Cancelling Socrates review – Howard Brenton interrogates democracy in a rich play of ideas

Jermyn Street theatre, London
Fine acting and lively dialogue save this philosophical play from feeling static as it applies Athenian ideals to modern dilemmas

Howard Brenton’s play about the last days of Athenian philosopher and gadfly Socrates comes at a moment when playwrights seem increasingly to be seeking out the parallels between the ancient Greek world and our own upset modern society.

Featuring a convincingly otherworldly Socrates in Jonathan Hyde, this is a rich play of ideas, elegantly directed by Tom Littler, and following in the tradition of Plato’s dialogues to give us some fine examples of the Socratic method.

There are question-and-answer discussions on meaty subjects around the unexamined life, the clash of old and new orders and the ideal of democracy in principle, along with its failures in practice. Brenton’s script combines the ancient and modern so well that everyday profanities sit next to talk of slaves (ever so subtly ironised) and big philosophical ideas to create sparky, bathetic moments.

Socrates is condemned to death by a jury for sacrilege and rationalism, essentially, in his questioning of the gods. The people, led by a young upstart, have strains of intolerance, and cleave to “certain” values above Socrates’ questioning in clear, clever parallels to today.

Sophie Ward, Robert Mountford, Jonathan Hyde and Hannah Morrish in Cancelling Socrates.
Sophie Ward, Robert Mountford, Jonathan Hyde and Hannah Morrish in Cancelling Socrates. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

It is an accomplishment for a play whose action comes in philosophical discussion and in which dramatic speeches are only ever reported, that it does not feel static or sleepy. Isabella van Braeckel’s set is striking in its minimalism (a few pillars, a wall frieze). William Reynolds’ lighting is exquisite; and sound designer Max Pappenheim, who is also a classicist, writes a great mini-essay on ancient Athenian society in the playtext, too.

What drama there is alongside the ideas feels arresting, fiercely intelligent and full of risk but not satisfyingly complete – like scenes from a play rather than a play itself. Although we believe in Socrates as a philosopher, we never quite believe in him as a man choosing death on principle, over family, children and life. He walks towards his end, blithely philosophising, right until the cup of hemlock touches his lips and even afterwards as he wavers between life and death.

There is, though, some very fine acting that brings the ideas to life and plays the comic lines perfectly. Socrates’ fellow Athenian, Euthyphro, is played by Robert Mountford as a pompous religious stickler. Doubling up as the “gaoler”, Mountford is so good in both roles that he near enough upstages the lead.

There are also the women in Socrates’ life – the mistress, Aspasia (Sophie Ward) in a face-off with the wife, Xanthippe (Hannah Morrish) – who are so fascinating you wish for greater focus on them. Surely Aspasia, an influential thinker in this male-dominated space, deserves a play of her own? Their fight for the love of the same man is turned into a heated debate on family versus public life, which never entirely convinces but is fascinating nonetheless.

At times, the modern world, and its terms, seem too obviously grafted on, even in Socrates’ titular “cancellation”: his is a death sentence that does not amount to the same thing as social media “cancellation” at all (or was Jesus cancelled, too, and the likes of Galileo?). So too, the talk of Socrates as a dinner-party-throwing elite figure and “the great unwashed” who condemn him and who are clearly today’s populists.

It is ultimately its discussion on democratic rule that brings the most depth and complexity: Socrates finds himself interrogating his belief in the rightness of the majority vote, and as questions around the ancient Athenian democratic process hang in the air, the unspoken spectre of the Brexit referendum is there alongside them.


Arifa Akbar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cancelling Socrates: how the great philosopher sealed his fate with comedy
Playwright Howard Brenton asks why ancient Athens turned on its famous citizen, and how such an uncompromising free-thinker might fare in our own ‘age of rage’

Howard Brenton

26, May, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Blinding Light review – Howard Brenton imagines Strindberg's inferno
The Swedish dramatist’s life is shown to echo his plays in a new production about his obsession with alchemy and his relationships with three women

Michael Billington

13, Sep, 2017 @12:51 PM

Article image
Forgotten plays: No 4 – Bloody Poetry (1984) by Howard Brenton
This magnificently honest play about the Shelleys and Byron’s summer of sexual experimentation raises difficult questions about the cost of utopian aspirations

Michael Billington

22, Jun, 2020 @8:03 AM

Article image
Lawrence After Arabia review – Howard Brenton on a tortured war hero
Why did TE Lawrence turn his back on fame after assisting the Arab uprising? Brenton’s solidly acted play explores the mystery of a troubled figure

Michael Billington

06, May, 2016 @10:55 AM

Article image
Miss Julie review – passion and pain of Strindberg's midsummer lovers
Howard Brenton’s new adaptation of the Swedish master’s tragedy is given a classy staging that strikes the right note of intimate realism

Michael Billington

16, Nov, 2017 @11:52 AM

Article image
Creditors review – Strindberg lays bare the self-pitying male psyche
Howard Brenton’s no-nonsense translation of Strindberg’s astute drama charts the marriage of a failed artist and his more successful wife

Mark Fisher

01, Apr, 2019 @8:00 AM

Leader: In praise of ... Howard Brenton

Leader: Stamina and resilience are vital qualities in any dramatist; and Howard Brenton has them in spades


29, Mar, 2008 @12:17 AM

Article image
Howard Brenton, playwright – portrait of the artist

'Playwrights are no wiser than anyone else – but people start asking you about the economy'

Laura Barnett

02, Jul, 2013 @6:00 PM

Article image
Jude review – Hardy's hero becomes a Syrian refugee in Howard Brenton's reworking
Brenton’s ambitious but muddled new drama follows a gifted young Syrian woman who attracts the attentions of an Oxford classicist, Euripides and MI5

Michael Billington

05, May, 2019 @10:26 AM

Article image
Doctor Scroggy’s War review – Howard Brenton explores horror of combat
Fact and fiction are intertwined in an affecting drama about a first-world-war soldier’s treatment by the pioneering plastic surgeon Harold Gillies, writes Michael Billington

Michael Billington

18, Sep, 2014 @11:34 AM