Rock/Paper/Scissors review – sharp-edged trilogy celebrates a city in flux

Sheffield Theatres
Chris Bush’s audacious production, performed simultaneously by the same cast across three theatres, intertwines comedy, romance and political rage to dazzling effect

Think of the forces that shaped modern Britain and what comes to mind is heavy industry: mining, chemicals, oil … We tend not to think of scissors. Why would we? In our era of mass production, scissors are too commonplace to be noticed; not so much noble as comic.

Yet here in Sheffield, the city of steel, the production of scissors was once the province of as many as 60 companies. And in her audacious trilogy of plays performed simultaneously in three adjacent theatres, Chris Bush uses these everyday objects as a symbol. They stand for permanence in a world in flux.

Her setting is the fictional Spenser and Son, one of the last remaining scissor factories, where the value of a quality product, built to last, remains doggedly enshrined. Even the machinery on which the scissors are fashioned is decades old. Everything from the chemical composition to the curvature of the handles is finely judged, the domain of experts who have perfected their trade over long years.

This is in contrast to the ephemerality of today. The ailing factory is staffed almost entirely by apprentices who, for reasons of economy, will be discarded after a year. Dropping in for a photoshoot are a pop duo, going by the name of Co-codamol, who have just enough self-awareness to know their sell-by date is nearly up. The sister and stepdaughter of the recently deceased factory owner have opposing schemes to redevelop the site, but whether it is a nightclub or a trendy residential quarter, their plans have the air of impermanence.

Middle-aged punk … Susie (Denise Black) dominates Rock.
Middle-aged punk … Susie (Denise Black) dominates Rock. Photograph: Johan Persson

Not that Bush’s three plays are a reactionary paean to the good old days. Rather, in making repeated reference to Einstein’s assertion that energy can neither be created nor destroyed, a thought bolstered by the line in Ecclesiastes about there being a season for everything, they accept the inevitability of change and transformation. Instead, Bush takes a step back to ask what kind of change is desirable – a question she extends in particular to the role of women in an industry, and indeed a world, that has historically privileged men.

These ideas swirl around in Rock in the Crucible, Paper in the Lyceum and Scissors in the Studio, each running to the same length, right down to the time of the intervals, and each involving the same excellent 14-strong ensemble.

In outline, they tell the same story about the struggle for ownership of a dead-end business, the drama of one becoming the gossip of another, but in detail, they reveal hidden contours. A romance that seems superficial in Rock becomes touching in Paper. A peripheral figure in Paper is the centre of attention in Scissors. Where middle-aged punk Susie (Denise Black) dominates Rock, directed by Anthony Lau, it is the edgy relationship between Faye (Samantha Power) and Mel (Natalie Casey) that drives Paper, directed by Robert Hastie. For the voice of an exploited young generation, you need Scissors, directed by Elin Schofield.

The logistics of all this are mindboggling. Alan Ayckbourn’s simultaneous double-bill of House and Garden is modest by comparison. In its ambition, an all-day marathon is exhilarating – and not a little exhausting – for actors and audience alike.

The downside is that of the three, only Paper justifies its running time; both Rock and Scissors are prone to treading water, as they repeat ideas or settle into idle chat. That, though, is in between passages that dazzle and delight, be they Rock’s comedy of confusion, Paper’s romantic exposure or Scissors’ sizzling political rage.


Mark Fisher

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Guys and Dolls review – thrills and chaos in the giddy, gambling Big Apple
Against a spare backdrop, the cast generate energy, comedy and romance in spades in this revival of Frank Loesser’s New York musical

Catherine Love

16, Dec, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Richard Hawley writes musical about Sheffield's Park Hill estate
Standing at the Sky’s Edge, which features old and new songs by the musician, will be performed at the city’s Crucible theatre

Chris Wiegand

02, Mar, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
Standing at the Sky’s Edge review – Richard Hawley's ode to Sheffield estate
This across-the-decades Park Hill musical is cleverly staged, moving through idealism, dilapidation and gentrification

Catherine Love

21, Mar, 2019 @11:11 AM

Article image
Operation Crucible review – Sheffield steals the show in lively wartime tale
The cast offer a high-spirited depiction of male camaraderie in this play about the Sheffield blitz of 1940, but the show most impresses as a portrait of a city

Alfred Hickling

10, Sep, 2016 @9:00 PM

Article image
The week in theatre: Rock/ Paper/ Scissors; The Fellowship
Timing is everything in Chris Bush’s theatre-hopping trio of Sheffield plays; the same goes for Roy Williams’s ill-starred new Windrush generation drama

Susannah Clapp

03, Jul, 2022 @9:30 AM

Article image
The Band Plays On review – a celebration of songs forged in Sheffield
Chris Bush’s community play uses local music and family histories to explore the city’s resilience, hope and determination

Mark Fisher

16, Mar, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
The Boy Who Cried Wolf – review

Tutti Frutti's charming new take on Aesop's fable celebrates storytelling, families and quality knitwear, writes Lyn Gardner

Lyn Gardner

19, Dec, 2013 @4:31 PM

Article image
Anna Karenina review – Tolstoy meets Baz Luhrmann in a magnificent spectacle
With hula hoops and giant birthday cake, this show bashes the narrative with disco glitz, but keeps Anna’s tragic journey right at its centre

Nick Ahad

11, Feb, 2022 @10:42 AM

Article image
Sheffield Theatres 'fighting for our future' with 29% of roles at risk
The organisation – which comprises the Lyceum, Studio and Crucible theatres – will not fully reopen until spring 2021

Chris Wiegand

21, Jul, 2020 @4:43 PM

Article image
Steel review – sharp-witted political drama from Chris Bush
Bush tackles sexism and racial prejudice in a cross-generational commentary on contemporary politics

Catherine Love

18, Sep, 2018 @5:20 PM