Duchess! Duchess! Duchess! review – Meghan inspires explosive drama

Available online
In Steppenwolf theatre company’s creepy satire on palace life, two women have an intense teatime meeting

It is tempting to assume that an American drama about black women caught in the cold, hard machinery of Britain’s monarchy is a direct response to Meghan’s revelations to Oprah Winfrey earlier this week.

But theatre cannot move quite this fast and even though Vivian JO Barnes’ two-hander was inspired by the duchesses of Sussex and Cambridge, she conceived it in 2018 and it was filmed by Steppenwolf theatre at the end of last year.

The marketing gods, however, could not have aligned the stars for a greater impact for the digital premiere of a play billed as “a darker version of what might have happened if Meghan Markle had stayed”. That line gestures towards the surreal, satirical and incrementally creepy tone of this 35-minute dualogue.

Staged as a teatime meeting between The Duchess (Sydney Charles) and The Soon-to-be-Duchess (Celeste M Cooper), and directed by Weyni Mengesha, the couple’s exchanges seem deliberately wooden and gather sinister undertones that climax in the grotesque act of the final moments. The Duchess is already grounded in the ways of the institution and performing royal duties and has recently given birth (“I’m leaking”). She is meeting the Soon-to-be-Duchess in order to educate her in palace protocols for women – and black women – entering into royalty.

Watch an interview with the playwright Vivian JO Barnes

The Duchess seems more automaton than human – a regal version of a Stepford wife, lobotomised by institutional protocols, although sad vestiges of her former self remain.

“Pretend you’re not here,” is her advice in the event of being surrounded by paparazzi. “Say to yourself … ‘They are not doing this to me.’” The Soon-to-be-Duchess, by contrast, is bright-eyed and bursting with character. She hopes to tear down the palace’s icy traditions, though we begin to wonder how long it will take for her vivacity to be leached – or forcibly extracted. The actors add disturbing little flourishes to their performances and even when the script loses its subtlety, a greater sense of confusion and dread remains.

The Duchess reads out one palace memo that commands her never to wear green because it is not “becoming” on her. Another bears blatant suggestions of colourism that says she must endeavour to behave in a way that is “a little less cocoa” and “more beige”. The Soon-to-be-Duchess admits she does not know how to curtsy and wants to skip the formal gesture but is told that she must do so at all times, even in a meeting as informal as this one. These moments of satire gain an almost incredible prescience in their critiques on race and female submission in relation to the British monarchy.

Of course it is all just fiction, but it might be seen as a kind of bellwether as to how Americans perceived the British royal family long before Meghan’s revelations. The drama is the fourth in the six-part Steppenwolf Now virtual programming series, which brings together an array of dramatic forms and genres, from an engrossing two-part audio soap opera, Wally World, set in a department store and written by Isaac Gómez, to a thoughtfully angsty animation, Red Folder, written, directed and illustrated by Rajiv Joseph. The series, performed by the Chicago theatre’s ensemble, is well worth watching, and not just for its latest bombshell instalment.


Arifa Akbar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Incidental Moments of the Day review – a feast for Covid historians
In Richard Nelson’s third play about a US white liberal family Zooming through the pandemic, the Apples are forced to confront whether they are racist

Mark Lawson

13, Sep, 2020 @2:17 PM

Article image
'Dazzling' drama about race wins prize for Jackie Sibblies Drury
US dramatist wins Susan Smith Blackburn prize for female playwrights with Fairview, beating dramas by debbie tucker green and Ella Hickson

Chris Wiegand

04, Mar, 2019 @8:00 PM

Article image
Hugh Grant defends Prince Harry: 'The tabloids effectively murdered his mother'
The actor and activist has backed up Harry’s desire to ‘protect his family’, while Stormzy has said there is no ‘credible’ reason to dislike Meghan

Catherine Shoard

15, Jan, 2020 @12:08 PM

Article image
Meghan Marvel: which superhero should the duchess play?
A princess seeking revenge after her royal privileges are revoked? A drifter trying to get away from her awful father? Or maybe a guardian of Captain Britain?

Stuart Heritage

02, Mar, 2020 @12:32 PM

Article image
Br’er Cotton review – bold, hilarious drama in age of Black Lives Matter
A militant teenager grapples with politics and older relatives in Tearrance Arvelle Chisholm’s profound, beautifully staged play

Bridget Minamore

13, Mar, 2018 @4:30 PM

Article image
Duke and Duchess of Sussex to give to race and mental health charities
Announcement of donations follows Meghan’s claim she did not get help with mental health from palace

Molly Blackall

13, Mar, 2021 @7:39 PM

Article image
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex speaks out over George Floyd killing
In graduation address for her old high school, Meghan says ‘only wrong thing to say is nothing’

Caroline Davies

04, Jun, 2020 @8:06 AM

Article image
Carol Channing, star of Hello, Dolly! on Broadway, dies aged 97
Celebrated for her performances in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes and Hello, Dolly! Channing also earned an Oscar nomination for Thoroughly Modern Millie

Chris Wiegand

15, Jan, 2019 @12:31 PM

Article image
Ivo van Hove to 'bring West Side Story into the 21st century'
Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker will collaborate with the director on first Broadway version not to follow original choreography

Chris Wiegand

13, Jul, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Helen Mirren's regal turn in The Audience commands rave reviews
Following her Olivier award-winning performance as Elizabeth II, Helen Mirren is now playing the Queen on Broadway

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

09, Mar, 2015 @1:30 PM