an artist whose human side is more zealously guarded than the crown jewels. Here, Morris giggles at the list of animals he’s improvising while in character as a livestock supplier to British MPs. He giggles when an elephant pisses over his studio floor. And he breaks his daytime TV presenter character to giggle at one of the sickliest moments of the series, when he’s interviewing a fictional teenage girl who has been sexually abused by her uncle. “Was he,” asks Morris, unctuous concern and self-regard vying for the spotlight, “as handsome as me?”

Oof. But then there are so many “oof” moments – when you can’t believe Morris’s rent-a-quote celebs are actually speaking the nonsense he feeds them; or moments of cruelty or obscenity that you marvel Morris got away with, even (or perhaps especially) when viewed at 25 years’ distance. We’re more delicate now than in the 90s – this is not a series made for the era of self-care and the safe space.

In a post-screening conversation with Walliams, Cumming discusses the scenes Morris might not venture were the show made today. A sketch about a Holocaust board game was mentioned – although it ended up on the cutting-room floor anyway. The series’ rape jokes and conspicuous interest in gay sex feel ickier to me a quarter century on. Then there’s the subliminal single-frame expletive directed at Channel 4’s then chief exec, the telly grandee Michael Grade – which Cumming apologises for tonight, because Grade, he admits, was bolder in programming and defending the show than they gave him credit for.

But Brass Eye’s brutality is the point: it’s a bonfire of proprieties. (Cumming cited Pete ’n’ Dud’s Derek and Clive albums as an influence.) You take it in that spirit, or not at all. Its genius – alongside the rampant silliness, the Edward Lear-like linguistic flamboyance, the great performances – is to be in appalling taste on the one hand, and driven by a palpable moral scorn on the other. Scorn at the pompous inanities of the infotainment culture that was still dawning in 1997, when social media was but a twinkle in Mark Zuckerberg’s eye. Scorn at the cult of celebrity that suggests no charitable cause is worthwhile unless fronted by a C-list personality. (One of the pleasures of rewatching Brass Eye is to be reminded how swiftly such people – your Tamara Beckwiths, your Caesar the Geezers – return to obscurity.)

Inevitably, Cumming’s Q&A tended towards the question: could Brass Eye happen today? Its director doubts it: the internet has changed everything, including the likelihood (give or take the work of Sacha Baron Cohen, Brass Eye’s most obvious inheritor) that a show this audacious could ever premiere directly on network TV. It’s also a show of its time, when perspective was still possible on the interplay of media and celebrity or the flattening effect of rolling news. Nowadays, that’s just the air we breathe. Brass Eye takes a torch to it all, and to whatever bridges still connected Morris to a career in TV comedy. Artists that wild don’t come along often – and when they do, they’re seldom given their own TV show. It happened, once – and Oxide Ghosts gives us a great chance to celebrate it.


Brian Logan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'This isn't a paranoid future nightmare': the explosive return of Chris Morris
The satirist’s new film was inspired by the FBI’s attempts to manufacture terrorists. He talks about the problem with white liberals – and his duty to provoke

Catherine Shoard

27, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Nate: A One Man Show review – outrageous and electrifying comedy
Natalie Palamides’s drag king show remains both raucous and subtle, as it explores grey areas around consent

Brian Logan

02, Dec, 2020 @3:16 PM

Article image
Corona comedy: Facebook cabaret, gamer gags and a WhatsApp panel show
From Iain Stirling’s Fifa banter to Jayde Adams live from her lounge, comedians isolated by the lockdown are reaching audiences online

Chris Wiegand

09, Apr, 2020 @3:25 PM

Article image
Readers recommend: misanthropic songs | Peter Kimpton
Hatred of humankind? You’ve got to love it. Dark humour, sharp lyrics and moving music will be among your song suggestions, says Peter Kimpton

Peter Kimpton

04, Sep, 2014 @9:00 PM

Article image
Twenty years on … how comedy genius Chris Morris invented ‘fake news’
Out-takes from Brass Eye have been made into a film to mark its birthday – but fans of the cult show can only view it at rare live cinema screenings

Vanessa Thorpe

21, Oct, 2017 @11:05 PM

Leader: Brass Eye was degrading

Sometimes you choose sides in a battle by taking a look at the combatants on either side. In the war of Brass Eye against its critics, it seems like a straight choice. Ranged on one side are the Daily Mail, assorted rent-a-gob Conservative MPs and a nannying trio of government ministers: David Blunkett, Tessa Jowell and Beverley Hughes. They have all condemned the weekend programme on child sex abuse. On the other side, are the hip, cutting edge folk of Channel 4 standing by their "maverick" satirist Chris Morris.


31, Jul, 2001 @4:07 PM

Article image
Sarah Millican's mad at the middleman, and it's Piers Morgan v David Walliams
Brian Logan: Geordie comedian boycotts Ambassador Theatre Group venues over high booking fees, Morgan and Walliams lock horns, and Rowan Atkinson is set to return to live comedy

Brian Logan

18, Sep, 2012 @4:13 PM

Article image
'Fame proved toxic for the relationship': when comedy double acts split
David Baddiel, Andy Zaltzman, Richard Herring and other comics on fame, failure and friendship

Simon Parkin

27, Jan, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Scream with laughter: can comedy ever be scary?
Standup Nick Coyle’s new show Queen of Wolves takes a Victorian governess on a terrifying journey – and proves how humour and horror work in similar ways

Brian Logan

25, Sep, 2017 @2:18 PM

Article image
Louis CK review – sordid, cynical and queasy comedy
The standup returns to the UK with a set on morality, sex and religion that often excels but also stalls with casual misanthropy

Brian Logan

05, Oct, 2022 @9:34 AM