Educating Rita; The Comedy of Errors review – a breath of fresh air

Minack theatre, Porthcurno, Cornwall; Grosvenor Park Open Air theatre, Chester
An unflappable duo braved the elements in Willy Russell’s comedy drama, while Shakespeare’s crowd-pleaser cheered a lockdown-weary audience

Arriving at the Minack theatre, I am more than thrilled to be back at a live performance, but less than sure that this particular play will work here. Educating Rita is set in a northern, redbrick university – specifically, in the stuffy office of an English lecturer-cum-erstwhile minor poet. This open-air amphitheatre clings to a Cornish cliffside, a wide, blue horizon stretches beyond its wind-scoured stage.

Isn’t Willy Russell’s 1980 hit comedy better suited to a venue such as Keswick’s Theatre by the Lake, where this production opened last year, under Max Roberts’s direction? The contrast between this site and the fiction is as great as… well, as the contrast between the erudite, irascible Frank and his new, eager mature student, Rita, a hairdresser with no qualifications enthusiastically embarking on an Open University course.

Enter Frank: long, wispy hair, lashing across his face, hinders his search for the whisky bottle hidden on his bookshelves. Frantically fluttering papers threaten to fly from his desk; he grabs at glass weights to hold them down. Rita blows in, makes to take off her coat: a gust almost rips it from her back. Stephen Tompkinson and Jessica Johnson respond deftly to such unpredictabilities, cleverly adapting them to their characterisations.

Tompkinson uses the wind’s buffetings to intensify our impression that Frank is flailing desperately to take control of his job, his love life and his drinking; that, as a poet, he is trapped under the weight of his own defeated expectations. Taking a tight grip on her coat, Johnson guides it along the air current and loops it firmly on to a hook, her gesture emphasising Rita’s determination not to be dictated to by circumstances, to take charge of her life.

A gull swoops over the stage just as Rita is telling Frank that Chekhov’s The Seagull is a “dead sad” play. Before us, two people are making choices that limit or expand their horizons. This is, after all, a most appropriate setting.

Twins Lowri Izzard and Mari Izzard, Danielle Bird and Nichole Bird in The Comedy of Errors.
Twins Lowri Izzard and Mari Izzard, Danielle Bird and Nichole Bird in The Comedy of Errors. Photograph: PR Handout

The Minack was built on the 1930s dream of Rowena Cade. Chester’s Grosvenor Park theatre, which opened in 2010, is the dreamchild of Andrew Bentley and Alex Clifton and forerunner of the more permanent Storyhouse arts centre. The dreams of all three were realised because they connect with our aeons-old shared longing for the particular experience that is live performance – a magic merging of people, place and presentation. And Clifton’s pared-down production of Shakespeare’s The Comedy of Errors is shaped for an audience long deprived of conviviality by lockdown, a crowd-pleaser in the best sense of the term (miraculously, rehearsed over just four days).

An eight-strong cast brings a boisterous energy to the series of increasingly frenetic situations of mistaken identity set off by the arrival in Ephesus of Antipholus and his servant, Dromio. Unknown to them – or to anyone else – the city is home to each of their long-lost, identical siblings, also master and servant and also called Antipholus and Dromio. Making no pretence at a fourth wall, the performers share everything directly with the happily involved spectators, only concealing, until the final scene, the secret of the uncanny resemblances between the twin-pair actors. Great fun.

Although Educating Rita comes to the end of its run at the Minack today, producer David Pugh is aiming to take the production on a 40th anniversary tour. For updates, check here.

Star ratings (out of five)
Educating Rita ★★★★
The Comedy of Errors ★★★★


Clare Brennan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Educating Rita review – Lashana Lynch is ‘dazzlingly fresh’
Despite Lenny Henry’s first-night nerves, this Rita should graduate with distinction

Kate Kellaway

28, Jun, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Shirley Valentine; Educating Rita | Theatre review
Meera Syal impresses in a Willy Russell double bill, says Kate Kellaway

Kate Kellaway

10, Apr, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
The week in theatre: Women, Beware the Devil; Romeo and Julie; Shirley Valentine – review
Director Rupert Goold and co have a field day with Lulu Raczka’s elusive new Jacobean folk horror; star-crossed Cardiff teenagers snare hearts and minds; and Sheridan Smith makes Willy Russell’s midlife monologue her own

Susannah Clapp

05, Mar, 2023 @10:30 AM

Article image
Richard lll and The Comedy of Errors; Greenland | review

An unlikely pairing of Richard III and The Comedy of Errors pays off handsomely for all-male theatre company Propeller, writes Susannah Clapp

Susannah Clapp

06, Feb, 2011 @12:04 AM

Article image
The Comedy of Errors; The Heart of Robin Hood; Goodbye Barcelona – review
Lenny Henry makes his National Theatre debut in Dominic Cooke's enjoyably manic Comedy of Errors, while Robin Hood gets his tights in a twist at the RSC, writes Susannah Clapp

Susannah Clapp

04, Dec, 2011 @12:06 AM

Article image
The Comedy of Errors review – a descent into farce
Phillip Breen’s RSC romp lacks a feel for Shakespeare’s text and fails its female characters

Clare Brennan

01, Aug, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Comedy of Errors; Salome; Lift: Life Streaming | Theatre review
The Comedy of Errors, Shakespeare's timeless farce is given a fine reworking, while at the National, a radical form of theatre makes its challenging debut, writes Kate Kellaway

Kate Kellaway

03, Jul, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
The Comedy of Errors (more or less) review – funny, frenetic reimagining
Prescot is pitted against Scarborough – and women get their fair share of the limelight – in this engaging rewrite of Shakespeare’s comedy

Clare Brennan

12, Mar, 2023 @11:30 AM

Article image
Cymbeline review – thrown-together enthusiasm
There is something of the Edinburgh fringe about this RSC production

Clare Brennan

15, May, 2016 @6:59 AM

Article image
Othello review – sheer force of feeling
Powerful performances from fine young actors bring fresh power to this sensual, subtle reinvention

Susannah Clapp

26, Feb, 2017 @7:55 AM