The Band Plays On review – a celebration of songs forged in Sheffield

Available online
Chris Bush’s community play uses local music and family histories to explore the city’s resilience, hope and determination

It begins, as a show about Sheffield only could, with I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor. Less frenetic than the Arctic Monkeys original, it nonetheless has its own soulful swagger and, complete with swinging Top of the Pops camera angles and rock’n’roll lighting, kicks off Chris Bush’s play with a rush of celebratory energy.

Sheffield-forged songs by Def Leppard, Moloko and Slow Club follow. Under the music supervision of Will Stuart, they borrow American styles from funk to country and are given forceful renditions by Anna-Jane Casey, Maimuna Memon, Sandra Marvin, Jocasta Almgill and Jodie Prenger. After hearing them soar their way through Don’t Let Him Waste Your Time, you could believe Jarvis Cocker was a master of the sultry soul ballad.

As every reader of John McGrath’s A Good Night Out knows, you can’t beat a rousing song to sweeten a bitter political pill. Here, the music serves to raise the temperature in between a series of monologues that sink deep into Sheffield’s industrial past.

Through the imagined voices of modern-day residents, Bush references everything from the nuclear nightmare of Barry Hines’s Threads to the election of David Blunkett. We get the Hillsborough disaster and the people’s republic of South Yorkshire. She recalls pioneers such as the Sheffield Female Political Association, the UK’s first women’s suffrage body, and Sheffield FC, the world’s first football club.

Directed by Robert Hastie and Anthony Lau, the stories become testaments to resilience, survival and change. In her family histories, Bush shows each generation being shaped by its environment, be that the paranoia of the cold war, the liberalism of Nick Clegg or the divisions of Brexit. However contradictory, these are the strands that make up a community.

What a shame then that the one thing absent is the audience. In a necessarily empty Crucible theatre, The Band Plays On is a community play in search of a community. There’s nobody there to square the circle between stage and auditorium, to acknowledge the joy of being together, of sharing a common space. It’s not just the lack of laughter for Bush’s jokes and the eerie silence at the curtain call, it’s that a play about civic identity needs people to make it complete.


Mark Fisher

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Standing at the Sky’s Edge review – Richard Hawley's ode to Sheffield estate
This across-the-decades Park Hill musical is cleverly staged, moving through idealism, dilapidation and gentrification

Catherine Love

21, Mar, 2019 @11:11 AM

Article image
20 Tiny Plays About Sheffield – review
Shifting focus and a fluid, 60-strong cast are the making and undoing of Sheffield People's Theatre's evocative new piece, writes Clare Brennan

Clare Brennan

13, Apr, 2013 @11:05 PM

Article image
'Richard Hawley gets it!' Park Hill residents praise Sheffield musical
The giant housing estate has seen highs and endured lows, as captured in the new show Standing at the Sky’s Edge, which has impressed those who know the place best

Ammar Kalia

15, Mar, 2019 @3:54 PM

Article image
Operation Crucible review – Sheffield steals the show in lively wartime tale
The cast offer a high-spirited depiction of male camaraderie in this play about the Sheffield blitz of 1940, but the show most impresses as a portrait of a city

Alfred Hickling

10, Sep, 2016 @9:00 PM

Article image
Sheffield stars: local lives are at the heart of Yorkshire's theatre
This summer, community-led shows are encouraging residents to tell their own tales of loss, love and Bruce Springsteen gigs

Catherine Love

16, Jul, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Sheffield Theatres 'fighting for our future' with 29% of roles at risk
The organisation – which comprises the Lyceum, Studio and Crucible theatres – will not fully reopen until spring 2021

Chris Wiegand

21, Jul, 2020 @4:43 PM

Article image
Sheffield wins approval for its music-for-all in schools plans

The city's new Music Education Hub has still to prove itself, but £1,800,000 and 'good practice' commendation from Arts Council England bode well

Martin Wainwright

14, May, 2012 @1:11 PM

Article image
Richard Hawley writes musical about Sheffield's Park Hill estate
Standing at the Sky’s Edge, which features old and new songs by the musician, will be performed at the city’s Crucible theatre

Chris Wiegand

02, Mar, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
Rock/Paper/Scissors review – sharp-edged trilogy celebrates a city in flux
Sheffield Theatres
Chris Bush’s audacious production, performed simultaneously by the same cast across three theatres, intertwines comedy, romance and political rage to dazzling effect

Mark Fisher

23, Jun, 2022 @10:35 AM

Article image
Make ’em laugh? Serial killers, suicide and now a Sheffield estate are the grit of musicals | Stephanie Merritt
Richard Hawley’s plan to tell the story of Park Hill estate in song and dance shows how the genre is changing

Stephanie Merritt

04, Mar, 2018 @12:02 AM