The Play What I Wrote review – Tom Hiddleston has a laugh in farce masterclass

Birmingham Repertory theatre
The A-lister provided joyous shock on opening night, as Morecambe and Wise’s screen routines return to the boards

Regularly drawing TV audiences in the 1970s that would these days be attainable only by royal funerals or England World Cup penalty shootouts, The Morecambe & Wise Show used the conceit of pretending the studio was a theatre. A gold curtain opened on to sketches that often spoofed stage musicals.

Reversing the image, Hamish McColl and Sean Foley’s The Play What I Wrote, a West End and Broadway hit 20 years ago, returns Eric and Ernie’s screen routines to the boards. The premise is that a failing comic double act – played by Dennis Herdman and Thom Tuck, replacing the original’s McColl and Foley – lands a gig as a Morecambe & Wise tribute show; the second half is a full meticulous pastiche of the finale of a Christmas special.

Much material comes from the scripts by Eddie Braben, the brilliant scriptwriter who reimagined the comedians as a platonic married couple sharing a flat and a bed. Crucially, though, McColl and Foley can write new topical lines in perfect imitation of Braben; he would have loved the pun involving two tennis stars and a famous American play.

Dennis Herdman, Tom Hiddleston and Thom Tuck.
Startling slapstick ... Dennis Herdman, Tom Hiddleston and Thom Tuck. Photograph: Geraint Lewis

This revival is directed by Foley, a master of farce. At startling but comprehensible speed, wordplay, sight gags and slapstick constantly compete to top each other. The avalanche of laughs spans trick arms and legs, joke bread loaves, botched magic tricks and, hardest of all to replicate, the most sublime of Braben’s running gags. That involved classical actors – Glenda Jackson, Diana Rigg, Michael Redgrave – inveigled into delivering the anti-syntactical, arrhythmic lines of the plays “what” Ernie wrote.

A variety of famous faces will feature across the play’s run, but the production began with the joke at its absolute purest. Tom Hiddleston – the joyous shock of the audience that it was genuinely him filling the theatre – spoke the cod-French tosh of the revolutionary epic A Tight Squeeze for the Scarlet Pimple as if he were still giving his Coriolanus (an entry on the actor’s CV that the script isn’t going to miss). Hiddleston’s vocal double-takes at what he finds himself saying, rank with those of Dame Glenda in the 1972 Christmas show; he also gets double entendres the BBC would surely have refused to let Braben use. As Hiddleston presumably has other things to do than guest star every night, it was good to see his perfect comic turn being filmed for future use.

In the first night audience, I was intrigued to spot another significant star, collar high and baseball cap low, who Birmingham may presumably see at some point. But, regardless of the guest, the constant central trio is worth the ticket. Herdman and Tuck beautifully meet the need to inhabit the spirit of Eric (gangly irascibility) and Ernie (gentle self-delusion) without impersonating them. Mitesh Soni offers a glorious crowd of cameos, including Hollywood legends, the alleged producer of The Play What I Wrote, a menacing dog, a musician suffering harmonica interrupts and at one point a whole village.

Laughing so long and so loudly felt as energising and cleansing as going to the gym after a spell of vegetating. This show is the perfect therapeutic humour for these seriously unfunny times.

• At Birmingham Rep until 1 January.


Mark Lawson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tom Hiddleston to play Coriolanus at Donmar Warehouse

Star of War Horse and Thor will play opposite Mark Gatiss in Shakespeare tragedy, which he calls 'play for our time'

Maev Kennedy

20, May, 2013 @1:53 PM

Article image
Betrayal review – Hiddleston is superb in haunting drama of deception
Tom Hiddleston conveys unhealed emotional wounds in Jamie Lloyd’s production of Harold Pinter’s play

Michael Billington

14, Mar, 2019 @12:26 AM

Article image
‘Roger Moore collapsed one night. I thought he’d died’: how we made The Play What I Wrote
‘Ralph Fiennes strode into the dressing room and said he loved the show – we booked him there and then. The whole thing was very kick-bollocks-scramble’

Interviews by Andrew Dickson

22, Nov, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
East Is East review – magnificent revival of culture-clash classic
Ayub Khan Din’s comedy still resonates in its depiction of a hostile environment – Salford in the 70s – while its sharp wit and warm characterisations are exhilarating

Arifa Akbar

13, Sep, 2021 @8:19 AM

Article image
Rebus: Long Shadows review – Ian Rankin's sleuth fails to arrest
Charles Lawson is on fine form as a retired John Rebus but the novelist’s Edinburgh underworld is missing

Michael Billington

26, Sep, 2018 @12:08 PM

Article image
What’s New Pussycat? review – high-voltage collision of two Tom Joneses
The 18th-century novel and Welsh crooner meet on 1960s Carnaby Street in a spirited jukebox musical

Arifa Akbar

20, Oct, 2021 @12:10 PM

Article image
Tom Hiddleston to star in Branagh's Hamlet – for three weeks only
Ballot opens at noon to buy tickets for Rada-fundraising show to be held in tiny 160-seat theatre in September

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

01, Aug, 2017 @10:40 AM

Article image
Tom Hiddleston plays Hamlet in London – but you won't get a ticket
Three-week run at 160-seat theatre will raise money for drama school, with tickets given out by lottery system – now closed

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

01, Sep, 2017 @2:17 PM

Article image
Birmingham Rep may make 40% of roles redundant amid Covid-19 crisis
Despite emergency support funds, cuts may be needed for theatre to survive loss of income during coronavirus closure

Chris Wiegand

10, Jul, 2020 @3:50 PM

Article image
Floella Benjamin’s childhood memoir to become stage play
Birmingham Rep says premiere of Coming to England will be highlight of forthcoming season

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

20, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM