The Magician’s Elephant review – a puppet you’ll never forget

Royal Shakespeare Theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon
It is spirited and witty, with superb puppetry and comedic performances, but this new musical’s songs don’t stay with you and the messages are overdone

The tusked star of Kate DiCamillo’s novel The Magician’s Elephant arrives, like Dumbo, from the skies. This elephant falls not into a travelling circus, but an opera house in the city of Baltese and her arrival lifts the spirits of its war-weary inhabitants. Now this musical adaptation, directed by Sarah Tipple, lands at the Royal Shakespeare Theatre to welcome back audiences for the first time since it closed last March.

The musical was programmed before the pandemic but its storyline of collective grief, recovery and reconnection chimes with our current moment. And who doesn’t love an elephant? Puppetry director Mervyn Millar and fellow designer Tracy Waller have created a beauty who, controlled by three puppeteers inside, tickles bottoms with her trunk, flaps her ears and instantly delights the half-term audience at this matinee.

The elephant’s arrival links the lives of orphan Peter, desperate to solve the mystery of his sister; Peter’s guardian, Vilna, who is training the boy to be a soldier not a dreamer; Countess Quintet, furious she’s no longer the centre of attention; and Leo, a policeman with the soul of a poet. The slight plot of the novel has had a minor tinker and, over 145 minutes, the characterisation remains as thin as much of it is in the original. The key role of Madam LaVaughn, the noblewoman crushed by the elephant, is reduced to only a few lines.

Miriam Nyarko (Adele) and Summer Strallen (Countess Quintet) in The Magician’s Elephant.
Miriam Nyarko (Adele) and Summer Strallen (Countess Quintet) in The Magician’s Elephant. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

In their adaptation, Nancy Harris (book and lyrics) and Marc Teitler (music and lyrics) wisely build up three comedic roles. Forbes Masson is criminally funny as an exasperated police chief whose truncheon is filled with booze. Miriam Nyarko, triumph in the RSC’s The Boy in the Dress, is again superb as spirited orphan Adele, given much greater agency than in the novel. And playing the narrator, Amy Booth-Steel is as genial as she was dastardly in the National Theatre’s panto Dick Whittington, performing with the same glint in her eye and spring in her step, frequently winking to the audience.

There is witty rhyming in the songs, too. Guilty As Charged finds Masson desperately trying to pin a crime on the elephant and The Count Who Doesn’t Count is a lament from Countess Quintet’s overshadowed other half, who has “a title no one reads”. Jack Wolfe as Peter delivers an enchanting ballad, A Lot Like Me, but few of the melodies stay with you and the show’s liveliest sequences are dampened by a moralising, over-sentimental air that slows down the episodes in between. Even the upturning of a dung bucket isn’t as joyously anarchic as it could be. Sometimes, to paraphrase the RSC’s own Matilda, you have to be a little bit naughtier.

The Magician’s Elephant, designed by Colin Richmond.
The Magician’s Elephant, designed by Colin Richmond. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

It’s a brave Christmas show that uses colours this cold and dark, but designer Colin Richmond’s elephantine palette of greys and ivory captures dreary Baltese days. His set’s concentric arches give us an impression of being beneath an elephant, or even inside its trunk, and as the Countess, Summer Strallen’s black-and-white gowns align her with fellow animal-hater Cruella de Vil.

Harris and Teitler raise a broad range of issues, pertinently exploring how the elephant is exploited by and divides the community, yet the overwrought messages about achieving the impossible begin to feel forgettable. But the elephant herself, heroically powered by Zoe Halliday, Wela Mbusi and Suzanne Nixon, is one to remember.


Chris Wiegand

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
My Neighbour Totoro review – dazzling staging of the Studio Ghibli classic
The Royal Shakespeare Company’s production has astonishing puppetry, magical music and huge emotional impact

Arifa Akbar

19, Oct, 2022 @7:34 AM

Article image
Muppet power! RSC uses puppet legends for My Neighbour Totoro staging
The RSC’s version of the Japanese classic has smashed box office records – before the curtain’s even gone up. We meet the Jim Henson puppeteers bringing Studio Ghibli’s beloved fluffy monsters to life

Chris Wiegand

28, Jun, 2022 @1:39 PM

Article image
Mr Popper's Penguins review – retro charm and comical puppets skid along merrily
The Lowry, Salford
Pins and Needles, who admirably adapted Raymond Briggs, return with a musical revival of the 30s children’s story that’s lightweight but heartwarming

Lyn Gardner

05, Jan, 2016 @12:17 PM

Article image
Ugly Duckling review – feathers fly in a plucky take on Andersen classic
The set is captivating and the standout moments are performed with swagger by Tutti Frutti, yet the heart of Hans Christian Andersen’s story feels lost

Miriam Gillinson

23, Dec, 2017 @12:00 AM

Article image
Captain Flinn and the Pirate Dinosaurs: The Magic Cutlass review – timber-shivering fun
This musical for over-threes adapted from the eponymous picturebooks comes with delightful puppets and lashings of puns

Chris Wiegand

07, Aug, 2019 @2:52 PM

Article image
Animal Farm review – beguiling puppetry makes Orwell’s fable more equal than others
A startling handsome production of George Orwell’s allegorical fable, with hints of kabuki and film noir, is given ever more meaning and relevance by current news events

Arifa Akbar

27, Feb, 2022 @11:32 AM

Article image
Babe, the Sheep-Pig review – puppet porker's farmyard caper
This Dick King-Smith adaptation is a bit unsteady on its trotters but its merriment has some of the audience bouncing in their seats

Miriam Gillinson

08, Dec, 2016 @3:09 PM

Article image
Chester Tuffnut review – woodland puppet drama for little adventurers
This children’s show is boosted by a beautiful set design and imaginatively realised creatures, including a couple of sock-snails

Miriam Gillinson

27, Jun, 2016 @12:36 PM

Article image
The Little Gardener review – kids dig this greenhouse puppet show
There’s not much story to speak of, but this play based on Emily Hughes’s picturebook offers the young crowd the chance to get their hands dirty

Miriam Gillinson

09, Jun, 2016 @3:19 PM

Article image
The best family theatre for Christmas 2019
An exciting new adventure for Tiny Tim, a penguin chick with two daddies and a furry green grouch’s plot to steal Christmas are among the jolliest shows to unwrap this festive season

Chris Wiegand

23, Oct, 2019 @3:21 PM